Disruption of seasonal influenza circulation and evolution during two pandemic events in Southeastern Asia: contrasting the role of human movement and pathogen competition

Zhiyuan Chen, Joseph L.-h. Tsui, Jun Cai, Cécile Viboud, Louis Du Plessis, Philippe Lemey, Moritz U. G. Kraemer, Hongjie YumedRxiv 2024 · DOI

This study, recently published as a preprint on medRxiv, provides a fascinating look at how global catastrophes reshape the "engine room" of seasonal influenza: Southeastern Asia. By comparing the 2009 A/H1N1 pandemic and the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers have unraveled how human movement and viral competition independently dictate the way the flu evolves and spreads.

TL;DR

Researchers analyzed nearly two decades of influenza data to show that while the COVID-19 pandemic halted flu circulation through movement restrictions, the 2009 H1N1 pandemic disrupted it primarily through "pathogen interference." The study highlights Southeastern Asia’s role as a persistent reservoir for H3N2 and reveals how different types of global disruptions can either accelerate or delay the emergence of new flu strains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Southeastern Asia (encompassing East, South, and Southeast Asia) is widely considered the global source for seasonal influenza. In a typical year, new strains emerge here and are seeded into temperate regions (like North America or Europe) during their winter months.

However, we haven't fully understood the internal migration network within Asia, nor how major global shocks change it. The authors sought to answer a critical question: When the world is turned upside down by a new pandemic, does the seasonal flu stop moving because we stop traveling (human movement), or because the new virus is "winning" the competition for hosts (pathogen interference)?

Methods

The team employed a multi-modal "phylodynamic" approach, triangulating three distinct types of data from 2007 to 2023:

  1. Epidemiological Data: Weekly positivity rates from the WHO’s FluNet to track the rise and fall of flu seasons.
  2. Genomic Data: Over 6,000 Hemagglutinin (HA) gene sequences for A/H3N2 and B/Victoria viruses.
  3. Mobility Data: Global airline passenger and capacity data from the Official Airline Guide (OAG).

They used a Bayesian framework (specifically the BEAST software package) to reconstruct viral "Markov jumps"—statistical inferences of when and where a virus moved from one sub-region to another. A key novelty was their focus on "persistent lineages"—strains that stay within Southeastern Asia across multiple seasons rather than being re-introduced from the outside.

Datasets

  • Virological Surveillance: WHO-led Global Influenza Surveillance and Response System (GISRS) via FluNet.
  • Genetic Sequences: GISAID and GenBank.
  • Air Travel: Official Airline Guide (OAG) Ltd.
  • Policy Context: The Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker (for NPI stringency).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Persistence of H3N2: The study found that A/H3N2 is much more "at home" in Southeastern Asia than B/Victoria. About 86.5% of H3N2 viruses belonged to persistent local lineages, compared to only 29.1% for B/Victoria. This confirms H3N2’s status as the primary driver of the region's "source" status.
  • Two Pandemics, Two Mechanisms:
    • COVID-19 was a "movement shock." Drastic travel restrictions (a 70.9% drop in airline traffic) physically prevented the virus from spreading, leading to a massive "lag" in antigenic evolution.
  • 2009 H1N1 was a "competition shock." Travel only dipped by 2.4%, but the new H1N1 strain outcompeted H3N2 for susceptible hosts. Interestingly, this competition actually accelerated H3N2’s antigenic evolution as it struggled to survive.
  • Antigenic Heterochrony: The paper introduces the idea that the "lead time" for new strains isn't fixed. During the 2009 pandemic, new H3N2 variants appeared in Asia 10 months earlier than usual. During COVID-19, they lagged by over 5 months.

Key Results

  • Dispersal Rate Collapse: Internal viral movement within Southeastern Asia dropped by 54.7% during the 2009 pandemic and a staggering 79.2% during the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • Seasonal Interruption: The typical Autumn-Winter wave of flu exports from Asia to temperate regions vanished during the COVID-19 era for both subtypes. In 2009, only H3N2 was significantly disrupted; B/Victoria continued to move, though it failed to establish major outbreaks in temperate zones.
  • Lineage Mixing: During the 2021-2022 season (late COVID-19), lineage mixing between East Asia and the rest of the region plummeted, likely due to China’s uniquely prolonged and stringent "Zero-COVID" policies.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Gaps: The dataset lacks significant representation from Africa, Russia, and Central America, which may play unobserved roles in the global network.
  • Regional Averaging: The study uses regional averages for pandemic start dates and NPIs, which might mask finer-scale local variations.
  • Retrospective Nature: While the study describes what happened, it cannot perfectly disentangle the exact percentage of disruption caused by masks vs. social distancing vs. travel bans.

Future Work: The researchers suggest that establishing a global migration network at a finer geographic scale (country-level) could significantly improve our ability to forecast which strains will dominate the next flu season, leading to better-matched vaccines.

Summary updated

Abstract

East, South, and Southeast Asia (together referred to as Southeastern Asia hereafter) have been recognized as critical areas fuelling the global circulation of seasonal influenza. However, the internal migration network of seasonal influenza within Southeastern Asia remains unclear, including how pandemic-related disruptions altered the network structure and circulation dynamics in this region. Here, we leveraged genetic, epidemiological, and airline travel data between 2007-2023 to characterise the multiyear dispersal patterns of influenza A/H3N2 and B/Victoria viruses both out of and within Southeastern Asia, including during seasons marked by perturbations such as the 2009 A/H1N1 and COVID-19 pandemics. We show consistent Autumn-Winter movement waves of A/H3N2 and B/Victoria from Southeastern Asia to temperate regions during interpandemic seasons. During the COVID-19 pandemic this trend was interrupted for both subtypes, however the A/H1N1 pandemic only disrupted A/H3N2 spread. For influenza strains circulating in Southeastern Asia, we find a higher persistence of A/H3N2 than B/Victoria. We find pandemic-related disruptions in A/H3N2 antigenic evolution, with a greater time-advanced antigenic evolution during the 2009 A/H1N1 pandemic, and a greater time-lagged pattern during the COVID-19 pandemic, compared to inter-pandemic levels. Internally, in comparison to the interpandemic seasons, the inferred dispersal rates within Southeastern Asia decreased by 54.7% and 79.2% during the 2009 A/H1N1 and COVID-19 pandemic seasons, respectively; further, the internal movement structure within Southeastern Asia markedly diverged during the COVID-19 pandemic season, and to a lesser extent, during the 2009 A/H1N1 pandemic season. Analyses of the trunk location and phylogenetic similarity further reveal a temporally varying pattern within Southeastern Asia, suggesting a complex source-sink network, with a notable decrease in the mixing of lineages around the COVID-19 pandemic season. Our findings provide insights into the heterogeneous interplay between influenza circulation in Southeastern Asia and two distinct pandemic-related disruptions (strong decline in human movements during the COVID-19 pandemic, pronounced pathogen interference during the A/H1N1 pandemic), which can help anticipate the effects of potential mitigation strategies and the emergence of future influenza pandemic strains on influenza dynamics.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2024disruption,
  author = {Zhiyuan Chen and Joseph L.-H. Tsui and Jun Cai and Cécile Viboud and Louis Du Plessis and Philippe Lemey and Moritz U. G. Kraemer and Hongjie Yu},
  title = {{Disruption of seasonal influenza circulation and evolution during two pandemic events in Southeastern Asia: contrasting the role of human movement and pathogen competition}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.06.19.24309151},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure