Diverse grouping and mating strategies in the Critically Endangered Hainan gibbon (Nomascus hainanus)

Ping Li, Paul A. Garber, Yu Bi, Kun Jin, Xuming Qi, Jiang ZhouPrimates 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex social and mating behaviors of the critically endangered Hainan gibbon, revealing surprising flexibility in their group structures and reproductive strategies. Understanding this variability is crucial for developing effective conservation plans for the last remaining population of these primates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Hainan gibbon ( Nomascus hainanus) is on the brink of extinction, with only about 35 individuals remaining in the wild, confined to a small area in Hainan Island, China. Historically, gibbons were thought to primarily form monogamous, pair-bonded family groups. However, recent observations suggest that some species, particularly within the Nomascus genus, exhibit more complex social structures and mating systems, including polygyny (multiple mates). This paper aims to shed light on the social structure and mating strategies of the Hainan gibbon, a species that has experienced severe habitat loss and population decline. The researchers want to understand if their current social organization and mating behaviors are typical for the species or if they represent adaptations to their precarious situation, which is vital for effective conservation efforts.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of observational methods over a ten-year period (September 2011 to August 2021), focusing on five social groups of Hainan gibbons. They used a 5-minute scan sampling method at 15-minute intervals to collect data on group location, activity budgets, and social interactions. Individuals were identified by their morphological characteristics and changes in hair color. Detailed ad libitum data were collected specifically on mating behavior, utilizing a Kowa TSN-883 telescope for observation. The study specifically details observations of mating events within Group C, which was composed of eight individuals, including three adult males and two adult females.

Datasets

The study utilized observational data collected from wild Hainan gibbon groups in the Hainan Tropical Rainforest National Park. No new datasets were introduced or made publicly available as part of this research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mating System Flexibility: Contrary to a simple monogamous model, Hainan gibbons, particularly in Group C, exhibit a multi-male/multi-female social structure and engage in polygynous mating.
  • Female Agency in Mating: The breeding female (F2) in Group C actively solicited copulations from multiple resident males, demonstrating significant control over mating partner choice.
  • Male Tolerance: Resident males did not interrupt mating pairs, suggesting a level of tolerance or acceptance of extra-pair copulations within the group.
  • Conservation Implications: The observed variability in social and mating strategies, even within this small, endangered population, suggests that conservation plans need to be flexible and account for these diverse behaviors.
  • Adaptation to Stress: The complex social structures and mating strategies might be adaptations to severe population disruption and habitat degradation, allowing for greater reproductive success and group stability.

Key Results

  • As of August 2021, four of the five Hainan gibbon groups contained two breeding females, and three groups had two or three adult males.
  • Group C, the focus of detailed mating observations, consisted of three adult males (M1, M2, M3) and two adult females (F1, F2).
  • The study documented five instances of mating in Group C.
  • In one instance (March 21, 2019), the pregnant female F2 solicited matings from both M1 and M2 on the same day, with unsuccessful attempts with M1 and a subsequent attempt with M2.
  • On July 11, 2020, F2 solicited M2, and they successfully copulated twice. Later that same day, F2 also mated with M1.
  • On April 25, 2021, F2 copulated with M1.
  • The third adult male (M3) in Group C was not observed to copulate.
  • The adult male-to-female sex ratio in established Hainan gibbon groups was approximately 1:1.2.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that detailed, long-term data on Hainan gibbon behavior, diet, ecology, and reproductive strategies remain limited. The severely altered landscape and fragmented habitat present significant challenges for conservation planning and effective population management.

Future work should focus on:

  • Gathering more detailed and long-term data on group formation, dispersal patterns, and group stability.
  • Investigating the role of "floaters" (individuals not part of established groups) in maintaining genetic diversity and group continuity.
  • Understanding the nutritional ecology and diet of Hainan gibbons in their disturbed upland forest habitats.
  • Prioritizing programs that restore natural forests, fund long-term research, and protect the remaining population to prevent extinction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding flexibility in the social structure and mating strategies of the world's last remaining population (35 individuals) of wild Hainan gibbons (Nomascus hainanus) is critical for developing effective management plans to aid in their population recovery. Three of the five remaining Hainan gibbon groups (A, B, and C) currently live in a social unit characterized by two or three adult males, two reproducing adult females, and offspring. A fourth group (D) contains one adult male, two adult females, and offspring, and Group E contains a single adult male-adult female pair with a young infant. In this study, we describe observations of copulations between multiple resident males and one of the two resident females in Group C. Group C is best described as a small multi-male/multi-female group. We found that this breeding female (F2) solicited copulations from two resident adult males (M1 and M2) on the same day, and also mated with each of these two males on different days. Resident males were not observed to interrupt the mating pair. Although factors such as a biased adult sex ratio, severe population disruption, and habitat degradation can help explain variation in group composition and mating strategies in Hainan gibbons, we argue that there exists considerable mating system variability across gibbon species, and that this variability offers important insights into male and female Hainan gibbon group structure and reproductive strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022diverse,
  author = {Ping Li and Paul A. Garber and Yu Bi and Kun Jin and Xuming Qi and Jiang Zhou},
  title = {{Diverse grouping and mating strategies in the Critically Endangered Hainan gibbon (Nomascus hainanus)}},
  booktitle = {Primates},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10329-022-00983-5},
}
Figure