Distribution of Shallow Isochronous Layers in East Antarctica Inferred from Frequency-Modulated Continuous-Wave (FMCW) Radar

Wangxiao Yang, Yinke Dou, Shinan Lang, Jingxue Guo, Guangyu Zuo, Yan Chen, Yuchen WangAnnals 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel application of Frequency-Modulated Continuous-Wave (FMCW) radar to map shallow (within ~100m) isochronous ice layers across a significant transect in East Antarctica. By developing a refined wave velocity model and calibrating with ice core data, the researchers achieved a high-precision depth estimation, revealing distinct variations in layer distribution and stability across different Antarctic regions, crucial for understanding ice sheet dynamics and past climate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the history of ice sheets, particularly their accumulation rates and flow dynamics, is vital for reconstructing past climates and predicting future changes. Isochronous layers within glaciers, representing annual or event-specific deposition, serve as invaluable markers for this. However, accurately identifying and mapping these shallow layers over large distances has been challenging. Traditional radar systems often struggle with the resolution needed for these shallow depths, while existing methods for depth estimation can be imprecise due to variations in ice density and wave propagation speed. This paper aims to address this by demonstrating the effectiveness of FMCW radar for high-resolution shallow ice layer mapping and by developing a more accurate method for depth calibration.

Methods

The study employed a Frequency-Modulated Continuous-Wave (FMCW) radar system mounted on a snowmobile for data acquisition across a ~1280 km transect in East Antarctica. The data processing involved a multi-stage approach:

  • Signal Processing: A pipeline including removal of coherent noise, Fast Fourier Transform (FFT), Hanning windowing, low-pass filtering, median filtering, and removal of direct waves was applied to enhance signal quality and suppress interference. A key step was the application of a curvelet transform to further attenuate noise and extract layer features.
  • Wave Velocity Model: A crucial aspect was the development of a dynamic wave velocity model. Instead of assuming a constant velocity, the researchers used an empirical formula to estimate the relative dielectric constant of firn/ice based on density, which in turn was modeled as a function of depth using a densification model. This allowed for depth calculation based on two-way travel time (TWT).
  • Calibration and Validation: The calculated depths were rigorously calibrated and validated against volcanic eruption records found in the DT263 ice core. This comparison allowed for error analysis and refinement of the depth estimation, achieving a relative error of approximately 5%.
  • Layer Mapping and Analysis: Isochronous layers were then mapped and tracked across different regions, including Dome A, an area 100 km from Dome A, and the Lambert Glacier. The continuity, stability, and folding patterns of these layers were analyzed in relation to elevation changes and regional characteristics.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study was collected using the FMCW sounding radar during the 32nd Chinese National Antarctic Research Expedition (CHINARE 32) along a ~1280 km transect from Zhongshan Station to Kunlun Station in East Antarctica.

For calibration and validation, the study utilized data from the DT263 ice core, specifically its record of volcanic eruptions. This ice core provided known age-depth markers (e.g., Krakatoa eruption in AD1884) that were compared with the radar-derived depths of corresponding isochronous layers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FMCW Radar's High-Resolution Capability: The study demonstrates that FMCW radar, with its specific bandwidth and sweep period, is highly effective at resolving shallow isochronous layers within the top ~100 meters of the ice sheet, a depth range often challenging for other radar systems.
  • Importance of a Dynamic Velocity Model: The paper highlights that a simple, constant wave velocity model is insufficient for accurate depth estimation in ice sheets. Developing a depth-dependent velocity model that accounts for firn densification and varying ice density significantly improves accuracy.
  • Volcanic Records as Precise Calibration Tools: The use of well-dated volcanic eruption markers in ice cores proved to be a powerful method for calibrating radar-derived depths, leading to a high degree of confidence in the results (approx. 5% relative error).
  • Regional Variability in Ice Layer Structure: The research reveals significant differences in the continuity and stability of isochronous layers across different Antarctic regions. Dome A exhibits relatively flat and stable layers, while the Lambert Glacier shows more pronounced folding and volatility, likely linked to variations in accumulation rates and ice flow dynamics.
  • Folding as an Indicator of Ice Dynamics: The observed folding and convergence of isochronous layers, particularly near Dome A, are interpreted as evidence of local layer mixing and compression, potentially caused by ice flow and wind-driven processes.

Key Results

  • The FMCW radar system successfully obtained clear echograms of shallow isochronous layers within ~100 meters of depth.
  • The developed wave velocity model, calibrated with ice core DT263 volcanic records, achieved a relative error of approximately 5% in depth estimation.
  • Analysis of isochronous layers in three distinct regions (Dome A, 100 km from Dome A, and Lambert Glacier) showed significant differences:
  • Dome A: Relatively stable and flat layers.
  • Lambert Glacier: More volatile and folded layers.
  • Area 100 km from Dome A: Layers were less effectively extracted, suggesting potential challenges in this region.
  • The study provides data that can support the calculation of large-scale accumulation rates and ice flow history in the Antarctic.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Elevation Influence: The paper acknowledges that significant elevation changes (exceeding 4000 m over the transect) can influence radar signals and layer interpretation. While elevation was considered for individual regions, its impact over very large scales requires further investigation.
  • Shrinkage Zones: In some areas, particularly around Dome A, the continuity of isochronous layers was difficult to track due to "shrinkage areas" or convergence phenomena, which are attributed to ice flow and compression. Further research is needed to fully understand the mechanisms behind these features.
  • Regional Differences and Accumulation Rates: The observed differences in layer distribution and stability across regions strongly suggest varying accumulation rates. The authors propose that further analyses incorporating geographic and meteorological factors are needed to fully explain these differences.
  • Three-Dimensional Distribution: While the study presents 2D profiles, the authors suggest that combining multiple investigations could enable the plotting of three-dimensional distributions of specific isochronous layers, offering a more comprehensive understanding of ice sheet dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

During the 32nd Chinese National Antarctic Research Expedition, the Frequency-Modulated Continuous-Wave (FMCW) radar was used for the first time to obtain the distribution of shallow isochronous layers within the East Antarctic region extending from Zhongshan Station to Kunlun Station. Taking a typical area as a case study, this article describes the complete workflow used in radar data processing, including signal processing and extraction of isochronous layers. The wave velocity model is established according to an empirical formula to calculate the depth of the layer, and the result is compared and corrected with the volcanic record in ice core DT263; the relative error of depth is only approximately 5%. The echograms of the isochronous layers in three regions are presented, including the area around the Dome A, the area 100 km from the Dome A and the area in the Lambert Glacier. A comparison of the echograms within the three regions shows that the isochronous layers are relatively stable in the Dome A and change more intensely in the Lambert Glacier, while the folding of the layer occurs in a concentrated area near Dome A. This folding may be due to the local layer mixing and compression caused by the ice flow and wind-driven processes. The analysis of the distribution of the shallow isochronous layers and age-depth information from different regions provides important data that support the calculation of large-scale accumulation rates and flow history in the Antarctic.
BibTeX
@article{yang2019distribution,
  author = {Wangxiao Yang and Yinke Dou and Shinan Lang and Jingxue Guo and Guangyu Zuo and Yan Chen and Yuchen Wang},
  title = {{Distribution of Shallow Isochronous Layers in East Antarctica Inferred from Frequency-Modulated Continuous-Wave (FMCW) Radar}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.4401/ag-7794},
}
Figure