Distance Measurement and Data Analysis for Civil Aviation at 1000 Frames per Second Using Single-Photon Detection Technology

Yiming Shan, Xinyu Pang, Huan Wang, Jitong Zhao, Shuai Yang, Yunlong Li, Gui‐Qing Xu, Lihua Cai, Zhenyu Liu, Xiaoming Wang, Yi YuSensors 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel single-photon laser ranging system capable of operating at 1000 frames per second, enabling precise real-time tracking of high-speed aerial maneuvers. By demonstrating that higher frame rates significantly reduce measurement errors and improve reproducibility, the system offers a promising solution for advanced aviation monitoring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-speed maneuvers by aircraft present a significant challenge for traditional optical measurement systems. Capturing these rapid changes in distance, velocity, and acceleration requires extremely high frame rates. Existing methods like dual-station triangulation, while capable of high frame rates, are complex and expensive to deploy. Conventional laser rangefinders, on the other hand, are limited by low repetition rates, often necessitating frame interpolation which can compromise accuracy. This gap leaves a need for an affordable, simple, and high-frame-rate ranging solution to accurately characterize dynamic aerial targets.

Methods

The core of this work is a single-photon laser ranging system that utilizes low-energy laser pulses and highly sensitive single-photon detectors. This approach allows for the detection of individual photons, even after significant attenuation, enabling ranging with lower power lasers and higher repetition rates.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Kilohertz-level Ranging: The system achieves a frame rate of 1000 Hz, significantly exceeding conventional laser rangefinders.
  • Time-of-Flight (TOF) Principle: Distance is calculated based on the time it takes for a laser pulse to travel to the target and return, detected by the single-photon detector.
  • Triple-Frequency Laser Emission: To overcome range ambiguity (where the system cannot distinguish between multiple possible distances), the laser emits pulses at three slightly different frequencies. By solving a system of congruence equations, the true target distance can be accurately determined.
  • Density-Based Clustering for Denoising: Given the low signal strength and short integration times at high frame rates, noise filtering is crucial. The authors employ a density-based clustering algorithm to effectively distinguish signal photons from background noise and detector dark counts. This algorithm adjusts density thresholds based on the spatial distribution of photons.
  • Data Aggregation for Lower Frame Rate Simulation: To evaluate the impact of frame rate on measurement precision, the 1000 Hz data was systematically aggregated to simulate lower frame rates (500 Hz, 100 Hz, 50 Hz, and 10 Hz).

Datasets

The study utilizes civil aviation targets (commercial aircraft) within a 20 km range for its field tests. The data collected consists of raw and processed ranging measurements, including distance, radial velocity, and radial acceleration. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses real-world flight data to validate its system and analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Frame Rate is Paramount for Dynamic Targets: The most significant insight is the direct correlation between higher frame rates and improved measurement precision and reproducibility. This is crucial for accurately capturing the complex motion of high-speed aircraft.
  • Single-Photon Detection is Key to High Frame Rates: The inherent sensitivity of single-photon detectors, coupled with low-energy lasers, unlocks the possibility of achieving kilohertz-level repetition rates, which is the enabler for high-frame-rate ranging.
  • Denoising is Critical at High Frame Rates: The challenge of distinguishing weak signals from noise becomes more pronounced at high frame rates due to short integration times. The density-based clustering approach proves effective in this context.
  • Frame Synchronization Matters: The study highlights that the method of aggregating frames to simulate lower frame rates can introduce subtle discrepancies, underscoring the importance of precise frame synchronization in such systems.

Key Results

  • Successful 1000 Hz Ranging: The system successfully performed thousand-frame-per-sequence tracking and ranging of civil aircraft.
  • Reduced Standard Deviation with Higher Frame Rates: The standard deviation of ranging measurements decreased significantly with increasing frame rates: 0.2683 m at 10 Hz, 0.2361 m at 50 Hz, and 0.1661 m at 100 Hz. This demonstrates enhanced reproducibility and reduced signal variance.
  • Lower Fitting Errors at Higher Frame Rates: Error analysis showed that fitting errors for radial distance, velocity, and acceleration increased substantially as frame rates decreased. For instance, radial distance fitting error rose from 0.61% at 100 Hz to 24.39% at 10 Hz.
  • Improved SNR After Denoising: The denoising algorithm significantly improved the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR), with post-filtering SNRs reaching up to 28.36 dB, compared to raw data SNRs as low as 4.66 dB during midday.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Denoising Under Strong Background Noise: The paper acknowledges that while the noise reduction algorithm performs well under low-background-light conditions, its effectiveness is limited when the signal is overwhelmed by strong background illumination (e.g., midday sun).
  • Theoretical Improvement Plan: The authors mention an "aforementioned improvement plan" for enhancing theoretical ranging frame frequency, which is currently at the theoretical conception stage and requires experimental validation. This likely refers to techniques like dead time mitigation and algorithm-hardware co-design.
  • Future Testing: The study plans to conduct extensive testing with various target types under different distances and environmental conditions. This will help refine the selection of density thresholds for optimal noise suppression.
  • Adaptive Thresholds: The research suggests that experimenters can use the provided data (Table 1) to select appropriate density thresholds based on measurement time for more stable and reliable noise suppression.

Summary updated

Abstract

During high-speed maneuvers, aircraft experience rapid distance changes, necessitating high-frame-rate ranging for accurate characterization. However, existing optical ranging technologies often lack simplicity, affordability, and sufficient frame rates. While dual-station triangulation enables high-frame-rate distance calculation via geometry, it suffers from complex and costly deployment. Conventional laser rangefinders are limited by low repetition rates. Single-photon ranging, using high-frequency low-energy pulses and detecting single reflected photons, offers a promising alternative. This study presents a kilohertz-level single-photon ranging system validated through civil aviation field tests. At 1000 Hz, relative distance, velocity, and acceleration were successfully captured. Simulating lower frame rates (100 Hz, 50 Hz, 10 Hz) via misalignment merging revealed standard deviations of 0.1661 m, 0.2361 m, and 0.2683 m, respectively, indicating that higher frame rates enhance distance measurement reproducibility. Error analysis against the 1000 Hz baseline further confirms that high-frame-rate ranging improves precision when monitoring high-speed maneuvers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shan2025distance,
  author = {Yiming Shan and Xinyu Pang and Huan Wang and Jitong Zhao and Shuai Yang and Yunlong Li and Gui‐Qing Xu and Lihua Cai and Zhenyu Liu and Xiaoming Wang and Yi Yu},
  title = {{Distance Measurement and Data Analysis for Civil Aviation at 1000 Frames per Second Using Single-Photon Detection Technology}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/s25133918},
}
Figure