Diurnal, synoptic and seasonal variability of atmospheric CO 2 in the Paris megacity area

Irène Xueref-Rémy, Elsa Dieudonné, C. Vuillemin, Morgan Lopez, Christine Lac, Martina Schmidt, Marc Delmotte, Frédéric Chevallier, François Ravetta, Olivier Perrussel, Philippe Ciais, François‐Marie Bréon, Grégoire Broquet, Michel Ramonet, T. Gerard Spain, Christophe AmpèAtmospheric 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents the first comprehensive analysis of atmospheric CO2 variability in the Paris megacity region using a novel in-situ measurement network. It reveals how urban emissions, atmospheric dynamics (like boundary layer height), and regional transport interact to shape CO2 concentrations, highlighting the inadequacy of remote sites for capturing urban impacts and offering crucial insights for designing future urban CO2 monitoring networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately quantifying CO2 emissions from urban areas is critical for climate change mitigation, but bottom-up inventory methods often suffer from large uncertainties. Understanding the atmospheric impact of these emissions requires robust in-situ measurements that can capture the complex interplay of local sources, regional transport, and atmospheric processes. Previous studies often relied on remote sites or limited urban monitoring, making it difficult to disentangle the specific contribution of megacities like Paris to regional CO2 levels. This paper addresses this gap by deploying a dedicated network to monitor CO2 across urban, peri-urban, and rural gradients around Paris, aiming to characterize diurnal, synoptic, and seasonal variability and assess the representativeness of background sites.

Methods

The study utilizes a network of five CO2 measurement stations strategically placed across the Paris megacity area (urban, peri-urban, and rural). Data collected over nearly a year (August 2010 - July 2011) were analyzed. Key methods include:

  • In-situ CO2 measurements: Continuous monitoring using cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS) analyzers.
  • Atmospheric Boundary Layer Height (ABLH) observations: Data from an elastic lidar at a central Paris location.
  • Meteorological data: Modeled wind fields (Meso-NH model) and observed data from local meteorological stations.
  • Air mass back-trajectory analysis: Using the HYSPLIT model to understand the origin of air masses.
  • Wind classification: Categorizing data based on wind speed and direction to differentiate local, regional, and remote influences.
  • Comparison with remote site data: Using measurements from Mace Head, Ireland, as a reference for background concentrations.

Datasets

  • CO2-MegaParis Network Data: In-situ CO2 measurements from five stations (MON, GON, EIF, GIF, TRN) collected between August 2010 and July 2011.
  • Mace Head (MHD) Data: Remote CO2 measurements from the Atlantic coast of Ireland.
  • QUALAIR Lidar Data: Atmospheric Boundary Layer Height (ABLH) observations in central Paris.
  • Meso-NH Model Output: Modeled meteorological fields (wind speed and direction) for the Paris region.
  • NOAA-NCEP/NCAR Reanalysis Data: Used for HYSPLIT model calculations.
  • AIRPARIF Inventory: Used for context on anthropogenic CO2 emissions in the Paris region.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Urban CO2 "Dome" and "Plume": At low wind speeds, local emissions create a CO2 "dome" that significantly elevates concentrations at peri-urban sites. As wind speed increases, this dome transforms into a more dispersed "plume."
  • Vertical CO2 Gradients: The study provides strong evidence for a vertical CO2 gradient above Paris, with higher concentrations near the ground, particularly at night, due to the coupling of emissions with the boundary layer dynamics.
  • MHD's Limited Representativeness: The remote Mace Head site is shown to be insufficient for accurately defining the regional CO2 background for the Paris megacity, especially at diurnal and seasonal scales, due to its distance from continental emission sources.
  • Site Elevation Matters: Stations with inlets at higher altitudes (like the Eiffel Tower) exhibit different diurnal CO2 cycles and are less directly influenced by immediate ground-level emissions, showcasing the importance of vertical profiling.
  • Designing Effective Networks: The study offers concrete recommendations for designing future urban CO2 monitoring networks, emphasizing the need for strategically placed regional background sites, careful consideration of station elevation, and high-resolution wind data.

