Diversification and hybridization in firm knowledge bases in nanotechnologies

Éric Avenel, Anne-Violaine Favier, Siwei Ma, Vincent Mangematin, Carole RieuResearch 2007 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Nanotechnology is frequently characterized as a "converging" technology—a melting pot where physics, chemistry, biology, and engineering intersect. While this convergence is often discussed at the industry level, a critical strategic question remains: how do individual firms build expertise in such a multi-disciplinary field? This paper investigates whether firms develop their "Nano-Knowledge Base" (NKB) through juxtaposition—adding new, independent R&D silos—or through hybridization—blending multiple scientific disciplines within single research projects.

Understanding these patterns helps clarify whether nanotechnology acts as a "competence-destroying" force that threatens established giants or a "competence-enhancing" tool that they can readily adopt.

Methodology and Metrics

The researchers employed scientometric methods to analyze the NKB of firms, distinguishing between scientific knowledge (measured via publications) and technological knowledge (measured via patents). To quantify the structure of this knowledge, they utilized two primary metrics:

  • Diversity Index: Based on "1 minus the Herfindahl index," this measures the breadth of a firm’s portfolio across different ISI subject categories or US Patent Classifications.
  • Hybridization Index: This metric measures the average number of different technological or scientific fields cited within a single patent or publication.

By comparing these indices against the total size of a firm’s knowledge base, the authors could identify which firms were "collecting" disparate fields versus those "blending" them into integrated innovations.

Data Overview

The study utilized a worldwide database of "nanofirms" covering the period from 1993 to 2003. The dataset included:

  • Publications: Approximately 122,000 papers from the Thomson-ISI ‘Web of Science,’ identifying 1,271 firms.
  • Patents: Approximately 4,000 nano-patents from the USPTO.

The researchers used a sophisticated two-stage extraction method to ensure the data was central to nanotechnology, combining keyword searches with citation analysis to filter out peripheral research.

Key Insights: The Size vs. Strategy Divide

The research reveals that there is no single path to nanotechnology expertise. Instead, large incumbents and small startups play entirely different strategic games.

Large Firms as "Collectors"

Large incumbents typically achieve high diversity through juxtaposition. Because they possess the capital to run independent physics, chemistry, and biotech labs simultaneously, their overall portfolio appears diverse. However, their individual researchers often remain specialized within their respective silos. For these firms, nanotechnology is often treated as an extension of existing capabilities.

Small Firms as "Integrators"

In contrast, many small startups achieve diversity through hybridization. Despite having only a few patents or publications, these documents often cite four or five different scientific fields. These firms act as the true "hybridizers" of the industry, likely employing multi-disciplinary teams where researchers from different backgrounds work together on the same project to exploit the "white space" between established disciplines.

Conclusion

The data suggests that the convergence of nanotechnology is a real organizational phenomenon, particularly visible in the R&D strategies of new entrants. The "nano-landscape" is currently a mixture of two worlds: incumbents using their complementary assets (such as massive cleanrooms and distribution networks) to manage diverse portfolios, and startups using their agility to pioneer interdisciplinary breakthroughs.

While the study highlights these distinct strategies, it also notes that further research is required to determine which approach leads to better long-term financial performance and whether the hybridization strategy of startups will eventually force a change in how large incumbents structure their R&D.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{avenel2007diversification,
  author = {Éric Avenel and Anne-Violaine Favier and Siwei Ma and Vincent Mangematin and Carole Rieu},
  title = {{Diversification and hybridization in firm knowledge bases in nanotechnologies}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1016/j.respol.2007.02.002},
}
Figure