DNA methylation in Arabidopsis has a genetic basis and shows evidence of local adaptation

Manu Dubin, Pei Zhang, Dazhe Meng, Marie-Stanislas Remigereau, Edward J. Osborne, Francesco Paolo Casale, Philipp Drewe, André Kahles, Géraldine Jean, Bjarni J. Vilhjálmsson, Joanna Gunis, Selen Irez, Viktor Voronin, Qiang Song, Quan Long, Gunnar Rätsch, Oliver Stegle, Richard M. Clark, Magnus NordborgeLife 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Epigenome modulation in response to the environment potentially provides a mechanism for organisms to adapt, both within and between generations. However, neither the extent to which this occurs, nor the molecular mechanisms involved are known. Here we investigate DNA methylation variation in Swedish Arabidopsis thaliana accessions grown at two different temperatures. Environmental effects on DNA methylation were limited to transposons, where CHH methylation was found to increase with temperature. Genome-wide association mapping revealed that the extensive CHH methylation variation was strongly associated with genetic variants in both cis and trans, including a major trans-association close to the DNA methyltransferase CMT2. Unlike CHH methylation, CpG gene body methylation (GBM) on the coding region of genes was not affected by growth temperature, but was instead strongly correlated with the latitude of origin. Accessions from colder regions had higher levels of GBM for a significant fraction of the genome, and this was correlated with elevated transcription levels for the genes affected. Genome-wide association mapping revealed that this effect was largely due to trans-acting loci, a significant fraction of which showed evidence of local adaptation. These findings constitute the first direct link between DNA methylation and adaptation to the environment, and provide a basis for further dissecting how environmentally driven and genetically determined epigenetic variation interact and influence organismal fitness.

Introduction

The relationship between an organism's genetic "hardware" and its epigenetic "software" is a central question in evolutionary biology. DNA methylation—a chemical modification that regulates gene expression without altering the underlying DNA sequence—has long been proposed as a mechanism for rapid environmental adaptation. However, the scientific community has debated whether these modifications are merely transient responses to the environment or stable, genetically inherited traits shaped by natural selection.

This study analyzes Arabidopsis thaliana accessions across Sweden to untangle these factors. By examining how DNA methylation varies in response to both immediate temperature changes and the plant's geographic origin, the researchers aimed to determine the extent to which the epigenome is hard-coded by genetics to facilitate local adaptation.

Methods

The research team conducted a "common garden" experiment, growing 150 distinct Swedish Arabidopsis accessions under two controlled temperature settings: 10°C and 16°C. This approach allowed the researchers to isolate environmental plasticity from underlying genetic variation.

Key methodologies included:

  • Whole-Genome Bisulfite Sequencing (BS-seq): To map methylated cytosines across the genome at single-base resolution.
  • RNA-seq: To measure the correlation between methylation patterns and gene expression levels.
  • Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS): Treating methylation levels at specific regions as quantitative phenotypes to identify controlling genetic loci (SNPs).
  • Variance Component Analysis: Utilizing the LIMIX framework to partition variation into environmental, cis-genetic (local), and trans-genetic (distant) influences.

Validation was further supported by analyzing F2 cross populations and specific knockout lines (e.g., cmt2, dcl3) to confirm the functional roles of specific genes.

Key Insights and Results

Temperature-Sensitive CHH Methylation

The study found that immediate environmental effects were highly specific. CHH methylation on transposable elements (TEs) increased by an average of 14% at 16°C compared to 10°C. This suggests that the RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) pathway, which silences "jumping genes," becomes more active as temperatures rise.

GWAS revealed that a single gene, CMT2 (chromo-methylase-3), acts as a major trans-acting regulator of this CHH variation. Interestingly, natural "null" mutations of CMT2 were found in northern Swedish populations, leading to significantly lower CHH methylation levels in those plants.

Latitudinal Adaptation and Gene Body Methylation

While CHH methylation responded to temperature, CpG gene body methylation (GBM)—methylation within the coding regions of genes—was primarily influenced by the plant's origin. There was a strong positive correlation (Pearson’s r = 0.70) between CG methylation and the latitude of origin. Accessions from colder, northern regions exhibited approximately 11% higher global CG methylation than southern accessions.

This phenomenon, termed "epigenetic temperature compensation," suggests that northern plants have genetically "locked in" higher gene expression via methylation. This likely serves to compensate for the slower metabolic rates typical of cold climates, as higher GBM levels were found to correlate with increased transcription.

Evidence of Selection

The researchers identified 10,812 distinct differentially methylated regions (DMRs). For GBM, 69% of the genetic associations were in trans, driven by 15 SNPs found almost exclusively in northern populations. These variants overlap with "selective sweeps"—genomic regions where natural selection has favored specific traits—providing robust evidence that these epigenetic patterns are adaptive.

Discussion and Future Work

This study establishes the first direct link between DNA methylation and local environmental adaptation in Arabidopsis. It demonstrates that much of the observed epigenetic variation is not random noise but is genetically determined and shaped by natural selection.

However, the causal relationship between methylation and expression remains a subject for future inquiry: does methylation drive higher expression, or does high expression attract methylation? Future research will focus on the functional validation of the 15 trans-acting SNPs and field experiments to confirm the survival advantages provided by these specific methylation profiles in extreme northern environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Epigenome modulation potentially provides a mechanism for organisms to adapt, within and between generations. However, neither the extent to which this occurs, nor the mechanisms involved are known. Here we investigate DNA methylation variation in Swedish Arabidopsis thaliana accessions grown at two different temperatures. Environmental effects were limited to transposons, where CHH methylation was found to increase with temperature. Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) revealed that the extensive CHH methylation variation was strongly associated with genetic variants in both cis and trans, including a major trans-association close to the DNA methyltransferase CMT2. Unlike CHH methylation, CpG gene body methylation (GBM) was not affected by growth temperature, but was instead correlated with the latitude of origin. Accessions from colder regions had higher levels of GBM for a significant fraction of the genome, and this was associated with increased transcription for the genes affected. GWAS revealed that this effect was largely due to trans-acting loci, many of which showed evidence of local adaptation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dubin2015dna,
  author = {Manu Dubin and Pei Zhang and Dazhe Meng and Marie-Stanislas Remigereau and Edward J. Osborne and Francesco Paolo Casale and Philipp Drewe and André Kahles and Géraldine Jean and Bjarni J. Vilhjálmsson and Joanna Gunis and Selen Irez and Viktor Voronin and Qiang Song and Quan Long and Gunnar Rätsch and Oliver Stegle and Richard M. Clark and Magnus Nordborg},
  title = {{DNA methylation in Arabidopsis has a genetic basis and shows evidence of local adaptation}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.05255},
}
Figure