Diversity-stability relationships become decoupled across spatial scales: a synthesis of organism and ecosystem types

Nathan I. Wisnoski, Riley Andrade, Max C. N. Castorani, Christopher P. Catano, Aldo Compagnoni, Thomas Lamy, Nina K. Lany, Luca Marazzi, Sydne Record, Annie C. Smith, Christopher M. Swan, Jonathan D. Tonkin, Nicole M. Voelker, Phoebe L. Zarnetske, Eric R. SokolbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the stabilizing effect of biodiversity on ecological communities, a well-established principle at local scales, doesn't consistently translate to regional scales. The authors found that while local diversity can buffer against fluctuations, regional stability is more influenced by the spatial arrangement of species (β-diversity) than by the sheer number of species (γ-diversity).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, ecologists have observed a "diversity-stability relationship" (DSR): more diverse ecosystems tend to be more stable, meaning their populations and biomass fluctuate less over time. This has been primarily studied at local scales. However, as ecological processes operate across vast landscapes, it's crucial to understand if these DSRs hold up at broader spatial extents. A key challenge is that simply looking at total biomass or abundance (aggregate properties) might mask underlying shifts in species composition, which can also impact stability. This paper tackles the question of whether DSRs scale up to regional levels and how both aggregate properties and species composition contribute to this scaling, across a wide variety of organisms and ecosystems.

Methods

The researchers employed a novel quantitative framework to analyze metacommunity data. This framework uses a multiplicative partitioning approach to decompose regional variability into two components: local variability and spatial synchrony. They applied this to both aggregate properties (like total abundance) and compositional properties (species relative abundances). By comparing these components across different spatial scales (local, regional) and levels of diversity (α, β, γ), they could assess how diversity influences stability at each scale and how spatial processes like synchrony mediate these relationships. They used linear mixed-effects models to account for variations across different datasets.

Datasets

The study utilized 22 long-term, spatially replicated metacommunity time series datasets. These datasets were sourced from the Long-Term Ecological Research (LTER) Network and are publicly available through the Environmental Data Initiative (EDI) portal. The datasets span a wide range of ecosystem types (e.g., deserts, forests, coral reefs) and taxonomic groups (e.g., birds, fish, plants, invertebrates, algae).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Local vs. Regional Stability: The classic stabilizing effect of biodiversity is strong at local scales but weakens or changes at regional scales.
  • Composition Matters: Focusing solely on aggregate properties (like total biomass) can be misleading; changes in species composition are crucial for understanding regional stability.
  • Spatial Synchrony is Key: How species populations fluctuate in sync across space (spatial synchrony) plays a critical role in regional stability, often more so than the total number of species.
  • β-diversity's Role: The diversity of species composition between sites (β-diversity) is a powerful driver of regional stability, particularly by reducing spatial synchrony.
  • Taxonomic Differences: Different organism groups (e.g., birds vs. plants) exhibit distinct patterns of spatial synchrony and thus different scaling of diversity-stability relationships.

Key Results

  • At the local scale, higher α-diversity (within-site diversity) generally reduced aggregate variability but had mixed effects on compositional variability, sometimes increasing it in plants.
  • Spatial synchrony varied significantly among taxa, with birds showing low synchrony and plants high synchrony.
  • Higher spatial β-diversity consistently reduced both aggregate and compositional spatial synchrony, with a stronger effect on compositional synchrony.
  • At the regional (γ) scale, higher γ-diversity did not consistently stabilize aggregate properties. Instead, there was a positive relationship between γ-diversity and compositional variability.
  • The study found a moderate positive correlation between aggregate and compositional spatial synchrony, suggesting that metacommunities with lower compositional synchrony also tended to have lower aggregate synchrony.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their findings suggest a decoupling of diversity-stability relationships from local to regional scales. They highlight that the specific mechanisms and strengths of these relationships can vary significantly among organismal groups and ecosystem types. Future work could explore these system-specific nuances further, particularly how environmental heterogeneity and dispersal interact to shape these scaled relationships. Understanding these differences is crucial for effective conservation efforts, as strategies that work for one type of community might not apply to others. The paper also points out that while aggregate properties might not show a clear regional DSR, compositional variability can become more consistent at regional scales, suggesting that focusing on species composition might be a more robust approach for understanding regional stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT The relationship between biodiversity and stability, or its inverse, temporal variability, is multidimensional and complex. Temporal variability in aggregate properties, like total biomass or abundance, is typically lower in communities with higher species diversity (i.e., the diversity-stability relationship or DSR). Recent work has shown that, at broader spatial extents, regional-scale aggregate variability is also lower with higher regional diversity (in plant systems) and with lower spatial synchrony. However, it is not yet clear whether regional DSRs hold across a broad range of organisms and ecosystem types. Furthermore, focusing exclusively on aggregate properties of communities may overlook potentially destabilizing compositional shifts. To test these questions, we compiled a large collection of long-term spatial metacommunity data spanning a wide range of taxonomic groups (e.g., birds, fish, plants, invertebrates) and ecosystem types (e.g., deserts, forests, oceans). We applied a newly developed quantitative framework for jointly analyzing aggregate and compositional variability across scales. We quantified DSRs for composition and total abundance in local communities and metacommunities. At the local scale, compositional DSRs suggested that higher local (α) diversity was associated with lower variability in animal populations but higher variability in plant populations, while aggregate DSRs supported the classic stabilizing effects of diversity. Spatial synchrony differed among taxa (birds had the lowest, plants the highest), suggesting differences in stabilization by spatial processes. Spatial synchrony declined with higher diversity among sites (β) for both compositional and aggregate properties. However, at the regional (γ) scale, we found no aggregate DSR, but a positive compositional DSR. Across a broader range of taxa, our results suggest that high γ-diversity does not consistently stabilize aggregate properties at regional scales without sufficient spatial β-diversity to reduce spatial synchrony. Open research statement All data sets are accessible via the Environmental Data Initiative, and a specific data package of the data sets used in this analysis will be made publicly available (doi: pending). Citations to original sources are included in Appendix S1. Code to reproduce the analyses is found in a Zenodo archive (doi: pending) of the GitHub repository for this project ( https://github.com/sokole/ltermetacommunities/tree/master/Manuscripts/MS3 ).
BibTeX
@misc{wisnoski2022diversity,
  author = {Nathan I. Wisnoski and Riley Andrade and Max C. N. Castorani and Christopher P. Catano and Aldo Compagnoni and Thomas Lamy and Nina K. Lany and Luca Marazzi and Sydne Record and Annie C. Smith and Christopher M. Swan and Jonathan D. Tonkin and Nicole M. Voelker and Phoebe L. Zarnetske and Eric R. Sokol},
  title = {{Diversity-stability relationships become decoupled across spatial scales: a synthesis of organism and ecosystem types}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.10.04.510879},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure