Do endocrine and lipid responses to an ice bath depend on the time of day?

Alexander Braunsperger, Maximilian Bauer, Chaima Ben Brahim, Lea Seep, Dominik Tischer, Mirko Peitzsch, Jan Hasenauer, Sieglinde Hechenbichler Figuera, Anna Worthmann, Jöerg Heeren, Kenneth A. Dyar, Karsten Koehler, Ana Soriano‐Arroquia, Martin Schönfelder, Henning WackerhageResearch Square 2024 · DOI

Abstract

While the physiological effects of cold exposure are well-documented, the influence of circadian timing on these responses remains poorly understood. This crossover-designed study investigated whether the time of day (morning vs. evening) alters the endocrine and lipidomic reactions to a standardized ice bath. Twelve healthy participants (six men, six women) underwent a 5-minute ice bath (8–12°C) in both the morning and evening. Results showed that while both sessions triggered a similar, significant surge in plasma noradrenaline, a corresponding increase in plasma fatty acids occurred only after the morning session. These findings suggest that the lipolytic response to cold-induced noradrenaline is gated by the time of day, with morning exposure being more effective for mobilizing fatty acids.

Introduction

Cold exposure, popularized by methods such as "Wim Hof" ice baths and whole-body cryotherapy, is widely utilized for its potential benefits in metabolic health, recovery, and immune function. In other domains of physiology, such as nutrition and exercise, the timing of the stimulus (chrono-biology) is known to significantly alter the body's metabolic processing. However, it has remained unclear whether the metabolic "payoff" of an ice bath depends on when the plunge occurs. This study sought to determine if endocrine markers (noradrenaline, adrenaline, cortisol) and lipid profiles respond differently to cold stress in the morning versus the evening.

Materials and Methods

The researchers employed a rigorous crossover design involving 12 healthy, lean participants. To isolate the effect of time-of-day, the protocol included strict standardization: participants woke at 5:30 AM, abstained from alcohol and caffeine for 24 hours, and consumed standardized meals calculated by body weight.

Each participant completed two sessions: a morning session (8:00 AM) and an evening session (8:00 PM). The intervention consisted of a 5-minute ice bath (8–12°C), preceded by a brief low-intensity warm-up. Venous blood samples were collected at three intervals: baseline (pre-bath), 5 minutes post-bath, and 30 minutes post-bath. Beyond standard hormonal assays, the team utilized shotgun lipidomics to track 945 lipid species, eventually filtering the data to 305 robustly measured lipids for statistical modeling.

Results

Overview of the study design and key findings comparing morning and evening ice bath responses.

Hormonal Response

The study found that the "fight or flight" response to cold is largely independent of the clock. Noradrenaline levels spiked nearly identically in both sessions, with a 2.3-fold increase in the morning and a 2.4-fold increase in the evening (rising from ~390 pg/ml to ~900 pg/ml). Adrenaline and cortisol levels remained largely unaffected by the ice bath itself, though cortisol followed its natural circadian rhythm (higher in the morning).

Lipidomic Shifts

Despite the uniform noradrenaline surge, the metabolic outcome differed significantly by time of day. In the morning, the relative composition of free fatty acids in the plasma increased from 5.1% to 6.3% within 30 minutes of the bath. In contrast, the evening response was essentially flat. This indicates that noradrenaline-associated lipolysis—the breakdown of stored fats into the bloodstream—is significantly more active or "primed" during morning hours.

Individual and Sex Differences

Interestingly, no significant differences were observed between male and female participants regarding noradrenaline or lipidomic responses. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) further revealed that an individual's unique baseline lipid "fingerprint" accounted for more variance in the data than the timing of the ice bath, suggesting high inter-individual variability in how people respond to cold stress.

Discussion

The core finding of this research is that the body perceives cold stress equally at both times of day, but only the morning session translates that stress into significant fatty acid mobilization. This suggests a circadian gating of the lipolytic pathway. In the morning, the relationship between noradrenaline and lipids shifts from a correlation with complex fats (triglycerides) to a correlation with free fatty acids, signaling active fat breakdown.

While these results are promising for those using cold exposure for metabolic health, the study has limitations. The sample size of 12 is small, and the measurements were restricted to circulating blood markers. Future research involving tissue biopsies from white and brown adipose tissue, as well as direct measurements of energy expenditure (VO2), is needed to confirm if these acute blood-level changes translate to long-term fat loss or metabolic adaptation. For now, those looking to maximize the metabolic impact of their cold plunge may find the most benefit in a morning routine.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> While the effect of time-of-day (morning versus evening) has been studied in relation to meals and exercise, there are no studies that investigate the effects of time-of-day on an ice bath. In this crossover-designed study, we recruited a homogenous group of six women and six men for an ice bath (8–12°C for 5 min) in the morning and evening. Venous blood samples were collected before and after the ice baths. Both ice baths increased plasma noradrenaline levels similarly between women and men. Adrenaline and cortisol were not affected by any of the ice baths. Plasma lipid class composition differs in the morning versus the evening and only in the morning, ice bathing is accompanied by a significantly higher fatty acid composition. The increase of noradrenaline in response to the ice bath in the morning is consistent with higher plasma concentrations of fatty acids. This relationship suggests that the time-of-day affects noradrenaline-associated lipolysis induced by an ice bath. This time-of-day effect can be further attributed to interindividual plasma fatty acid responses to a morning ice bath. Apparently, morning ice baths increase plasma fatty acids via noradrenaline-associated lipolysis more than in the evening.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{braunsperger2024do,
  author = {Alexander Braunsperger and Maximilian Bauer and Chaima Ben Brahim and Lea Seep and Dominik Tischer and Mirko Peitzsch and Jan Hasenauer and Sieglinde Hechenbichler Figuera and Anna Worthmann and Jöerg Heeren and Kenneth A. Dyar and Karsten Koehler and Ana Soriano‐Arroquia and Martin Schönfelder and Henning Wackerhage},
  title = {{Do endocrine and lipid responses to an ice bath depend on the time of day?}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5053033/v1},
}
Figure