DITCHES AND PONDS CAN BE THE SOURCES OR SINKS OF NON-POINT SOURCE POLLUTION: OBSERVATIONS IN AN UPLAND AREA IN THE JINGLINXI CATCHMENT, CHINA

Yiwen Wang, Lei Chen, Kaihang Zhu, Chenxi Guo, Yu Pu, Zhenyao ShenFrontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether the network of ditches and ponds in China's upland agricultural areas acts as a filter or a contributor to water pollution. The researchers found that while these systems are effective "sinks" that retain up to 20% of nutrients during the dry season, they frequently flip into "sources" of nitrogen and phosphorus during the rainy season due to rapid drainage and overflow.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Non-point source (NPS) pollution—primarily nitrogen and phosphorus runoff from agriculture—is a leading cause of water quality degradation globally. In China’s hilly regions, such as the Three Gorges Reservoir area, steep slopes and intense rainfall exacerbate this problem.

While "ditch-pond systems" (the network of small channels and reservoirs used for irrigation) are known to act like mini-wetlands that trap pollutants in lowland areas, their effectiveness in upland, mountainous terrain is poorly understood. In these high-energy environments, the same infrastructure meant to manage water might actually be accelerating the delivery of pollutants to downstream rivers. The authors sought to determine the "source-sink" status of these systems in the Jinglinxi catchment.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Spatio-temporal Analysis: They used high-resolution remote sensing data (Google Maps and ArcGIS) to compare the distribution and density of ditches and ponds between 2009 and 2019.
  2. Field Monitoring: Over a two-year period (2020–2022), the team monitored six sampling sites representing different combinations of land use (woodland vs. paddy) and ditch materials (soil vs. concrete). They measured Total Nitrogen (TN), Total Phosphorus (TP), Dissolved Phosphorus (DP), and Particulate Phosphorus (PP) at the inlets and outlets of these systems to calculate pollutant retention rates.

Datasets

  • Remote Sensing: 1:5000 scale imagery from 2009 and 2019 for infrastructure mapping.
  • Topographic/Land Use: 30m resolution Digital Elevation Models (DEM) and 2m resolution land-use maps.
  • Hydrometeorological: Daily rainfall data (2010–2020) from local meteorological bureaus.
  • Water Quality: A primary dataset of 188 observations across six sampling sites (S1–S6) collected between 2020 and 2022.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Seasonal Flip: The most critical finding is that ditches and ponds are not permanent filters. In the dry season, they are effective sinks. However, during the rainy season, high-velocity runoff scours the bottom mud of ditches and causes ponds to overflow, releasing stored nutrients and turning the system into a pollution source.
  • Infrastructure Explosion: In just 15 years, the total length of ditches in the study area increased by 32%, and the number of small ponds (<500 m²) surged by 75%. This reflects a shift toward more intensive irrigation and aquaculture (converting paddies to fish ponds).
  • Material Matters: The study compared soil ditches to concrete-lined ones. While concrete is better for drainage efficiency, soil ditches—with their associated vegetation and sediment—showed a higher capacity to absorb and intercept pollutants, particularly nitrogen.
  • The "Fertilizer-Rain" Synergy: Pollutant spikes were most dramatic when heavy rainfall occurred shortly after fertilizer application (typically March–June for rice/maize). During these windows, phosphorus loss shifted from particulate form (soil erosion) to dissolved form (direct runoff of fertilizer).

Key Results

  • Retention Capacity: In the dry season, the ditch-pond systems achieved nutrient retention rates of up to 20%.
  • Concentration Swings: The rate of change in nutrient concentrations between inlets and outlets mostly fluctuated between -20% and +20%, highlighting the delicate balance between acting as a source or a sink.
  • Phosphorus Dynamics: Particulate Phosphorus (PP) accounted for up to 96.9% of Total Phosphorus in runoff during heavy rains, emphasizing that sediment management is synonymous with phosphorus management in upland areas.
  • Infrastructure Growth: Small ponds (<500 m²) increased from 56 to 98 in the study period, indicating a trend toward fragmented, small-scale water management.

Limitations and Future Work

The study is limited to a single representative catchment (Jinglinxi), and while the findings are likely applicable to similar hilly regions in the subtropics, the specific "flip" points between source and sink may vary by soil type and slope.

The authors suggest that future "ecological engineering" should focus on optimizing these systems. This includes using more soil-based or vegetated ditches rather than concrete ones and designing ponds with better "buffer" capacities to prevent overflow during the first flush of a storm. There is also a clear need for better synchronization between fertilizer application schedules and local weather forecasts to minimize dissolved nutrient loss.

Summary updated

Abstract

● The source and sink status of ditches and ponds was studied in an upland area in the Jinglinxi catchment, China. ● Over the past 15 years, ditch length has increased by 32% and small pond number by 75%. ● Ditches and ponds are important nutrient sinks in the dry season. ● Retention of nutrients in ditches and ponds is up to 20%. As the common features of agroecosystems, ditches and ponds benefit the irrigation and drainage, as well as intercepting non-point source pollutants. However, most ditch-pond studies have been conducted in lowland areas. To test this source-sink assumption in upland areas, this study made observations on the ecological function of the ditch and pond system in a typical catchment in China. First, the changes in ponds in the catchment were analyzed using high-resolution remote sensing data. Then, the migration of agricultural pollutants in ditches and ponds were analyzed by field sampling and laboratory detection. The results showed that over the past 15 years the length of ditches in the catchment and the number of small ponds (< 500 m2) have increased by 32% and 75%, respectively. The rate of change in nutrient concentrations in the ditches and ponds were mostly from −20% to 20%, indicating ditches and ponds can be both sources and sinks for agricultural pollutants. Lastly, the contributing factors were explored and it was found that ditches and ponds are important sinks in dry season. However, during the rainy season, ditches and ponds become sources of pollutants, with the rapid drainage of ditches and the overflow of ponds in upland areas. The results of this study revealed that the ditches and ponds could be used for ecological engineering in upland catchments to balance drainage and intercept pollutants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023ditches,
  author = {Yiwen Wang and Lei Chen and Kaihang Zhu and Chenxi Guo and Yu Pu and Zhenyao Shen},
  title = {{DITCHES AND PONDS CAN BE THE SOURCES OR SINKS OF NON-POINT SOURCE POLLUTION: OBSERVATIONS IN AN UPLAND AREA IN THE JINGLINXI CATCHMENT, CHINA}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.15302/j-fase-2023517},
}
Figure