Divergent responses of native predators to severe wildfire and biological invasion are mediated by life history

Joshua M. Barry, Connor M. Wood, Gavin M. Jones, Kate McGinn, Kevin G. Kelly, H. Anu Kramer, Daniel F. Hofstadter, Stefan Kahl, Holger Klinck, Nicholas F. Kryshak, Brian P. Dotters, Kevin N. Roberts, John J. Keane, Elizabeth Ng, M. Zachariah PeeryEcological 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how severe wildfires and the invasion of barred owls, a non-native predator, impact three native forest owl species in California. By combining experimental removals of barred owls with natural wildfire events and using passive acoustic monitoring, the researchers found that life history traits, such as body size and activity patterns, significantly influence how these owls respond to these dual threats. This work highlights the importance of proactive management and understanding species-specific vulnerabilities in a rapidly changing environment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Anthropocene is characterized by rapid environmental changes, including increasingly severe wildfires and the spread of invasive species. These dual stressors pose a significant challenge to biodiversity, and understanding their combined effects on native species is crucial for effective conservation. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of how native forest owl communities in the Sierra Nevada, California, are affected by two major, co-occurring threats: severe wildfires and the invasion of the barred owl, a larger, non-native predator. Previous research has often studied these stressors in isolation, making it difficult to disentangle their relative and interactive impacts on species facing multiple environmental challenges. This study aims to fill this gap by using an experimental approach to assess these combined effects.

Methods

The researchers employed a "Before-After-Control-Impact" (BACI) experimental design. This involved:

  • Passive Acoustic Monitoring: Autonomous recording units (ARUs) were deployed across hundreds of hexagonal cells (400 ha each) in the northern Sierra Nevada for four breeding seasons (2018, 2021, 2022, 2023). This method allowed for the detection of owl vocalizations without direct observation.
  • Bioacoustic Data Processing: The BirdNET algorithm, a deep convolutional neural network, was used to identify owl vocalizations. Custom thresholds were established to minimize false positives.
  • Experimental Barred Owl Removal: A lethal removal experiment for barred owls was conducted across the study area, primarily in the summer of 2019. This provided a manipulative aspect to assess the impact of removing the invasive predator.
  • Natural Wildfire Events: The study area experienced two significant, high-severity wildfires (North Complex Fire in 2020 and Dixie Fire in 2021) during the monitoring period.
  • Occupancy Modeling: Bayesian single-species, single-season occupancy models were used to analyze the detection/non-detection data. These models accounted for imperfect detection and allowed for the assessment of environmental predictors (wildfire, barred owl presence/removal) on owl occupancy rates.
  • Habitat Niche Segregation Analysis: Occupancy models were also used to examine habitat preferences of native owls and barred owls, looking at factors like elevation, terrain ruggedness, and the proportion of intermediate-to-late seral forests.

Datasets

The study utilized acoustic data collected from 2018 to 2023. This data was collected using ARUs deployed across 265 hexagonal cells. The researchers also incorporated data on severe wildfire extent and severity from the Monitoring Trends in Burn Severity (MTBS) database. Information on barred owl lethal removal locations was also used. The authors state that anonymized encounter histories and data are publicly available in Dryad.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Life History is Key: The most striking insight is how fundamental life history traits (body size, diet, activity patterns) dictate vulnerability to these dual stressors. This moves beyond simple habitat availability to explain differential responses.
  • Wildfire's Selective Impact: Severe wildfires disproportionately affected flammulated owls, likely due to their reliance on specific microhabitats (mature forests for foraging and nesting) that are destroyed by high-severity burns.
  • Barred Owl Impact Varies: The invasive barred owl had a significant negative impact on flammulated owls, but not on the larger great horned owls or the more diurnal pygmy owls. This suggests that nocturnal, smaller-bodied species are most at risk.
  • Niche Partitioning Isn't Enough: Even though barred owls and native owls showed some habitat segregation, this was insufficient to fully protect flammulated owls from the barred owl's influence, indicating non-consumptive or predatory pressures.
  • Experimental Approach is Powerful: The study successfully demonstrates the value of combining manipulative experiments (barred owl removals) with natural events (wildfires) and regional monitoring to understand complex ecological interactions.

