Diversity–stability relationships across organism groups and ecosystem types become decoupled across spatial scales

Nathan I. Wisnoski, Riley Andrade, Max C. N. Castorani, Christopher P. Catano, Aldo Compagnoni, Thomas Lamy, Nina K. Lany, Luca Marazzi, Sydne Record, Annie C. Smith, Christopher M. Swan, Jonathan D. Tonkin, Nicole M. Voelker, Phoebe L. Zarnetske, Eric R. SokolEcology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The relationship between biodiversity and stability, or its inverse, temporal variability, is multidimensional and complex. Temporal variability in aggregate properties, like total biomass or abundance, is typically lower in communities with higher species diversity (i.e., the diversity-stability relationship [DSR]). At broader spatial extents, regional-scale aggregate variability is also lower with higher regional diversity (in plant systems) and with lower spatial synchrony. However, focusing exclusively on aggregate properties of communities may overlook potentially destabilizing compositional shifts. It is not yet clear how diversity is related to different components of variability across spatial scales, nor whether regional DSRs emerge across a broad range of organisms and ecosystem types. To test these questions, we compiled a large collection of long-term metacommunity data spanning a wide range of taxonomic groups (e.g., birds, fish, plants, invertebrates) and ecosystem types (e.g., deserts, forests, oceans). We applied a newly developed quantitative framework for jointly analyzing aggregate and compositional variability across scales. We quantified DSRs for composition and aggregate variability in local communities and metacommunities. At the local scale, more diverse communities were less variable, but this effect was stronger for aggregate than compositional properties. We found no stabilizing effect of γ-diversity on metacommunity variability, but β-diversity played a strong role in reducing compositional spatial synchrony, which reduced regional variability. Spatial synchrony differed among taxa, suggesting differences in stabilization by spatial processes. However, metacommunity variability was more strongly driven by local variability than by spatial synchrony. Across a broader range of taxa, our results suggest that high γ-diversity does not consistently stabilize aggregate properties at regional scales without sufficient spatial β-diversity to reduce spatial synchrony.

Introduction: The Scaling Challenge in Ecology

Ecologists have long observed that species-rich communities tend to be more stable over time—a phenomenon called the diversity–stability relationship (DSR). However, most evidence for this comes from small-scale, local experiments, often focused exclusively on plants. There is a significant gap in our understanding of how this relationship scales up to larger "metacommunities" (groups of local communities linked by dispersal) and whether it holds true for animals and microbes. Furthermore, stability is often measured only as "aggregate" variability (e.g., total biomass), which can mask "compositional" variability (shifts in which species are dominant). This study investigates whether regional diversity actually stabilizes regional ecosystems across a broad range of life forms and habitats.

Methods and Data Synthesis

The authors applied a newly developed quantitative framework to jointly analyze aggregate (total abundance/biomass) and compositional (relative species proportions) variability across spatial scales.

  1. Variability Partitioning: Multiplicative partitioning was used to separate variability into local ($\alpha$) and regional ($\gamma$) components.
  2. Synchrony Analysis: Spatial synchrony—the degree to which different sites fluctuate in tandem—was calculated. Low synchrony is a hallmark of "spatial insurance," where one site's boom offsets another's bust.
  3. Statistical Modeling: Linear Mixed Effects Models (LMMs) and Bayesian hierarchical models were employed to test relationships across 29 diverse datasets.
  4. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): This mapped the complex, indirect pathways through which different types of diversity ($\alpha, \beta, \gamma$) influence stability at the regional level.

The study synthesized 29 long-term metacommunity time series (minimum 5 years and 5 sites) primarily from the Long Term Ecological Research (LTER) network, covering birds, fish, plants, grasshoppers, algae, mollusks, and various invertebrates across deserts, temperate forests, grasslands, coral reefs, and coastal oceans.

