Diverse cloud and aerosol impacts on solar photovoltaic potential in southern China and northern India

Jiang-Yan Yang, Bingqi Yi, Shuai Wang, Yushan Liu, Yuxiao LiScientific 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Cloud and aerosol are two important modulators that influence the solar radiation reaching the earth's surface. It is intriguing to find diverse impacts of clouds and aerosols over Southern China (SC) and Northern India (NI) which result in remarkable differences in the plane-of-array irradiance (POAI) that signifies the maximum available solar photovoltaic potential by combining the latest satellite retrieval results and modeling tools. By separating the impacts of cloud and aerosol on the POAI, it is found that clouds are responsible for the most reduction of POAI in the SC, while aerosols and clouds are equally important for the NI region. The frequent occurrences of low and middle level clouds with high optical depth in the SC, as compared with the much lower occurrences of all levels of clouds with lower optical depth in the NI, is regarded as the major reason for the differences in the POAI. The differences in the main compositions of aerosols in the SC (sulfate) and the NI (dust) could be essential to answer the question of why higher aerosol optical depth in the SC whereas leads to weaker reduction in the POAI than that in the NI. The mitigation measures targeting on the controls of different types of aerosols should be considered for different regions.

Introduction

As developing nations pivot toward renewable energy, understanding the available "solar resource" is critical for grid planning and economic viability. Southern China (SC) and Northern India (NI) are both high-demand regions with significant air pollution (haze) and cloud cover. Curiously, even though they share similar geographic coordinates, their actual solar photovoltaic (PV) potential differs dramatically. This study addresses the gap in quantifying the simultaneous and relative impacts of both clouds and aerosols to understand why solar potential is so much lower in Southern China than in Northern India.

Methodology and Data

The researchers employed a combination of satellite observations and atmospheric modeling to calculate Plane-of-Array Irradiance (POAI). Unlike standard horizontal irradiance, POAI represents the actual energy hitting a tilted solar panel, providing a more realistic metric for PV potential.

Key tools and datasets included:

  • PVLIB-Python: An open-source library used to model real-world PV potential.
  • Decomposition Analysis: The model was run under four scenarios (Pristine, Clear-sky, All-sky-no-aerosol, and All-sky) to isolate the "Cloud Effect" (CE) and the "Aerosol Effect" (AE).
  • CERES SYN1deg & MERRA-2: These provided high-resolution long-term data (2003–2019) on radiative fluxes, cloud properties, and aerosol compositions (sulfate, dust, black carbon, etc.).

Regional Solar Potential

Northern India boasts a significantly higher annual average POAI (5.27 kWh/m²/d) compared to Southern China (3.57 kWh/m²/d). The difference is most pronounced in the spring; for instance, in March, NI’s solar potential is nearly double that of SC.

Comparison of average annual and monthly solar potential (POAI) between Southern China and Northern India.

Drivers of Solar Reduction

The study reveals a stark contrast in what blocks the sun in these two regions. In Southern China, clouds are the undisputed primary driver of solar reduction, responsible for approximately 75% of the total loss. This is largely due to the frequent occurrence of persistent, optically thick mid-level clouds, particularly in areas like the Sichuan Basin.

In Northern India, the impact is more balanced: aerosols and clouds are roughly equal contributors to the dimming effect. While NI has lower cloud frequency, its aerosols are remarkably efficient at blocking light.

Decomposition of solar potential reduction, showing the dominant role of clouds in Southern China versus the balanced impact of clouds and aerosols in Northern India.

The "Aerosol Quality" Paradox

Surprisingly, Southern China often has a higher total volume of aerosols (Aerosol Optical Depth, or AOD) than Northern India. However, Northern India’s aerosols cause a much larger reduction in solar potential per unit. This is due to composition: NI is dominated by dust, while SC is dominated by sulfate. Dust is significantly more effective at scattering and absorbing solar radiation, leading to an Aerosol Effect Efficiency (AEE) in Northern India that is nearly three times higher than in Southern China.

Conclusion

The findings suggest that "one-size-fits-all" air pollution policies will not work for solar optimization. Northern India needs to focus on dust management and transboundary pollution, while Southern China’s solar future is more tied to understanding cloud microphysics and reducing industrial sulfates. Future work will need to explore the indirect effects where aerosols act as seeds for cloud formation, further complicating these regional dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cloud and aerosol are two important modulators that influence the solar radiation reaching the earth's surface. It is intriguing to find diverse impacts of clouds and aerosols over Southern China (SC) and Northern India (NI) which result in remarkable differences in the plane-of-array irradiance (POAI) that signifies the maximum available solar photovoltaic potential by combining the latest satellite retrieval results and modeling tools. By separating the impacts of cloud and aerosol on the POAI, it is found that clouds are responsible for the most reduction of POAI in the SC, while aerosols and clouds are equally important for the NI region. The frequent occurrences of low and middle level clouds with high optical depth in the SC, as compared with the much lower occurrences of all levels of clouds with lower optical depth in the NI, is regarded as the major reason for the differences in the POAI. The differences in the main compositions of aerosols in the SC (sulfate) and the NI (dust) could be essential to answer the question of why higher aerosol optical depth in the SC whereas leads to weaker reduction in the POAI than that in the NI. The mitigation measures targeting on the controls of different types of aerosols should be considered for different regions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2022diverse,
  author = {Jiang-Yan Yang and Bingqi Yi and Shuai Wang and Yushan Liu and Yuxiao Li},
  title = {{Diverse cloud and aerosol impacts on solar photovoltaic potential in southern China and northern India}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-24208-3},
}
Figure