Distributed classification of multiple observations by consensus

Effrosini Kokiopoulou, Pascal FrossardICIP 2010 · OpenReview

Abstract

We consider the problem of distributed classification of multiple observations of the same object that are collected in an ad-hoc network of vision sensors. Assuming that each sensor captures a different observation of the same object, the problem is to classify this object by distributed processing from the sensors. We present a graph-based problem formulation whose objective function captures the smoothness of candidate labels on the data manifold. We design a distributed average consensus algorithm for estimating the unknown object class by computing the value of the above smoothness objective function for different class hypotheses. It initially estimates the objective function locally, based on the observation of each sensor. All the observations are then progressively taken into account in the estimation of the objective function, along the iterations of the distributed consensus algorithm. We illustrate the performance of the distributed classification algorithm by simulation of multi-view face recognition in an ad-hoc network of vision sensors. When the training set is sufficiently large, the simulation results show that the consensus classification decision is equivalent to the decision of a centralized system that would have access to all observations.

Introduction

In ad-hoc sensor networks, such as a collection of vision sensors monitoring a space, multiple observations of a single object are often available from different perspectives. Traditional centralized classification requires transmitting high-bandwidth data to a central hub, which is often impractical due to communication costs and the lack of a fixed infrastructure. This paper addresses the challenge of distributed classification: enabling individual sensors to collaboratively identify an object through local communication with immediate neighbors.

Methodology

The proposed approach, termed MAnifold Smoothing under Constraints (MASC), leverages graph-based manifold learning and distributed average consensus.

Graph-Based Smoothness

The algorithm operates on the "smoothness assumption," which posits that similar data points should share identical labels. A $k$-nearest neighbor ($k$-NN) graph is constructed where nodes represent data samples (both labeled training examples and unlabeled observations) and edges represent similarity weights.

Distributed Average Consensus

To achieve a global decision without a central controller, the network employs a distributed average consensus protocol. Sensors iteratively exchange and average local cost values with their neighbors. This process ensures that every node eventually converges to the global average of the initial values, representing the collective cost for each class hypothesis.

Conceptual diagram showing the relationship between the data graph $\mathcal{G}_d$ and the sensor network graph $\mathcal{G}_s$.

As shown in Figure 1, the data graph $\mathcal{G}_d$ captures the relationships between labeled examples and unlabeled observations, while the sensor network graph $\mathcal{G}_s$ defines the communication topology between sensors.

Experimental Results

The algorithm was evaluated using the UMIST Face Database and simulated ad-hoc networks modeled as random geographic graphs.

Performance and Convergence

The distributed MASC (distMASC) algorithm demonstrates performance nearly identical to its centralized counterpart when the training set is sufficiently large. It consistently outperforms standard Label Propagation (LP) because it explicitly leverages the fact that all observations belong to the same class.

Classification error rate vs. number of iterations, showing the convergence of distMASC to the centralized MASC solution.

A critical finding is the rapid convergence of the consensus mechanism. As illustrated in Figure 3, the classification error rate of the distributed algorithm stabilizes and matches the centralized performance within approximately 30 to 40 iterations. This makes the approach highly practical for real-time sensor networks where rapid decision-making is essential.

Conclusion

The MASC framework provides an efficient, distributed solution for multi-view object classification. By combining manifold smoothing with consensus iterations, the system achieves centralized-level accuracy with significantly lower computational complexity—$O(l + c)$ locally versus $O((l+m)^2 + c)$ centrally. Future work will address network partitioning and dynamic sensor topologies to further enhance robustness in mobile environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of distributed classification of multiple observations of the same object that are collected in an ad-hoc network of vision sensors. Assuming that each sensor captures a different observation of the same object, the problem is to classify this object by distributed processing from the sensors. We present a graph-based problem formulation whose objective function captures the smoothness of candidate labels on the data manifold. We design a distributed average consensus algorithm for estimating the unknown object class by computing the value of the above smoothness objective function for different class hypotheses. It initially estimates the objective function locally, based on the observation of each sensor. All the observations are then progressively taken into account in the estimation of the objective function, along the iterations of the distributed consensus algorithm. We illustrate the performance of the distributed classification algorithm by simulation of multi-view face recognition in an ad-hoc network of vision sensors. When the training set is sufficiently large, the simulation results show that the consensus classification decision is equivalent to the decision of a centralized system that would have access to all observations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kokiopoulou2010distributed,
  author = {Effrosini Kokiopoulou and Pascal Frossard},
  title = {{Distributed classification of multiple observations by consensus}},
  booktitle = {ICIP},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=IJXJfzuNGT},
}
Figure