Key Results

  • Diurnal Cycles: Mean diurnal CO2 cycles at regional stations are driven by biospheric activity, ABLH, and proximity to urban emissions. Urban and peri-urban sites show larger diurnal amplitudes and variability than rural sites.
  • Seasonal Cycles: Seasonal CO2 cycles at regional sites are influenced by biospheric and anthropogenic fluxes, ABLH, and synoptic variations. Peri-urban stations consistently show higher CO2 concentrations than rural ones, particularly in winter.
  • Wind Speed Impact: Higher wind speeds lead to ventilation and dilution of CO2 emissions, reducing concentrations. At very high wind speeds, concentrations tend towards a mean value that varies by site and reflects the surrounding urbanization.
  • Weekday vs. Weekend: CO2 concentrations are generally lower on weekends, especially at night, reflecting reduced anthropogenic activity, though this difference is less pronounced at sites with stronger biospheric influences.
  • Eiffel Tower Anomaly: The Eiffel Tower station (317m a.g.l.) exhibits a unique diurnal CO2 cycle, peaking in the mid-morning, likely due to its elevation and strong coupling with the evolving boundary layer.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Nighttime Data for EIF: The study acknowledges a lack of nighttime data at the Eiffel Tower, which limits a deeper analysis of ABL dynamics and turbulence's role in CO2 variability.
  • Disentangling Fluxes: It remains challenging to fully separate the contributions of anthropogenic and biospheric CO2 fluxes, and different emission sectors.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to equip the Eiffel Tower with additional sampling levels to better characterize vertical CO2 profiles and their relationship with ground emissions and atmospheric dynamics. They also suggest the need for carbon isotopic measurements and co-emitted species monitoring to better attribute CO2 sources. Further research is recommended for developing more sophisticated urban mesoscale modeling frameworks to accurately reproduce vertical CO2 gradients and improve inversion modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Most of the global fossil fuel CO2 emissions arise from urbanized and industrialized areas. Bottom-up inventories quantify them but with large uncertainties. In 2010–2011, the first atmospheric in situ CO2 measurement network for Paris, the capital of France, began operating with the aim of monitoring the regional atmospheric impact of the emissions coming from this megacity. Five stations sampled air along a northeast–southwest axis that corresponds to the direction of the dominant winds. Two stations are classified as rural (Traînou – TRN; Montgé-en-Goële – MON), two are peri-urban (Gonesse – GON; Gif-sur-Yvette – GIF) and one is urban (EIF, located on top of the Eiffel Tower). In this study, we analyze the diurnal, synoptic and seasonal variability of the in situ CO2 measurements over nearly 1 year (8 August 2010–13 July 2011). We compare these datasets with remote CO2 measurements made at Mace Head (MHD) on the Atlantic coast of Ireland and support our analysis with atmospheric boundary layer height (ABLH) observations made in the center of Paris and with both modeled and observed meteorological fields. The average hourly CO2 diurnal cycles observed at the regional stations are mostly driven by the CO2 biospheric cycle, the ABLH cycle and the proximity to urban CO2 emissions. Differences of several µmol mol−1 (ppm) can be observed from one regional site to the other. The more the site is surrounded by urban sources (mostly residential and commercial heating, and traffic), the more the CO2 concentration is elevated, as is the associated variability which reflects the variability of the urban sources. Furthermore, two sites with inlets high above ground level (EIF and TRN) show a phase shift of the CO2 diurnal cycle of a few hours compared to lower sites due to a strong coupling with the boundary layer diurnal cycle. As a consequence, the existence of a CO2 vertical gradient above Paris can be inferred, whose amplitude depends on the time of the day and on the season, ranging from a few tenths of ppm during daytime to several ppm during nighttime. The CO2 seasonal cycle inferred from monthly means at our regional sites is driven by the biospheric and anthropogenic CO2 flux seasonal cycles, the ABLH seasonal cycle and also synoptic variations. Enhancements of several ppm are observed at peri-urban stations compared to rural ones, mostly from the influence of urban emissions that are in the footprint of the peri-urban station. The seasonal cycle observed at the urban station (EIF) is specific and very sensitive to the ABLH cycle. At both the diurnal and the seasonal scales, noticeable differences of several ppm are observed between the measurements made at regional rural stations and the remote measurements made at MHD, that are shown not to define background concentrations appropriately for quantifying the regional (∼ 100 km) atmospheric impact of urban CO2 emissions. For wind speeds less than 3 m s−1, the accumulation of local CO2 emissions in the urban atmosphere forms a dome of several tens of ppm at the peri-urban stations, mostly under the influence of relatively local emissions including those from the Charles de Gaulle (CDG) Airport facility and from aircraft in flight. When wind speed increases, ventilation transforms the CO2 dome into a plume. Higher CO2 background concentrations of several ppm are advected from the remote Benelux–Ruhr and London regions, impacting concentrations at the five stations of the network even at wind speeds higher than 9 m s−1. For wind speeds ranging between 3 and 8 m s−1, the impact of Paris emissions can be detected in the peri-urban stations when they are downwind of the city, while the rural stations often seem disconnected from the city emission plume. As a conclusion, our study highlights a high sensitivity of the stations to wind speed and direction, to their distance from the city, but also to the ABLH cycle depending on their elevation. We learn some lessons regarding the design of an urban CO2 network: (1) careful attention should be paid to properly setting regional (∼ 100 km) background sites that will be representative of the different wind sectors; (2) the downwind stations should be positioned as symmetrically as possible in relation to the city center, at the peri-urban/rural border; (3) the stations should be installed at ventilated sites (away from strong local sources) and the air inlet set up above the building or biospheric canopy layer, whichever is the highest; and (4) high-resolution wind information should be available with the CO2 measurements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xuerefremy2018diurnal,
  author = {Irène Xueref-Rémy and Elsa Dieudonné and C. Vuillemin and Morgan Lopez and Christine Lac and Martina Schmidt and Marc Delmotte and Frédéric Chevallier and François Ravetta and Olivier Perrussel and Philippe Ciais and François‐Marie Bréon and Grégoire Broquet and Michel Ramonet and T. Gerard Spain and Christophe Ampè},
  title = {{Diurnal, synoptic and seasonal variability of atmospheric CO <sub>2</sub> in the Paris megacity area}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-18-3335-2018},
}
Figure