Distributed Detection in Ad Hoc Networks Through Quantized Consensus

Shengyu Zhu, Biao ChenIEEE Trans. Information Theory 2018 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel one-bit quantized consensus algorithm for distributed detection in sensor networks. It demonstrates that this approach can achieve the optimal detection performance of a centralized system, even when nodes only communicate with their immediate neighbors, overcoming the limitations of traditional quantized consensus methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In large-scale sensor networks, distributed detection is crucial for making informed decisions based on data collected from multiple sensors. A common challenge is the limited communication bandwidth, which often necessitates quantizing sensor data before transmission. Traditional distributed detection often relies on a fusion center that receives all data, which is not always feasible in ad hoc networks where nodes only communicate with their neighbors. Existing quantized consensus algorithms struggle with achieving optimal performance due to inherent quantization errors that lead to non-vanishing consensus errors. This paper tackles the problem of achieving optimal distributed detection performance in ad hoc networks using only one-bit quantized communication, aiming to match the performance of centralized detection without requiring a fusion center or unlimited bandwidth.

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel distributed averaging algorithm called BQ-CADMM with an $\delta$-quantizer. This algorithm builds upon existing BQ-CADMM but introduces a one-bit quantizer with a controllable threshold. This specific quantizer design is crucial for achieving arbitrarily small consensus errors, a key improvement over prior work. The algorithm allows each sensor node to iteratively exchange one-bit quantized information with its neighbors to reach a consensus on the average log-likelihood ratio (LLR) of observations. The paper then leverages this consensus result to construct acceptance regions for hypothesis testing under three common criteria: Bayesian, Neyman-Pearson with a constant type-I error constraint, and Neyman-Pearson with an exponential type-I error constraint. The theoretical analysis focuses on asymptotic performance (as the network size grows) and also explores non-asymptotic behavior.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses simulated data for Gaussian distributions to evaluate performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • One-bit quantization can achieve optimal distributed detection: The paper demonstrates that even with the severe constraint of one-bit communication, it's possible to achieve the same asymptotic error exponents as centralized detection. This is a significant finding, as it suggests that practical, low-bandwidth distributed systems can be highly effective.
  • Controllable threshold is key: The introduction of a one-bit quantizer with a controllable threshold is the critical innovation. This allows the consensus error to be made arbitrarily small, overcoming the constant error terms found in previous quantized consensus algorithms.
  • Consensus on LLRs enables optimal detection: By achieving a consensus on the average log-likelihood ratio (LLR) across the network, the distributed system effectively reconstructs the information that a centralized fusion center would use, leading to optimal detection performance.
  • Network topology matters for convergence time, not asymptotic performance: While the network structure (e.g., star vs. complete graph) influences how quickly the consensus is reached, the paper shows that the optimal asymptotic error exponent is achievable regardless of the specific connected topology.

Key Results

  • Asymptotic Optimality: The proposed BQ-CADMM with the $\delta$-quantizer achieves the optimal asymptotic error exponent for distributed detection under Bayesian, Neyman-Pearson (constant constraint), and Neyman-Pearson (exponential constraint) criteria. This means that as the network size grows, the error probability decays at the same optimal rate as in a centralized system.
  • Non-Asymptotic Performance: The paper shows that for a continuity condition satisfied by the underlying distributions, the type-I and type-II error probabilities at each node can be made arbitrarily close to the centralized optimal ones, even for finite network sizes.
  • Simulation Results: Monte Carlo simulations for Gaussian distributions demonstrate that the consensus-based approach closely matches the centralized error probability, especially for larger networks. The simulations also highlight the effectiveness of a decreasing parameter strategy for accelerating convergence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Convergence Time Characterization: While the paper shows that convergence is finite, a precise characterization or tight upper bound on the convergence time remains elusive. The numerical studies suggest an $O(m \log n)$ dependency for data transmissions, but a more rigorous analysis is needed.
  • Stopping Criterion: Determining an efficient and practical stopping criterion for the consensus algorithm in a fully distributed manner is an open problem.
  • Sequential Observations: The current work focuses on static observations. Extending the approach to handle temporal observations (sequential detection) is suggested as a future research direction.
  • Practical Parameter Selection: While the theoretical framework provides conditions for optimal performance, selecting optimal quantizer and algorithm parameters in practice can be challenging and may require further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the asymptotic performance of distributed detection in large scale connected sensor networks. Contrasting to the canonical parallel network where a single node has access to local decisions from all other nodes, each node can only exchange information with its direct neighbors in the present setting. We establish that, with each node employing an identical one-bit quantizer for local information exchange, a novel consensus reaching approach can achieve the optimal asymptotic performance of centralized detection as the network size scales. The statement is true under three different detection frameworks: 1) the Bayesian criterion where the maximum a posteriori detector is optimal; 2) the Neyman-Pearson criterion with a constant type-I error probability constraint; and 3) the Neyman-Pearson criterion with an exponential type-I error probability constraint. Leveraging recent development in distributed consensus reaching using bounded quantizers with possibly unbounded data (which are log-likelihood ratios of local observations in the context of distributed detection), we design a one-bit deterministic quantizer with a controllable threshold that leads to desirable consensus error bounds. The obtained bounds are key to establishing the optimal asymptotic detection performance. In addition, we examine the non-asymptotic performance of the proposed approach and show that the type-I and type-II error probabilities at each node can be made arbitrarily close to the centralized ones simultaneously when a continuity condition is satisfied.
BibTeX
@article{zhu2018distributed,
  author = {Shengyu Zhu and Biao Chen},
  title = {{Distributed Detection in Ad Hoc Networks Through Quantized Consensus}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Information Theory},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Jn0grrwFWeh},
}
Figure