Distributed Variational Representation Learning

Inaki Estella Aguerri, Abdellatif ZaidiIEEE TPAMI 2018 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper extends the Information Bottleneck (IB) framework to a distributed setting where multiple sources of information collectively learn about a target variable. They introduce a novel variational bound and two algorithms (Blahut-Arimoto and variational inference) to optimize this bound, enabling efficient distributed representation learning for both discrete and Gaussian data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of distributed representation learning. Imagine you have data from multiple sources (e.g., different sensors, different types of features from an image). Instead of combining all this data into one massive chunk, you want to process each source separately using "encoders" and then combine their compressed representations to learn about a common underlying "ground truth" variable. This is crucial in scenarios where data is naturally distributed or privacy concerns prevent centralizing it. The core problem is how to design these individual encoders so that, collectively, they extract the most relevant information about the target variable while minimizing the complexity (or redundancy) of their representations. This is a generalization of the well-established Information Bottleneck (IB) principle, which deals with a single source.

Methods

The authors generalize Tishby's centralized Information Bottleneck (IB) method to a Distributed Information Bottleneck (DIB) framework for $K \ge 2$ encoders. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Information-Theoretic Characterization: They derive theoretical characterizations of the optimal trade-off between complexity (measured by mutual information between the observation and the representation) and relevance (mutual information between the representation and the target variable) for both discrete memoryless sources and vector Gaussian models.
  • Variational Bound: A novel variational bound is developed that generalizes the Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO) and the $\beta$-VAE cost to the distributed setting. This bound allows for optimization even when the exact data distributions are unknown.
  • Two Algorithms:
    1. Blahut-Arimoto (BA-DIB): An iterative algorithm that converges to optimal encoding mappings by solving self-consistent equations. This is suitable when data distributions are known or can be accurately estimated.
  • Variational Inference (D-VIB): An algorithm that uses deep neural networks (DNNs) to parameterize encoders and decoders. The variational bound is approximated using Monte Carlo sampling and optimized with stochastic gradient descent. This is more practical for large, high-dimensional datasets.

Datasets

The paper uses the following datasets for evaluation:

  • Synthetic Datasets: Specifically, a vector Gaussian data model is used for experiments.
  • Real Datasets:
    • Handwritten MNIST Dataset: A two-view version of MNIST is created for classification tasks. View 1 is generated by occluding the original image, and View 2 is created by adding noise to a randomly selected image of the same digit.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Collective Optimization is Key: In the distributed setting, encoders must be optimized collectively to achieve the best overall trade-off between relevance and complexity, not just individually.
  • Variational Bound as a Unifying Principle: The proposed variational bound elegantly unifies concepts from IB, ELBO, and $\beta$-VAE, providing a principled way to tackle distributed representation learning.
  • DNNs for Scalability: Using DNNs within a variational inference framework (D-VIB) makes the approach scalable to complex, high-dimensional data where analytical solutions are intractable.
  • Regularization's Role: The complexity constraint (regularization) is shown to be crucial for improving generalization and preventing overfitting, especially in the D-VIB approach.
  • Trade-off Dynamics: The paper visualizes how the relevance-complexity trade-off evolves during training, revealing different trajectory types depending on the regularization parameter.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Characterizations: Explicit analytical characterizations of optimal relevance-complexity trade-offs are derived for discrete memoryless and vector Gaussian models.
  • Algorithm Performance: Both the BA-DIB and D-VIB algorithms demonstrate the ability to achieve near-optimal relevance-complexity trade-offs on synthetic (vector Gaussian) and real (MNIST) datasets.
  • D-VIB Generalization: The D-VIB algorithm shows good generalization performance, particularly with larger training datasets, and its performance is competitive with or superior to centralized approaches (C-VIB) and baseline methods.
  • MNIST Classification: On the two-view MNIST dataset, D-VIB achieves high classification accuracy (e.g., >97% average accuracy), demonstrating its effectiveness in multi-view learning tasks.
  • Vector Gaussian Model: Experiments on the vector Gaussian model show that the algorithms can recover the theoretical optimal trade-off curves.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameterization Expressiveness: The paper notes that the chosen parametric families for DNNs (e.g., multivariate Gaussian) might not always be expressive enough to perfectly approximate the optimal distributions, potentially leading to a performance gap.
  • Computational Cost: While the D-VIB algorithm is scalable, training DNNs can still be computationally intensive.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more expressive parameterizations for DNNs to further close the gap to the optimal trade-off. They also leave the study of different trajectory types under various activation functions as future work. Additionally, the paper mentions that while the proposed methods are applicable even when the Markov chain assumption is not strictly satisfied, the interpretation of relevance and complexity might be lost.

Summary updated

Abstract

The problem of distributed representation learning is one in which multiple sources of information $X_1,\ldots,X_K$ are processed separately so as to learn as much information as possible about some ground truth $Y$. We investigate this problem from information-theoretic grounds, through a generalization of Tishby's centralized Information Bottleneck (IB) method to the distributed setting. Specifically, $K$ encoders, $K \geq 2$, compress their observations $X_1,\ldots,X_K$ separately in a manner such that, collectively, the produced representations preserve as much information as possible about $Y$. We study both discrete memoryless (DM) and memoryless vector Gaussian data models. For the discrete model, we establish a single-letter characterization of the optimal tradeoff between complexity (or rate) and relevance (or information) for a class of memoryless sources (the observations $X_1,\ldots,X_K$ being conditionally independent given $Y$). For the vector Gaussian model, we provide an explicit characterization of the optimal complexity-relevance tradeoff. Furthermore, we develop a variational bound on the complexity-relevance tradeoff which generalizes the evidence lower bound (ELBO) to the distributed setting. We also provide two algorithms that allow to compute this bound: i) a Blahut-Arimoto type iterative algorithm which enables to compute optimal complexity-relevance encoding mappings by iterating over a set of self-consistent equations, and ii) a variational inference type algorithm in which the encoding mappings are parametrized by neural networks and the bound approximated by Markov sampling and optimized with stochastic gradient descent. Numerical results on synthetic and real datasets are provided to support the efficiency of the approaches and algorithms developed in this paper.
BibTeX
@article{aguerri2018distributed,
  author = {Inaki Estella Aguerri and Abdellatif Zaidi},
  title = {{Distributed Variational Representation Learning}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell.},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=3sYjX-CYV3},
}
Figure