Key Results: Decoupling and the Role of $\beta$-Diversity

The analysis revealed that the classic DSR is strong at the local scale—more species generally mean more stable total biomass. However, this relationship "decouples" at the regional scale; having a high total number of species in a region ($\gamma$-diversity) does not consistently lead to regional stability.

Relationships between diversity, variability, and synchrony across scales and organism groups.

As shown in Figure 4, local richness had a significant stabilizing effect on aggregate properties (panel a). Interestingly, high local diversity sometimes increased compositional variability (panel b). In species-rich plots, species "swap" roles more frequently, which actually helps keep the total biomass stable.

At the regional scale, there was no direct stabilizing effect of $\gamma$-diversity on metacommunity variability. Instead, $\beta$-diversity emerged as the primary driver of regional stability. Spatial turnover ($\beta$-diversity) was strongly negatively related to both aggregate and compositional spatial synchrony (panels c and d). By ensuring that different sites have different species compositions, $\beta$-diversity reduces spatial synchrony. When sites don't all crash at the same time, the region as a whole remains stable.

The study also noted taxonomic "personalities": Different groups stabilize differently. Birds showed very low spatial synchrony (high spatial insurance), likely due to their high mobility. In contrast, plants and invertebrates were more synchronous, making them more vulnerable to regional-scale fluctuations.

Discussion and Future Directions

While this study provides a robust cross-taxa analysis, it is observational in nature. Because it used existing monitoring data rather than controlled experiments, the authors cannot definitively prove causation, only strong correlation. Additionally, the "regional" scale varied between datasets, which may influence the strength of the observed synchrony.

The findings suggest that conservation efforts should shift focus from just "counting species" in a region to protecting spatial heterogeneity ($\beta$-diversity) to ensure long-term regional resilience. Future work should investigate how external factors like climate change or habitat fragmentation interact with these diversity-stability pathways.

Summary updated

Abstract

The relationship between biodiversity and stability, or its inverse, temporal variability, is multidimensional and complex. Temporal variability in aggregate properties, like total biomass or abundance, is typically lower in communities with higher species diversity (i.e., the diversity-stability relationship [DSR]). At broader spatial extents, regional-scale aggregate variability is also lower with higher regional diversity (in plant systems) and with lower spatial synchrony. However, focusing exclusively on aggregate properties of communities may overlook potentially destabilizing compositional shifts. It is not yet clear how diversity is related to different components of variability across spatial scales, nor whether regional DSRs emerge across a broad range of organisms and ecosystem types. To test these questions, we compiled a large collection of long-term metacommunity data spanning a wide range of taxonomic groups (e.g., birds, fish, plants, invertebrates) and ecosystem types (e.g., deserts, forests, oceans). We applied a newly developed quantitative framework for jointly analyzing aggregate and compositional variability across scales. We quantified DSRs for composition and aggregate variability in local communities and metacommunities. At the local scale, more diverse communities were less variable, but this effect was stronger for aggregate than compositional properties. We found no stabilizing effect of γ-diversity on metacommunity variability, but β-diversity played a strong role in reducing compositional spatial synchrony, which reduced regional variability. Spatial synchrony differed among taxa, suggesting differences in stabilization by spatial processes. However, metacommunity variability was more strongly driven by local variability than by spatial synchrony. Across a broader range of taxa, our results suggest that high γ-diversity does not consistently stabilize aggregate properties at regional scales without sufficient spatial β-diversity to reduce spatial synchrony.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wisnoski2023diversitystability,
  author = {Nathan I. Wisnoski and Riley Andrade and Max C. N. Castorani and Christopher P. Catano and Aldo Compagnoni and Thomas Lamy and Nina K. Lany and Luca Marazzi and Sydne Record and Annie C. Smith and Christopher M. Swan and Jonathan D. Tonkin and Nicole M. Voelker and Phoebe L. Zarnetske and Eric R. Sokol},
  title = {{Diversity–stability relationships across organism groups and ecosystem types become decoupled across spatial scales}},
  booktitle = {Ecology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1002/ecy.4136},
}
Figure