Distribution and Characterization of Typical Antibiotics in Water Bodies of the Yellow River Estuary and Their Ecological Risks

Jindong Wang, Zhenfei Yan, Yu Qiao, Daqing Liu, Chenglian Feng, Yingchen BaiToxics 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the presence and ecological risks of 14 common antibiotics in the Yellow River Estuary, revealing widespread contamination primarily from agricultural and domestic sources. While most detected antibiotics pose a low ecological risk, clarithromycin and doxycycline hydrochloride warrant attention as medium-risk contaminants, highlighting the need for targeted pollution control strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Yellow River, a vital water source for China, faces significant pollution challenges, including the pervasive presence of antibiotics. These compounds, essential for human and animal health, can enter aquatic environments through various pathways, including wastewater discharge and agricultural runoff. Their persistence and potential to disrupt aquatic ecosystems and contribute to antimicrobial resistance pose a serious threat. While antibiotic pollution in other parts of the Yellow River Basin has been studied, there's a notable gap in understanding the specific distribution, sources, and ecological risks within the Yellow River Estuary itself, a critical area for ecological balance and water supply. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a comprehensive assessment of antibiotic contamination in this region.

Methods

The researchers employed an optimized solid-phase extraction (SPE) technique for sample pre-treatment, followed by analysis using an Agilent 6410B tandem triple-quadrupole liquid chromatography-mass spectrometer (LC-MS/MS). This combination allows for sensitive and specific detection of a wide range of antibiotics. For ecological risk assessment, they utilized the risk quotient (RQ) method, a standard approach that compares measured environmental concentrations (MEC) with predicted no-effect concentrations (PNEC). PNEC values were derived from literature data and toxicity endpoints (EC50/LC50) using appropriate assessment factors (AF). The study analyzed 34 antibiotics across five major classes: macrolides, sulfonamides, quinolones, tetracyclines, and chloramphenicol.

Datasets

The study collected eight water samples from different points within the Yellow River Estuary in September 2022. These samples were analyzed for the presence of 34 target antibiotics. The ecological risk assessment relied on toxicity data for 14 of these antibiotics, sourced from existing literature, to derive PNEC values. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitous Antibiotic Presence: The Yellow River Estuary is not immune to antibiotic contamination; 14 out of 34 targeted antibiotics were detected, indicating widespread presence.
  • Lincomycin Hydrochloride Dominance: This specific antibiotic showed a particularly high detection rate, suggesting it's a significant contributor to the overall antibiotic load in the estuary.
  • Farming and Domestic Sewage as Primary Sources: The study strongly implicates agricultural activities (wastewater from farming) and domestic sewage as the main drivers of antibiotic pollution in the estuary.
  • Human Activity Correlation: The distribution patterns of antibiotics are closely linked to the intensity of farming and other human social activities in the surrounding areas.
  • Differential Ecological Risks: While many antibiotics are present at low concentrations, a few stand out. Clarithromycin and doxycycline hydrochloride pose a medium ecological risk, while others are at a low risk level, suggesting a need for prioritized management.

Key Results

  • 14 Antibiotics Detected: Out of 34 antibiotics tested, 14 were detected in the Yellow River Estuary water bodies.
  • High Detection Rate for Lincomycin Hydrochloride: This antibiotic was detected with a high frequency.
  • Concentration Levels: Sulfonamides, macrolides, and quinolones were the most prevalent antibiotic classes detected. Lincomycin hydrochloride had the highest detected concentration at a single site (83.31 ng/L).
  • Ecological Risk Assessment:
    • Medium Risk: Clarithromycin and Doxycycline hydrochloride were identified as posing a medium ecological risk (0.1 < RQ < 1).
  • Low Risk: Lincomycin hydrochloride, sulfamethoxazole, ofloxacin, enrofloxacin, sulfadiazine, roxithromycin, sulfapyridine, and ciprofloxacin were found to pose a low ecological risk (RQ < 0.1).
  • Comparison to Other Regions: The antibiotic concentration levels in the Yellow River Estuary were found to be moderate when compared to other sections of the Yellow River Basin, which exhibited significantly higher concentrations in some areas.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that two of the 14 detected antibiotics (azithromycin and sulphonamide acetate) could not be fully evaluated for ecological risk due to a lack of available toxicity data for deriving PNEC values. This highlights a broader challenge in comprehensive environmental risk assessment for emerging contaminants.

Future work could focus on:

  • Expanding the scope of antibiotics analyzed to include a wider range of emerging contaminants.
  • Conducting more detailed source apportionment studies to pinpoint specific agricultural and industrial contributors.
  • Investigating the fate and transformation of these antibiotics within the estuary ecosystem.
  • Assessing the combined ecological effects of multiple antibiotic co-contaminants.
  • Developing and implementing targeted pollution control measures based on the identified risks and sources.

Summary updated

Abstract

A total of 34 antibiotics from five major classes of antibiotics, including macrolides, sulfonamides, quinolones, tetracyclines and chloramphenicol, were considered as contaminants, considering the Yellow River Estuary as the study area. The distribution, sources and ecological risks of typical antibiotics in the Yellow River Estuary were investigated using an optimized solid-phase extraction pre-treatment and an Agilent 6410B tandem triple-quadrupole liquid chromatography-mass spectrometer for antibiotic detection. The results show that antibiotics were widely present in the water bodies of the Yellow River Estuary, with 14 antibiotics detected to varying degrees, including a high detection rate for lincomycin hydrochloride. Farming wastewater and domestic sewage were the primary sources of antibiotics in the Yellow River Estuary. The distribution characteristics of antibiotics in the study area were linked to the development of farming and social activities. The ecological risk evaluation of 14 antibiotics in the Yellow River Estuary watershed showed that clarithromycin and doxycycline hydrochloride were present at medium-risk levels, and lincomycin hydrochloride, sulfamethoxazole, methomyl, oxifloxacin, enrofloxacin, sulfadiazine, roxithromycin, sulfapyridine, sulfadiazine and ciprofloxacin were present at low-risk levels in the samples collected from water bodies of the Yellow River Estuary. This study provides novel, beneficial information for the assessment of the ecological risk presented by antibiotics in the Yellow River Estuary water bodies and provides a scientific basis for future antibiotic pollution control in the Yellow River Basin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023distribution,
  author = {Jindong Wang and Zhenfei Yan and Yu Qiao and Daqing Liu and Chenglian Feng and Yingchen Bai},
  title = {{Distribution and Characterization of Typical Antibiotics in Water Bodies of the Yellow River Estuary and Their Ecological Risks}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics11050400},
}
Figure