Distribution and Preservation of Total Organic Carbon and Total Inorganic Carbon in Pipahai Lake over the Past Century

Zhilei Zhen, Lishuai Xu, Wenhao GaoWater 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the historical trends and influencing factors of total organic carbon (TOC) and total inorganic carbon (TIC) in Pipahai Lake sediments over the past century. The findings reveal that while TOC content generally increased with decreasing depth, its fluctuations are more influenced by temperature than precipitation, with evidence suggesting a shift in nutrient influence after 1996.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lakes play a critical role in the global carbon cycle, acting as significant carbon sinks. Understanding how carbon is buried and how these processes change over time is crucial for predicting future climate change. High-altitude alpine lakes, like Pipahai Lake, are particularly valuable for this research because their relatively simple watersheds can act as sensitive recorders of environmental changes, including climate shifts and human activities. While previous research has explored various aspects of alpine lake ecosystems, the specific historical dynamics of both organic and inorganic carbon burial in Pipahai Lake and the factors driving these changes over the last century remained largely unaddressed. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by reconstructing the carbon burial history and identifying the key drivers.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-indicator approach using sediment core samples collected from Pipahai Lake. To establish a precise timeline, they utilized 210Pb and 137Cs dating techniques. These radioactive isotopes, with known decay rates, allow for the reconstruction of sediment deposition chronology. For elemental analysis, including total carbon (TC) and total organic carbon (TOC), they used a TOC analyzer and a microwave digestion system followed by high-resolution inductively coupled plasma emission spectrometry. Total inorganic carbon (TIC) was calculated by subtracting TOC from TC. Grain size analysis was performed using a laser particle analyzer. To understand the influence of human activities, they correlated sediment data with historical socioeconomic data such as population size, agricultural land use, and industrial output.

Datasets

The study utilized sediment core samples (P1, P2, and P3) from Pipahai Lake. These cores provided the primary dataset for analyzing TOC, TIC, and elemental composition over time. Additionally, historical socioeconomic data for Ningwu County, including sown area of grain crops, population size, heavy livestock numbers, and gross industrial output value, were obtained from the Shanxi Provincial Bureau of Statistics and the Ningwu County Annals. This socioeconomic data served as a proxy for human activity over the past century.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TOC as a primary indicator: The study highlights that TOC content was consistently higher than TIC, suggesting organic matter accumulation is a dominant carbon burial process in Pipahai Lake.
  • Depth vs. Carbon: A consistent trend of increasing TOC and TIC with decreasing depth (i.e., more recent sediments) was observed, indicating a general increase in carbon deposition over the past century.
  • Temperature's subtle hand: While both temperature and precipitation influence TOC, temperature appears to have a more significant, albeit complex, role. The relationship isn't straightforward, suggesting other factors are also at play.
  • Nutrient shift: Before 1996, nutrients were not the primary driver of TOC changes. However, after 1996, there's evidence suggesting nutrients began to play a more significant role, potentially linked to increased algal growth.
  • External inputs matter: The synchronous changes in TIC and TOC before 1996 point towards a strong influence of external inputs (like wind-borne dust) on carbon burial.
  • Human activity's footprint: The study strongly suggests that human activities, particularly industrial development and changes in land use, have significantly impacted TOC levels in the lake.

Key Results

  • TOC content in the sediment cores ranged from 21.05 to 54.77 mg/g, with average values around 39-44 mg/g.
  • TIC content ranged from 0 to 26.61 mg/g, with average values between 10.74 and 15.05 mg/g.
  • Linear regression showed a weak correlation between TOC and precipitation (R = 0.39) but a stronger one with temperature (R = 0.58).
  • The 100Ti/Al ratio, an indicator of aeolian transport, showed a decreasing trend generally consistent with precipitation, but with specific increases correlating with periods of stable wind and no significant TOC/TIC fluctuations, suggesting wind as a primary input source.
  • Post-1996, an increase in phosphorus (P) content correlated with increased TOC and TIC, suggesting a shift towards nutrient-driven processes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that studying only one lake from the Tianchi alpine lake group might limit the generalizability of their findings. Future work should involve comparative analyses of sediment cores from multiple lakes within the group to better understand regional carbon deposition processes. Additionally, instrumental climate data only extends back to 1950, necessitating the use of additional proxy indicators to reconstruct climate influences on sedimentary conditions prior to this period. The study also suggests that further investigation into the specific mechanisms of TIC formation and its relationship with TOC and autochthonous processes would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon burial patterns in lakes and their dynamic changes significantly impact terrestrial carbon sink fluxes and global carbon budgets. In this study, multi-indicator analysis of sediment core samples (P1, P2, and P3) from Pipahai Lake was conducted. Integrating the chronological sequences of 210Pb and 137Cs, we identified the historical changes and spatial characteristics of total organic carbon (TOC) and inorganic carbon (TIC) burial in Pipahai Lake since 1884. The results show that the TOC content was higher than that of the TIC. They exhibited an increasing trend with decreasing depth. Linear regression results indicated that the variation of TOC is less directly affected by precipitation (R = 0.39) and temperature (R = 0.58), while temperature may have a greater impact on TOC. From 1884 to 1995, nutrients were not the primary factor influencing changes in TOC. The synchronous variation in TIC and TOC contents reflects a higher contribution of external inputs to carbon burial in the Pipahai Lake basin. After 1996, nutrients may have begun to affect variations in TOC. The TOC primarily originates from distal aeolian transport or autochthonous sources, though human activity has played a role in its evolution. The TIC content is controlled by the TOC content and autochthonous sources. This study will contribute to the understanding of the carbon cycling dynamics and their influencing mechanisms in a high-altitude lake ecosystem.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhen2024distribution,
  author = {Zhilei Zhen and Lishuai Xu and Wenhao Gao},
  title = {{Distribution and Preservation of Total Organic Carbon and Total Inorganic Carbon in Pipahai Lake over the Past Century}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/w16213064},
}
Figure