Distributed rate control of smart solar arrays with batteries

Phuthipong Bovornkeeratiroj, Stephen Lee, Srinivasan Iyengar, David Irwin, Prashant ShenoyFrontiers in the Internet of Things 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a decentralized "rate control" mechanism for smart solar arrays, inspired by TCP congestion control, to manage high solar penetration without crashing the grid. By using Lagrangian optimization and adaptive gradients, the system allows for 2.6× more solar installations while requiring only minimal output curtailment (as low as 12.4%).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As solar power becomes cheaper than retail electricity, we are seeing a massive surge in installations. However, the power grid wasn't designed for this. Solar is intermittent; a cloud passing over a city can cause a sudden drop in supply, while a sunny midday can create a "supply-side surplus" that exceeds demand (the famous "duck curve").

To maintain stability, utilities currently impose "dumb" hard caps on how much solar can be connected to a local feeder or transformer. These caps are often conservative and prevent many homeowners from adopting solar. The authors argue that the grid is currently in its "pre-TCP" era—relying on rigid limits rather than active, fair management of "congestion" (excess power).

Methods

The authors propose transforming "passive" solar arrays into "smart" ones that can modulate their output in real-time.

  • Proportional Fairness: Instead of cutting off users arbitrarily, the system uses a logarithmic utility function. This ensures that if the grid is "congested," every array backs off its output proportionally to its capacity or a pre-set weight.
  • Dual Decomposition: To avoid the need for a massive central supercomputer knowing every home's status, the authors use a decentralized approach. The grid (at the transformer or feeder level) broadcasts a "control price" (a Lagrangian multiplier). Each smart inverter then solves a simple local optimization problem to decide its own injection rate.
  • Sense-Broadcast-Respond Protocol: A three-step loop where sensors measure grid load, the control center broadcasts price signals, and smart inverters adjust their output.
  • AdaGrad for the Grid: The authors applied AdaGrad (an adaptive gradient descent algorithm common in machine learning) to the price-setting mechanism. This allows the system to converge on the "fair" price much faster than standard fixed-step methods.
  • Battery Integration: They extended the algorithm to manage co-located batteries, allowing them to store energy that would otherwise be curtailed and discharge it when grid capacity opens up.

Datasets

The study evaluated the approach using a real-world, city-scale dataset:

  • Location: A small city in New England, USA.
  • Scale: Data from 11,186 residential homes.
  • Granularity: 5-minute intervals over 12 months.
  • Topology: Includes the actual mapping of 29 feeders and 1,108 transformers.
  • Solar Profiles: Generated from real residential solar data, scaled to represent 4–10 kW installations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Internet Analogy: The core "aha moment" is treating electrons like data packets. Just as TCP prevents network collapse by having sources back off when they detect dropped packets, smart inverters can back off when they receive "congestion" signals from the grid.
  • Fairness is a Mathematical Choice: By choosing specific utility functions, the authors prove that a decentralized system can reach a "Pareto optimal" state where no user can increase their solar injection without unfairly harming another.
  • Speed Matters: In a dynamic environment like a power grid, an algorithm that takes minutes to converge is useless. The move from fixed gradients to AdaGrad was crucial, making the system responsive enough for real-world fluctuations.
  • Batteries Change the Math: Batteries aren't just for backup; they act as a buffer that allows the rate controller to be more aggressive. Even a small 30-minute battery significantly increases the amount of solar energy a home can successfully "net-meter" back to the utility.

Key Results

  • Increased Penetration: The system enabled 2.6× more solar homes to be added to the grid compared to current rigid caps.
  • Minimal Loss: To achieve this massive increase in capacity, smart arrays only had to reduce their total potential output by an average of 12.4%.
  • Convergence Speed: The AdaGrad-based decentralized algorithm converged 3× to 30× faster than traditional fixed-gradient methods.
  • Edge-Ready: The algorithm is computationally light. When tested on a Raspberry Pi 3 (simulating a smart inverter's processor), it took less than 0.3 seconds to find the optimal rate, proving it is feasible for low-cost hardware.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Communication Dependency: The system assumes a reliable, low-latency communication link between the utility and the smart inverters. In the real world, network outages or high latency could destabilize the control loop.
  • Synchronization: The current model assumes that all arrays update their rates simultaneously. Future work is needed to see how the system handles asynchronous updates.
  • Voltage Constraints: While the paper focuses on power capacity (thermal limits of transformers), it does not explicitly model local voltage rise/drop issues, which are another major hurdle for solar integration.
  • Economic Incentives: The paper assumes users will follow the "fair" rate. In reality, this would likely require new regulatory frameworks or financial incentives to ensure compliance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Continued advances in technology have led to falling costs and a dramatic increase in the aggregate amount of solar capacity installed across the world. A drawback of increased solar penetration is the potential for supply-demand mismatches in the grid due to the intermittent nature of solar generation. While energy storage can be used to mask such problems, we argue that there is also a need to explicitly control the rate of solar generation of each solar array in order to achieve high penetration while also handling supply-demand mismatches. To address this issue, we present the notion of smart solar arrays that can actively modulate their solar output based on the notion of proportional fairness. We present a decentralized algorithm based on Lagrangian optimization that enables each smart solar array to make local decisions on its fair share of solar power it can inject into the grid and then present a sense-broadcast-respond protocol to implement our decentralized algorithm into smart solar arrays. We also study the benefits of using energy storage when we rate control solar. To do so, we present a decentralized algorithm to charge and discharge batteries for each smart solar. Our evaluation on a city-scale dataset shows that our approach enables 2.6× more solar penetration while causing smart arrays to reduce their output by as little as 12.4%. By employing an adaptive gradient approach, our decentralized algorithm has 3 to 30× faster convergence. Finally, we demonstrate energy storage can help netmeter more solar energy while ensuring fairness and grid constraints are met.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bovornkeeratiroj2023distributed,
  author = {Phuthipong Bovornkeeratiroj and Stephen Lee and Srinivasan Iyengar and David Irwin and Prashant Shenoy},
  title = {{Distributed rate control of smart solar arrays with batteries}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in the Internet of Things},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/friot.2023.1129367},
}
Figure