Distribution of short paired duplications in mammalian genomes

E Thomas, Nathan Srebro, Jonathan Sebat, Nicholas E. Navin, John Healy, Bud Mishra, Michael WiglerProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper identifies and characterizes a novel class of short, exact DNA duplications (25-100 bp) called "doublets" in mammalian genomes. These doublets are not random but exhibit non-random spacing, with a significant enrichment of pairs occurring very close together (adjacent) or around 1 kilobase apart (nearby), suggesting a specific, widespread genomic mechanism at play.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The evolution of genomes is significantly driven by duplication events, ranging from entire chromosomes to individual genes. While large-scale duplications like segmental duplications and the activity of transposable elements are well-studied, the role of smaller, more localized duplication events in shaping genome evolution, particularly in regulatory regions and protein-coding sequences, has been less clear. The authors aim to identify and characterize these short, exact duplications to understand their prevalence, distribution, and potential evolutionary impact.

Methods

The core of the methodology involves identifying "doublets" – pairs of identical DNA sequences (cores) of 25-100 bp that occur at least twice in a genome. To distinguish these from random occurrences or larger repeat structures, several filtering steps were applied:

  • Core Identification: Identifying exact matches of at least 25 bp.
  • Uniqueness of Flanks: Requiring that the sequences immediately flanking the cores (100 bp on each side) be unique in the genome to avoid capturing parts of larger, approximate duplications.
  • Homology Filtering: Using alignment scores to filter out pairs with significant homology between their flanking regions, and also using BLAST to exclude pairs homologous to known expressed sequences (to avoid processed pseudogenes).
  • Intercore Distance Analysis: For doublets on the same chromosome, the distance between the two cores (the "spacer") was calculated. This distribution was compared against two null models: one assuming uniform core distribution and another assuming random re-pairing of existing cores.
  • Cross-Species Comparison: The human genome was compared with the chimpanzee genome to assess the conservation and evolutionary age of these doublets.

Datasets

  • Human Genome: April 2003 assembly from the University of California, Santa Cruz.
  • Chimpanzee Genome: December 2003 Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research assembly.
  • Mouse Genome: NCBI Build 30.
  • C. elegans Genome: WS110 from WORMBASE.
  • Drosophila melanogaster Genome: Release 3-1 from FLYBASE.
  • Plasmodium falciparum Genome: Sanger center data.
  • Arabidopsis thaliana Genome: NCBI data.
  • NCBI est_human database: Used for homology filtering.
  • Repbase Update database: Used for transposon consensus sequences.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitous Short Duplications: Mammalian genomes are not just populated by large repeats but also by a significant number of short, exact duplications ("doublets").
  • Non-Random Spacing: The distribution of distances between these paired sequences is strikingly non-random, with a strong enrichment for pairs that are very close (adjacent, ≤100 bp) or around 1 kb apart (nearby). This suggests a specific mechanism, not random chance.
  • Polarity Conservation: Adjacent doublets are almost always direct repeats (same strand), and nearby doublets also show a strong tendency to be on the same strand (~70%), indicating a mechanism that preserves the orientation of the duplicated sequence.
  • Dynamic Nature of Adjacent Doublets: Doublets found only in humans ("young") are more likely to be adjacent and nearly tandem, while older doublets (shared with chimpanzees) are more likely to have the ~1 kb spacing. This suggests that adjacent, nearly tandem duplications might be more dynamic and prone to change or loss.
  • Widespread Mechanism: The presence of recognizable doublets in diverse organisms like Arabidopsis thaliana and Caenorhabditis elegans points to a conserved and widespread mechanism for generating these short duplications across eukaryotes.

Key Results

  • 32,057 Human Doublets Identified: After rigorous filtering, 32,057 paired sequences (doublets) were identified in the human genome.
  • Short Core Lengths: 99.9% of these doublets have core sequences less than 100 bp, with over half being exactly 25 bp.
  • Enrichment of Proximate Doublets: The number of adjacent (≤100 bp) and nearby (100 bp - 10 kb) doublets is significantly higher than expected by chance, suggesting they are not coincidental.
  • Conservation of Spacing: The ~1 kb spacing for older doublets is highly conserved between human and chimpanzee.
  • Gain of New Copies: Comparison with chimpanzee suggests that many nearby doublets in humans represent recent insertions (gains of new copies) rather than losses in chimpanzees.
  • Diverse Organism Presence: Doublets were found in Homo sapiens, Mus musculus, Arabidopsis thaliana, and Caenorhabditis elegans, indicating a conserved mechanism.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exact Match Bias: The study focused on exact matches, meaning older, more diverged duplications were likely missed. The authors suggest that at least four times as many shorter duplications (≥21 bp) exist.
  • Chimpanzee Assembly: A more complete chimpanzee genome assembly would help resolve ambiguities regarding the origin of doublets.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: While the data strongly suggest a duplication mechanism, the precise molecular mechanism remains to be fully elucidated. A model involving double-strand breaks and subsequent repair is proposed for adjacent doublets, but a clear mechanism for nearby doublets is still sought.
  • Functional Impact: The authors hypothesize that these short duplications could profoundly impact the evolution of regulatory and protein-coding sequences, but further studies are needed to explore this.
  • Relaxing Exactness: Future work could involve relaxing the requirement for exact identity between cores to gain a broader understanding of short duplications and their mutational dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mammalian genomes are densely populated with long duplicated sequences. In this paper, we demonstrate the existence of doublets, short duplications between 25 and 100 bp, distinct from previously described repeats. Each doublet is a pair of exact matches, separated by some distance. The distribution of these intermatch distances is strikingly nonrandom. An unexpectedly high number of doublets have matches either within 100 bp (adjacent) or at distances tightly concentrated approximately 1,000 bp apart (nearby). We focus our study on these proximate doublets. First, they tend to have both matches on the same strand. By comparing nearby doublets shared in human and chimpanzee, we can also see that these doublets seem to arise by an insertion event that produces a copy without markedly affecting the surrounding sequence. Most doublets in humans are shared with chimpanzee, but many new pairs arose after the divergence of the species. Doublets found in human but not chimpanzee are most often composed of almost tandem matches, whereas older doublets (found in both species) are more likely to have matches spaced by approximately 1 kb, indicating that the nearly tandem doublets may be more dynamic. The spacing of doublets is highly conserved. So far, we have found clearly recognizable doublets in the following genomes: Homo sapiens, Mus musculus, Arabidopsis thaliana, and Caenorhabditis elegans, indicating that the mechanism generating these doublets is widespread. A mechanism that generates short local duplications while conserving polarity could have a profound impact on the evolution of regulatory and protein-coding sequences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{thomas2004distribution,
  author = {E Thomas and Nathan Srebro and Jonathan Sebat and Nicholas E. Navin and John Healy and Bud Mishra and Michael Wigler},
  title = {{Distribution of short paired duplications in mammalian genomes}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.0403727101},
}
Figure