Distributed neural network control with dependability guarantees: a compositional port-Hamiltonian approach

Luca Furieri, Clara Lucía Galimberti, Muhammad Zakwan, Giancarlo Ferrari-TrecatearXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces "DeepDisCoPH," a novel approach for training distributed neural network controllers for large-scale cyber-physical systems. By leveraging the unique properties of port-Hamiltonian systems, DeepDisCoPH offers built-in guarantees of closed-loop stability and non-vanishing gradients during training, addressing critical dependability concerns in complex control applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing effective control policies for large-scale cyber-physical systems (like power grids, robot swarms, or autonomous vehicles) is challenging because controllers can only access local information and communicate with a limited number of neighbors. This is known as Optimal Distributed Control (ODC). While neural networks (NNs) show promise for learning complex control strategies, they often lack crucial "dependability" guarantees. Specifically, NN controllers can lead to unstable closed-loop systems, and their training can be hampered by vanishing or exploding gradients, especially in deep architectures. This paper tackles these issues by developing a method that ensures both stability and robust training for distributed controllers applied to networks of nonlinear port-Hamiltonian (pH) systems.

Methods

The core of this work lies in combining two key ideas:

  • Port-Hamiltonian (pH) Systems: The authors leverage the compositional properties of pH systems. These systems have a mathematical structure that inherently preserves energy and stability when interconnected. This property is crucial for guaranteeing that the overall system remains stable, even with complex network topologies.
  • Hamiltonian Deep Neural Networks (H-DNNs): They propose a specific architecture for the neural network controllers, termed Hamiltonian Deep Neural Networks (H-DNNs). These networks are designed to maintain the pH structure in the closed-loop system. By carefully structuring the controller's energy function and its interaction with the system, they achieve closed-loop stability by design. This means stability is guaranteed regardless of the specific NN weights or the network's interconnection structure.
  • Neural Ordinary Differential Equations (Neural ODEs): To address the vanishing/exploding gradient problem during training, the authors frame the control problem as a Neural ODE. This continuous-time formulation, combined with specific properties of the pH system and controller, allows them to prove that the gradients remain well-behaved, preventing training from stalling.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments use a simulated multi-robot formation control task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stability by Design, Not by Chance: The most significant insight is that by using a pH-structured controller, closed-loop stability can be guaranteed irrespective of the learned weights or network topology. This is a major step beyond traditional NN control, where stability is often an emergent property that can be lost after training.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The paper successfully bridges theoretical control concepts (pH systems, compositional properties) with modern machine learning techniques (deep NNs, Neural ODEs) to solve a practical control problem.
  • Dependability During Training: The work not only ensures stability of the final controller but also addresses the training process itself. The non-vanishing gradient property means that training deep controllers is more reliable and less prone to failure.
  • Scalability: The approach is designed for large-scale systems, where the compositional nature of pH systems and the distributed control paradigm are particularly beneficial.

Key Results

  • Guaranteed Closed-Loop Stability: The proposed DeepDisCoPH controllers, when applied to networks of pH systems, ensure closed-loop stability for any network topology and any choice of trainable parameters.
  • Non-Vanishing Gradients: The training process for these controllers is shown to avoid vanishing gradients, even for deep neural network architectures, making training more robust.
  • Competitive Performance: Numerical experiments on a multi-robot collision avoidance and formation task demonstrate that DeepDisCoPH controllers achieve performance comparable to general neural network policies, while offering superior stability guarantees.
  • Robustness to Early Stopping: The controllers maintain closed-loop stability even if training is stopped prematurely, highlighting their inherent dependability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • pH System Assumption: The current framework is specialized for systems that can be modeled as port-Hamiltonian systems. Extending this to more general nonlinear systems would be a significant advancement.
  • Computational Cost: While the approach offers theoretical guarantees, the implementation and training of deep H-DNNs can still be computationally intensive.
  • Generalization to Other Dynamics: The paper focuses on pH systems. Future work could explore how to adapt these dependability guarantees to other classes of dynamical systems.
  • Real-World Deployment: While validated in simulation, real-world deployment would require further investigation into sensor noise, actuator limitations, and communication delays.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large-scale cyber-physical systems require that control policies are distributed, that is, that they only rely on local real-time measurements and communication with neighboring agents. Optimal Distributed Control (ODC) problems are, however, highly intractable even in seemingly simple cases. Recent work has thus proposed training Neural Network (NN) distributed controllers. A main challenge of NN controllers is that they are not dependable during and after training, that is, the closed-loop system may be unstable, and the training may fail due to vanishing and exploding gradients. In this paper, we address these issues for networks of nonlinear port-Hamiltonian (pH) systems, whose modeling power ranges from energy systems to non-holonomic vehicles and chemical reactions. Specifically, we embrace the compositional properties of pH systems to characterize deep Hamiltonian control policies with built-in closed-loop stability guarantees, irrespective of the interconnection topology and the chosen NN parameters. Furthermore, our setup enables leveraging recent results on well-behaved neural ODEs to prevent the phenomenon of vanishing gradients by design. Numerical experiments corroborate the dependability of the proposed architecture, while matching the performance of general neural network policies.
BibTeX
@misc{furieri2021distributed,
  author = {Luca Furieri and Clara Lucía Galimberti and Muhammad Zakwan and Giancarlo Ferrari-Trecate},
  title = {{Distributed neural network control with dependability guarantees: a compositional port-Hamiltonian approach}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.09046},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.09046},
}
Figure