Distributed Nash Equilibrium Seeking in Consistency-Constrained Multicoalition Games

Jialing Zhou, Yuezu Lv, Guanghui Wen, Jinhu Lü, Dezhi ZhengIEEE Trans. Cybernetics 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel distributed algorithm for finding Nash Equilibria (NE) in complex multi-coalition games where agents within a coalition must agree on a common state. This work unifies several existing problems in game theory and optimization, offering a more general framework and a practical, discrete-time solution that converges linearly to the NE.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of finding a Nash Equilibrium (NE) in a specific type of game called "consistency-constrained multi-coalition games." Imagine a scenario with multiple groups (coalitions) of players, where players within each group cooperate to achieve a common goal (minimizing their collective cost). However, these groups also compete against each other. A key constraint is that all players within a single coalition must agree on a unified "state" or decision. This is crucial in real-world applications like multi-party politics or business strategy, where internal consensus is needed before external competition.

Existing research often simplifies this by either ignoring the internal agreement requirement or assuming very specific network structures (like balanced communication). This paper addresses the more general and challenging problem where:

  • Coalitions exist: Multiple groups of cooperating agents.
  • Internal consistency is required: Agents within a coalition must agree on a common state.
  • External competition exists: Coalitions compete against each other.
  • General network topologies: Communication links between agents can be arbitrary (not necessarily balanced or symmetric).
  • Distributed computation: Agents can only access local information and communicate with neighbors.

Methods

The core of the paper is a new distributed, discrete-time algorithm designed for agents to iteratively update their states and converge to an NE. The algorithm relies on two key estimations for each agent:

  1. Partial derivative estimation: Agents estimate the rate of change of their cost function with respect to their state. This is crucial for understanding how to improve their decisions.
  2. Global state estimation: Agents estimate the overall state of the system, even though they only have local information. This is achieved using a leader-following consensus protocol.

Based on these estimations, a novel state updating law is designed. This law balances two objectives: ensuring agents within a coalition reach an agreement (consensus) and driving the collective states of all agents towards the NE. The algorithm is designed to work even with unbalanced communication networks by carefully weighting information exchanged between agents. The authors also provide a rigorous mathematical proof demonstrating that the algorithm converges linearly to the NE under certain assumptions about the cost functions and network connectivity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and uses a simulated example for numerical verification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unifying Framework: The paper demonstrates that consistency-constrained multi-coalition games can serve as a unified framework for several well-studied problems, including networked games among individual players and distributed optimization problems. This suggests that solutions developed for this general framework can be adapted to these specific cases.
  • Balancing Consensus and NE Seeking: The algorithm cleverly integrates two distinct objectives: achieving internal consensus within coalitions and driving the system towards an external equilibrium (NE). This is a significant challenge in distributed multi-agent systems.
  • Handling General Topologies: The algorithm's ability to handle unbalanced directed communication networks is a key advancement, as many previous methods relied on more restrictive network assumptions.
  • Reduced-Order Algorithm: The paper also proposes a "reduced-order" version of the algorithm, which simplifies the information exchange requirements, making it potentially more practical for implementation.

Key Results

  • Linear Convergence: The proposed distributed algorithm is proven to converge linearly to the Nash Equilibrium (NE) under general directed network topologies and consistency constraints within coalitions.
  • Unified Solution: The algorithm can be specialized to solve distributed optimization problems and networked games among individual players, demonstrating its generality.
  • Numerical Verification: Simulations show that the algorithm effectively drives agent states towards the NE, with fast consensus within coalitions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The convergence proof relies on several assumptions, including the graph being strongly connected, sub-graphs within coalitions being strongly connected, and cost functions being convex and twice-differentiable with Lipschitz continuous gradients. Relaxing these assumptions could be a direction for future work.
  • Non-smooth Cost Functions: The current algorithm is designed for smooth cost functions. Extending it to handle non-smooth cost functions would broaden its applicability.
  • Time-Varying Topologies and Objectives: The paper focuses on static network topologies and objective functions. Future research could explore algorithms that can handle dynamic changes in communication links or agent objectives.
  • Reduced-Order Algorithm Trade-offs: While the reduced-order algorithm offers communication benefits, it might have different convergence properties or require more careful parameter tuning. Further analysis of these trade-offs would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

The distributed Nash equilibrium (NE) seeking problem for multicoalition games has attracted increasing attention in recent years, but the research mainly focuses on the case without agreement demand within coalitions. This article considers a class of networked games among multiple coalitions where each coalition contains multiple agents that cooperate to minimize the sum of their costs, subject to the demand of reaching an agreement on their state values. Furthermore, the underlying network topology among the agents does not need to be balanced. To achieve the goal of NE seeking within such a context, two estimates are constructed for each agent, namely, an estimate of partial derivatives of the cost function and an estimate of global state values, based on which, an iterative state updating law is elaborately designed. Linear convergence of the proposed algorithm is demonstrated. It is shown that the consistency-constrained multicoalition games investigated in this article put the well-studied networked games among individual players and distributed optimization in a unified framework, and the proposed algorithm can easily degenerate into solutions to these problems.
BibTeX
@article{zhou2023distributed,
  author = {Jialing Zhou and Yuezu Lv and Guanghui Wen and Jinhu Lü and Dezhi Zheng},
  title = {{Distributed Nash Equilibrium Seeking in Consistency-Constrained Multicoalition Games}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Cybernetics},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=nm9HlkIjFo},
}
Figure