Distance Geometry on the Sphere

Leo Liberti, Grzegorz Swirszcz, Carlile LavorJCDCGG 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper extends the classic Distance Geometry Problem (DGP) to the surface of a sphere. It shows that the problem remains largely similar when using Euclidean distances on the sphere, and importantly, provides a method for realizing graphs with geodesic distances on a sphere, generalizing a theorem by Kurt Gödel.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Distance Geometry Problem (DGP) is a fundamental problem in computational geometry and has applications in fields like protein structure determination and sensor network localization. It asks whether a given weighted graph can be embedded in a Euclidean space $\mathbb{R}^K$ such that the distances between connected vertices match the given edge weights. While significant progress has been made for DGP in Euclidean spaces, extending these methods to curved manifolds, specifically spheres, presents new challenges. This paper addresses the DGP on the surface of a sphere, considering both Euclidean distances (segments within the sphere) and geodesic distances (shortest paths along the sphere's surface).

Methods

The paper builds upon existing techniques for solving the DGP in Euclidean spaces and adapts them for spherical settings.

  • Euclidean Distances on the Sphere: The authors leverage the constraint that points lie on the sphere's surface (i.e., have a unit norm). This constraint is incorporated into the standard K-lateration process, which is a generalization of trilateration used to determine the position of a point given distances to other known points. By combining the distance constraints with the unit norm constraint, the problem is reduced to solving a linear system, which, under certain rank assumptions, leads to a unique solution for the next vertex in a clique realization.
  • Geodesic Distances on the Sphere: For geodesic distances, the paper generalizes a theorem by Kurt Gödel. The core idea is to consider a family of spheres with continuously decreasing radii. The realization of the graph is deformed along with the sphere. The authors show that there exists a critical radius where the geodesic distances on the sphere become equal to the chord distances (Euclidean distances) within that sphere. This is achieved by finding a fixed point of a function that relates the sphere's radius to the edge weights. This fixed-point approach provides a method to realize cliques using geodesic distances.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical aspects and algorithmic development rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sphere as a Natural Setting: The paper highlights that spheres are a natural setting for certain problems, such as completing partial correlation or covariance matrices in the financial sector.
  • Euclidean DGP on Sphere is Similar: The core insight for Euclidean distances is that the unit norm constraint on the sphere doesn't fundamentally change the problem's structure compared to its Euclidean counterpart, simplifying the K-lateration process.
  • Gödel's Theorem Generalization: The paper's most significant contribution is the generalization of Gödel's theorem to arbitrary dimensions. This provides a theoretical foundation and a constructive method for realizing graphs with geodesic distances on spheres.
  • Fixed-Point Approach for Geodesics: The use of a fixed-point argument to find the critical radius where geodesic and chord lengths match is a clever mathematical technique for solving the geodesic DGP.

Key Results

  • The paper demonstrates that the DGP with Euclidean distances on the surface of a sphere ($S^{K-1}$) is closely related to the standard Euclidean DGP.
  • A method is presented for realizing cliques on a sphere using geodesic distances, generalizing Kurt Gödel's result for $S^2$. This method involves finding a fixed point of a function related to the sphere's radius.
  • The authors provide a theoretical framework for understanding and solving the DGP on spherical manifolds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rank Assumptions: The methods for Euclidean distances rely on assumptions about the rank of matrices involved in the K-lateration process. While these assumptions are often justified in practice, they represent a theoretical limitation.
  • Computational Complexity: While the paper outlines efficient algorithms for cliques, the general DGP remains NP-hard. The complexity of realizing arbitrary graphs on spheres with geodesic distances is not fully explored.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings can be used to develop methods for realizing cliques on a sphere with geodesic distances. Further research could explore the application of these techniques to more complex graph structures and investigate the computational complexity for general graphs on spherical manifolds.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liberti2015distance,
  author = {Leo Liberti and Grzegorz Swirszcz and Carlile Lavor},
  title = {{Distance Geometry on the Sphere}},
  booktitle = {JCDCGG},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-48532-4\_18},
}
Figure