Distributing Labels on Infinite Trees

Nicolas Gast, Bruno GaujalarXiv 2008 · arXiv

Abstract

This paper explores the mathematical intersection of combinatorics on words and graph theory, specifically focusing on the distribution of labels across infinite tree structures. By generalizing the concept of Sturmian words to trees, the authors provide a robust framework for creating "balanced" distributions. They demonstrate that "mechanical" trees, constructed via simple floor-function formulas, are the tree-equivalents of optimal linear sequences and are highly effective for solving extremal scheduling problems in distributed systems.

Introduction

In computational fields like operations research, scheduling tasks "as regularly as possible" is a fundamental challenge. For linear sequences, Sturmian words—sequences that are perfectly balanced and minimally complex—provide the ideal solution. A sequence is balanced if the number of specific labels (e.g., tasks) in any two segments of the same length differs by at most one.

However, many modern computational structures, such as recursive programs or distributed systems with causal dependencies, are better modeled as trees. Previous attempts to define "Sturmian trees" often focused on factor complexity at the expense of the balance property. This paper bridges that gap, establishing a theory of trees that are simultaneously balanced, mechanical, and minimally complex.

Methodology

The authors utilize several distinct mathematical frameworks to develop their theory:

  • Unordered Trees: A key insight is treating the children of a node as indistinguishable. This "unordered" approach avoids the combinatorial explosion of patterns and allows the recovery of the elegant properties of Sturmian words.
  • Mechanical Construction: The authors define trees using an affine function: the number of labels in a subtree is determined by $\lfloor S(n)\alpha + \phi \rfloor$, where $S(n)$ is the subtree size, $\alpha$ is the density, and $\phi$ is a phase offset.
  • Graph Theory and Markov Chains: For "rational" trees (those with a finite number of distinct subtrees), the structure is represented as a graph $G(T)$. This graph acts as a transition kernel for a Markov chain, allowing the label density to be calculated as a stationary measure.
A rational tree and its associated state graph G(T) used for density analysis.
  • Algorithmic Analysis: The paper provides an $O(N^3)$ algorithm to test if a given rational tree is "strongly balanced," where $N$ is the number of vertices in the tree's minimal graph.

Key Insights and Ideas

The research demonstrates that for unordered trees, the three classic definitions of Sturmian words—balanced, mechanical, and minimal complexity—converge, mirroring their behavior in linear sequences.

A critical distinction is made between weak balance (comparing subtrees of the same height) and strong balance (comparing subtrees of the same height and width). The authors prove that mechanical trees are always strongly balanced. Furthermore, they show that for irrational densities, a tree is strongly balanced if and only if it is mechanical, providing a constructive method for building perfectly regular infinite trees.

Another example of a tree and its state-transition graph.

Key Results

  • Equivalence Proofs: Mechanical trees are shown to be strongly balanced and possess minimal factor complexity ($P(n) = n + 1$).
  • Complexity Bounds: The number of distinct factors of size $n$ in these trees grows linearly, significantly slower than the exponential growth typical of random trees.
  • Scheduling Optimality: Strongly balanced trees are identified as extremal points for certain convex cost functions. Practically, this means that in tree-shaped task dependencies, a strongly balanced distribution of tasks to processors minimizes average flow time or latency.

Limitations and Future Work

While the unordered assumption is mathematically powerful, many real-world data structures (like binary search trees) are ordered. Extending this theory to ordered trees remains an open challenge. Additionally, the current work focuses on binary labels; generalizing to $k$ labels increases complexity significantly. Finally, while the authors suggest these trees are extreme points for multimodular functions, a full proof for more general stochastic arrival patterns is left for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sturmian words are infinite binary words with many equivalent definitions: They have a minimal factor complexity among all aperiodic sequences; they are balanced sequences (the labels 0 and 1 are as evenly distributed as possible) and they can be constructed using a mechanical definition. All this properties make them good candidates for being extremal points in scheduling problems over two processors. In this paper, we consider the problem of generalizing Sturmian words to trees. The problem is to evenly distribute labels 0 and 1 over infinite trees. We show that (strongly) balanced trees exist and can also be constructed using a mechanical process as long as the tree is irrational. Such trees also have a minimal factor complexity. Therefore they bring the hope that extremal scheduling properties of Sturmian words can be extended to such trees, as least partially. Such possible extensions are illustrated by one such example.
BibTeX
@misc{gast2008distributing,
  author = {Nicolas Gast and Bruno Gaujal},
  title = {{Distributing Labels on Infinite Trees}},
  year = {2008},
  eprint = {0809.1989},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0809.1989},
}
Figure