Distributed robust optimization scheduling of a steel plant integrated energy system considering the uncertainty of byproduct coal gas

Fan Li, Yuxiao Li, Tao Niu, Sidun Fang, Wenguo WuFrontiers in Energy Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a two-stage distributed robust optimization (DRO) framework to manage the energy scheduling of a steel plant. By utilizing an Imprecise Dirichlet Model (IDM) to characterize the high uncertainty of byproduct coal gas production, the authors achieve a scheduling strategy that is less "paranoid" (conservative) than traditional robust methods and significantly faster than stochastic approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Steel manufacturing is an energy-intensive process that produces significant amounts of byproduct gases, such as Blast Furnace Gas (BFG) and Coke Oven Gas (COG). While these gases can be reused to generate steam and electricity, their production rates are notoriously difficult to predict due to sensor inaccuracies, fluctuating production plans, and environmental factors.

Existing scheduling methods often fall into two camps: Robust Optimization (RO), which plans for the absolute worst-case scenario and is often too expensive, and Stochastic Optimization (SO), which requires precise probability data that is rarely available and is computationally "heavy." The authors aim to bridge this gap by creating a model that handles uncertainty efficiently without requiring perfect data or sacrificing too much economic performance.

Methods

The researchers developed a Steel Plant Integrated Energy System (SPIES) model that coordinates gas, steam, and power flows. The core innovations include:

  • Imprecise Dirichlet Model (IDM): Instead of assuming a single probability distribution for gas production, the IDM constructs a "fuzzy set" of distributions. This is particularly effective when historical data is limited, as it allows for a range of statistical possibilities.
  • Two-Stage DRO Framework:
    • Stage 1 (Day-Ahead): Determines power purchase/sale and initial equipment states.
  • Stage 2 (Real-Time): Adjusts equipment (boilers, CHP units, gas holders) to compensate for actual gas production fluctuations.
  • Mathematical Transformation: To make the complex "min-max-min" optimization problem solvable, the authors used duality theory and the big-M method to transform it into a standard Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP) model.
  • Solution Algorithm: They employed the Column-and-Constraint Generation (CC&G) algorithm, which iteratively solves master and slave problems to reach an optimal balance between robustness and cost.

Datasets

The study validated its approach using:

  • Real-world Steel Plant Data: Historical production data for BFG, COG, and LDG (Linz Donawitz Gas).
  • IEEE-33 Node System: A standard power engineering benchmark used to simulate the distribution network of the industrial park surrounding the plant.
  • Synthetic Uncertainty Scenarios: Generated to test the model's performance against varying levels of data availability (from 200 to 2,500 samples).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sweet Spot" of DRO: The paper demonstrates that Distributed Robust Optimization is the "Goldilocks" of scheduling. It isn't as overly cautious as RO, but it avoids the massive computational burden of SO, which often struggles with large-scale industrial systems.
  • Gas Holders as Buffers: The model treats gas holders as critical flexibility assets. By using piecewise linearization to model the cost of adjusting holder positions, the authors account for the physical risks associated with pipe network pressure.
  • Data-Driven Resilience: A key "aha" moment is that as the number of historical samples increases, the DRO results naturally converge toward the results of Stochastic Optimization. This means the model is inherently scalable and improves as more data is collected.

Key Results

  • Economic Efficiency: Compared to traditional Robust Optimization, the proposed method reduced total scheduling costs by 1.91% (approximately 55,307¥).
  • Computational Speedup: The model solved 1,326.94 seconds faster than the Stochastic Optimization method, making it much more viable for real-time industrial applications.
  • Balanced Conservatism: The use of a "conservatism parameter" ($\Gamma$) allows plant operators to tune the system. They can choose to be more robust (safer but costlier) or more aggressive (cheaper but riskier) depending on their current operational needs.

Limitations and Future Work

While the big-M method successfully linearized the model, the authors acknowledge that more advanced techniques like the McCormick envelope could potentially yield even more accurate results. Additionally, the current model focuses primarily on gas, steam, and power. Future iterations could integrate carbon emission trading constraints or the complexities of hydrogen-based steelmaking, which are becoming increasingly relevant as the industry moves toward carbon neutrality.

Summary updated

Abstract

The steel plant integrated energy system (SPIES) is an important form in the steel industry. Improving the utilization efficiency of steam, electricity, coal gas and other energy flows is of great significance for both economic and environmental benefits. In this paper, a SPIES scheduling model is established according to the operation characteristics of coal gas holders, boilers and other equipment in steel plants. Meanwhile, to cope with the uncertainty of byproduct coal gas, this paper adopts an imprecise Dirichlet model (IDM) to construct a fuzzy set containing multisource coal gas production information. Then, according to duality theory and the big-M method, the original distributed robust optimization (DRO) model is transformed into a traditional mixed integer linear programming (MILP) model, which is solved by the column-and-constraint generation (CC&G) algorithm. Finally, a real steel production system is given in a case study. Case study illustrate that compared with the traditional robust method, the method proposed in this paper for a SPIES can effectively reduce the conservatism of the scheduling decision. Numerical simulation show that the proposed method can reduce total cost by 55,307.1¥, accounting for 1.91% of the total cost compared with robust optimization method and save 1,326.94 s of computational time compared with the stochastic optimization method, thus reaching balance between conservatism and computational efficiency.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022distributed,
  author = {Fan Li and Yuxiao Li and Tao Niu and Sidun Fang and Wenguo Wu},
  title = {{Distributed robust optimization scheduling of a steel plant integrated energy system considering the uncertainty of byproduct coal gas}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.979938},
}
Figure