Key Results

  • Flammulated Owls:
    • Occupancy declined by 71% in severely burned areas for at least 3 years postfire.
  • Occupancy increased approximately twofold (from 0.09 to 0.18) following lethal barred owl removals.
  • No interactive effect was found between severe wildfires and barred owl removals on flammulated owl occupancy.
  • Great Horned Owls:
    • No significant negative impact from severe wildfires was observed, and they were even more likely to occupy sites with some high-severity wildfire.
  • Barred owl removals had little to no significant effect on their occupancy.
  • Northern Pygmy Owls:
    • No significant negative impact from severe wildfires was observed.
  • Barred owl removals had little to no significant effect on their occupancy.
  • Habitat Niche: Barred owls exhibited the narrowest niche breadth, while pygmy and flammulated owls had the widest. Flammulated owls showed the least niche overlap with barred owls. Barred owls preferred lower elevations, less rugged terrain, and more intermediate-to-late seral forests.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Barred Owl Densities: The study focused on an early-stage invasion with relatively low barred owl densities. The authors suggest that interactions and impacts might be more pronounced in areas with higher barred owl densities.
  • Long-Term Fire Effects: While the study assessed impacts for up to 3 years postfire, the long-term recovery dynamics of flammulated owls following high-severity wildfires require further research.
  • Synergistic Effects: The study did not find evidence of interactive effects between fire and barred owl removals on flammulated owl occupancy. However, the authors acknowledge that interactions could emerge in areas with higher barred owl densities.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the need for proactive management, particularly early detection and removal of invasive barred owls, especially at the leading edges of their invasion. They also advocate for management strategies that aim to conserve large trees, reduce high-severity wildfire spread, and promote low-to-moderate severity fire to benefit species like flammulated owls. Further research into how fire severity and recovery dynamics impact secondary-cavity nesters is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Anthropocene is defined by rapid environmental changes such as biological invasions and shifting disturbance regimes that threaten native species. Understanding the drivers of endangerment for species facing multiple simultaneous threats is challenging without experimental methods. Here, we examined the relative and combined effects of severe wildfires and an early-stage barred owl (Strix varia) invasion on an assemblage of three native forest owl species in the Sierra Nevada, California, USA, leveraging manipulative (lethal barred owl removals) and natural (severe wildfires) experiments and a regional passive acoustic monitoring program from 2018 to 2023. Wildfires reduced flammulated owl (Psiloscops flammeolus) occupancy by 71% in severely burned areas (sites experiencing near-complete high-severity fire) for at least 3 years postfire but did not affect great horned (Bubo virginianus) or northern pygmy owl (Glaucidium californicum) occupancy. Because flammulated owls have small home ranges and an insectivorous diet that depends on nearby mature forest foraging habitat and secondary-cavity nest sites, they showed a strong negative response to extensive high-severity burn areas that eliminate these resources. Flammulated owl occupancy increased approximately twofold from 0.09 (85% CI: 0.03, 0.20) to 0.18 (85% CI: 0.07, 0.36) following lethal barred owl removals (with only 4% posterior distribution overlap), but removals did not affect the other two native species. Despite evidence of habitat segregation between barred owls and the native species, where barred owls typically occupied intermediate-to-late seral forests in flatter, lower elevation areas, this niche partitioning was insufficient to prevent nonconsumptive or predatory effects on flammulated owls. In contrast, the resilience of great horned and pygmy owls may have stemmed from their larger body size and diurnal activity, respectively, suggesting that life history mediates forest owl vulnerability to invasive barred owls. The negative effects of barred owls on flammulated owls, even during the early invasion stage, coupled with well-documented effects on other small, nocturnal forest owl species in regions with high barred owl densities, reinforce the conservation value of proactive invasive species management. Our study demonstrates the power of regional-scale experimentation, facilitated by bioacoustic monitoring, for understanding biological community responses-mediated by species' life history-to rapid environmental changes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{barry2025divergent,
  author = {Joshua M. Barry and Connor M. Wood and Gavin M. Jones and Kate McGinn and Kevin G. Kelly and H. Anu Kramer and Daniel F. Hofstadter and Stefan Kahl and Holger Klinck and Nicholas F. Kryshak and Brian P. Dotters and Kevin N. Roberts and John J. Keane and Elizabeth Ng and M. Zachariah Peery},
  title = {{Divergent responses of native predators to severe wildfire and biological invasion are mediated by life history}},
  booktitle = {Ecological},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1002/eap.70135},
}
Figure