Abstract
China’s transition from fossil fuels to clean energy to attain environmental and economic co-sustainability necessitates changes in its energy policy landscape. Such policy shifts impact the confidence of both businesses and consumers. Building on this argument, this research article investigates the response of China’s business and consumer confidence towards energy-related uncertainty for the period February 2000 to October 2022. Utilizing a novel energy-related uncertainty measure and the quantile-on-quantile regression approach, the empirical analysis underscores that China’s business confidence is hostile towards energy-related uncertainty across all quantiles. The quantiles of consumer confidence mirror the outcomes of business confidence, recording the negative impact of energy-related uncertainty, except for a few quantiles. The empirical outcomes indicate that to augment business and consumer confidence, Chinese policymakers should strive to minimize energy-related uncertainty through transparent communication with stakeholders and a gradual shift from fossil fuels to clean energy sources.
Introduction
As the world's largest energy consumer, China is aggressively transitioning from fossil fuels to clean, renewable energy to meet climate goals. However, this transition requires frequent regulatory changes, shifting subsidies, and evolving market rules, which collectively generate "energy-related uncertainty" (EU). While previous macroeconomic research has heavily explored broad economic policy uncertainty, there is a distinct gap in understanding how specific energy-related volatility impacts the psychological and economic sentiments of businesses and consumers. This paper aims to quantify that relationship within the context of China's economy.
Methodology and Data
The study utilizes monthly data spanning from February 2000 to October 2022, incorporating Business Confidence (BC) and Consumer Confidence (CC) indices alongside a novel, text-based Energy-Related Uncertainty (EU) Index.
To address the non-normal and asymmetric behavior typical of financial time-series data, the authors employ a Quantile-on-Quantile (QQ) regression approach. Before modeling, the researchers utilized the BDS nonlinearity test to confirm the data's complex structure. As shown in Table 2, the test results were significant at the 1% level across all embedding dimensions, validating the choice of a non-linear QQ model over standard linear regressions.
Key Results and Discussion
The empirical analysis reveals that energy-related uncertainty is universally hostile to economic sentiment in China.
Business Confidence Hostility
Regardless of whether the economy is booming or busting, energy uncertainty makes businesses adopt a "wait-and-see" approach. They delay long-term, capital-intensive investments—ironically, the exact type of renewable infrastructure investments the government seeks to encourage—because the risk of changing regulations threatens their return on investment. The 3D QQ regression plots visually confirm this pervasive negative relationship across all quantiles.
Consumer Sentiment and the Green Paradox
Consumer confidence largely mirrors business confidence, dropping as energy uncertainty rises. Unclear energy policies signal future inflation and higher utility bills, prompting households to cut discretionary spending. This creates a "Green Transition Paradox": while transitioning to renewables ensures long-term stability, the process itself—if volatile and poorly communicated—can actively harm the economy in the short term by eroding the confidence required for growth.
Conclusion and Policy Implications
The findings highlight a critical need for transparent, stable policy communication during national energy transitions. To augment business and consumer confidence, Chinese policymakers should strive to minimize energy-related uncertainty through transparent communication with stakeholders and a gradual shift from fossil fuels to clean energy sources. Future research may benefit from a multivariate quantile-on-quantile (m-QQR) approach to integrate additional macroeconomic variables into this framework.
Summary updated