Do General Practitioners in a Visiting Medical Officer Arrangement Improve the Perceived Quality of Care of Rural and Remote Patients? A Qualitative Study in Australia

I Nyoman Sutarsa, Rosny Kasim, Ben Albert Steward, Suzanne Bain‐Donohue, Claudia Slimings, Sally Hall Dykgraaf, Amanda S. BarnardHealthcare 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This qualitative study explores how General Practitioners working as Visiting Medical Officers (GP-VMOs) in rural and remote Australia impact patient-perceived quality of care. The findings suggest that GP-VMOs significantly enhance care by fostering continuity, building trust, and integrating services, ultimately improving patient satisfaction and outcomes in underserved areas.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rural and remote populations in Australia face significant health disparities, including shorter life expectancy and poorer access to healthcare compared to urban dwellers. This is largely due to shortages of healthcare professionals and their uneven distribution. While Visiting Medical Officer (VMO) arrangements, where General Practitioners (GPs) provide care in local hospitals, are a common strategy to address these gaps, there's limited understanding of how these GP-VMOs specifically influence the perceived quality of care from the patient's perspective. This study aims to fill that gap by investigating the roles GP-VMOs play in improving the quality of care and health outcomes for patients in these challenging environments.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative research design, utilizing in-depth interviews to gather rich data on the experiences and perceptions of both healthcare providers and patients.

  • Participants: The study included three GP-VMOs (all over 55 years old) and ten patients (all over 65 years old) from three rural and remote local health districts in New South Wales, Australia.
  • Data Collection: Thirteen in-depth interviews were conducted remotely (via Zoom or telephone) between October 2020 and February 2021. Interview guides were tailored for GP-VMOs and patients, covering topics such as experiences with care, perceived quality, and health outcomes.
  • Data Analysis: The collected interview data was transcribed and analyzed using thematic analysis. This involved identifying, categorizing, and reporting recurring themes within the data to understand the key roles of GP-VMOs. NVivo-11 software was used to aid in the analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on qualitative data collected through interviews with participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Continuity is King: The most striking insight is how crucial continuity of care is for rural and remote patients. GP-VMOs, by bridging primary and secondary care, ensure patients aren't lost in the system. This means a familiar doctor follows them from their GP surgery to the hospital and back, fostering a sense of security and consistent management.
  • Trust is Built, Not Given: Trust in rural healthcare isn't automatic; it's cultivated. Patients expressed that trust in GP-VMOs stems from their deep understanding of their medical history, social context, and personal lives. This familiarity, built over time through ongoing relationships, makes patients feel more confident and cared for, especially when dealing with complex health issues.
  • The "Local" Advantage: GP-VMOs who live in or near the communities they serve bring an invaluable local perspective. This social understanding, combined with their clinical expertise, allows them to navigate the local healthcare landscape more effectively and provide more responsive, patient-centered care.
  • Integrated Care is More Than Just Access: While access is a major issue, GP-VMOs contribute to a higher quality of integrated care. They act as a vital link between different healthcare services, ensuring smoother transitions and a more holistic approach to patient well-being.

Key Results

The study identified three primary perceived roles of GP-VMOs in improving the quality of care for rural and remote patients:

  1. Improving Continuity of Caring Relationships: Patients reported that GP-VMOs facilitated better communication across providers, improved understanding of their circumstances, and enhanced trust. This continuity allowed GPs to follow patients from primary care to hospital and back, creating better linkages and promoting integrated services.
  2. Cultivating Trust from Local Communities: Trust was found to be critical and developed over time through respectful, skillful interactions. Patients felt more confident when their GP understood their clinical conditions better than locums or fly-in/fly-out doctors, highlighting the importance of personal relationships and social understanding.
  3. Promoting Integrated Health Services and Patient Satisfaction: GP-VMOs' comprehensive knowledge and social understanding enabled them to provide rapid responses to health needs. Their involvement reduced the burden of travel for patients, allowed for family involvement, and improved mental well-being. Patients reported high satisfaction, especially when waiting times were shorter and outcomes were positive, often attributing this to the GP-VMO's familiarity and comprehensive approach.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Remote Interview Bias: Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, interviews were conducted remotely. This may have favored participants with better access to technology or higher socioeconomic status. Non-verbal cues, valuable in face-to-face interviews, were also missed.
  • Limited Participant Pool: The study only included GP-VMOs and patients. Perspectives from other healthcare staff and family members were not captured.
  • Small Sample Size: The small number of participants (3 GP-VMOs, 10 patients) limits the generalizability of the findings.
  • Demographic Skew: All interviewed GP-VMOs were male, and most patients were over 65. This means female perspectives and those of younger patients are not represented.
  • Further Analysis Needed: The authors suggest future research could explore the experiences of retired and unemployed patients separately, as their expectations for quality care might differ.

Future work could also include:

  • Social Return on Investment (SROI) Analysis: Quantifying the broader social, economic, and environmental value of employing GP-VMOs in rural areas.
  • Investigating Negative Consequences: Further exploring potential negative impacts, such as increased investigations or clinician workload stress.
  • Urban vs. Rural Comparison: Investigating whether dimensions of quality care differ between rural and urban settings to inform targeted improvement strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: In rural and remote Australia, general practitioners (GPs) provide care across the continuum from primary to secondary care, often in Visiting Medical Officer (VMO) arrangements with a local hospital. However, little is known about the role of GP-VMOs in improving the perceived quality of care and health outcomes for rural and remote communities. Methods: We collected qualitative data from three GP-VMOs (all aged >55 years) and 10 patients (all aged over 65 years) in three local health districts of New South Wales, Australia. Thirteen in-depth interviews were conducted between October 2020 and February 2021. We employed thematic analysis to identify key roles of GP-VMOs in improving the perceived quality of care and health outcomes of rural and remote patients. Results: Our study advances the current understanding regarding the role of GP-VMOs in improving the perceived quality of services and health outcomes of rural and remote patients. Key roles of GP-VMOs in improving the perceived quality of care include promoting the continuity of care and integrated health services, cultivating trust from local communities, and enhancing the satisfaction of patients. Conclusions: GP-VMOs work across primary and secondary care creating better linkages and promoting the continuity of care for rural and remote communities. Employing GP-VMOs in rural hospitals enables the knowledge and sensitivity gained from their ongoing interactions with patients in primary care to be effectively utilised in the delivery of hospital care.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sutarsa2022do,
  author = {I Nyoman Sutarsa and Rosny Kasim and Ben Albert Steward and Suzanne Bain‐Donohue and Claudia Slimings and Sally Hall Dykgraaf and Amanda S. Barnard},
  title = {{Do General Practitioners in a Visiting Medical Officer Arrangement Improve the Perceived Quality of Care of Rural and Remote Patients? A Qualitative Study in Australia}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare10061045},
}
Figure