Disrupted dynamic functional network connectivity among cognitive control networks in the progression of Alzheimer’s disease

Mohammad S.e. Sendi, Elaheh Zendehrouh, Zening Fu, Jingyu Liu, Yuhui Du, Elizabeth C. Mormino, David H. Salat, Vince D. Calhoun, Robyn L. MillerbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Alzheimer's disease (AD) disrupts not just the strength but also the dynamic, temporal patterns of brain connectivity within the cognitive control network (CCN). By analyzing how brain states change over time, researchers identified distinct connectivity patterns associated with different stages of AD, suggesting these dynamic patterns could serve as biomarkers for disease progression and potential therapeutic targets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder characterized by cognitive decline. While previous research has explored functional brain connectivity in AD, most studies have focused on "static" connectivity, which averages brain activity over an entire scan. This approach overlooks the dynamic, fluctuating nature of brain networks. The authors argue that these dynamic changes are crucial for understanding AD progression and may offer more sensitive biomarkers than static measures. Specifically, they aim to investigate how dynamic functional connectivity (dFC) within the cognitive control network (CCN) changes across different stages of AD, from healthy controls to mild cognitive impairment and mild dementia.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-step approach:

  1. Independent Component Analysis (ICA): They used group ICA to identify 17 distinct components (representing brain regions or networks) within the cognitive control network (CCN) from a large dataset of individuals.
  2. Dynamic Functional Connectivity (dFC) Estimation: For each individual, they calculated dFC by analyzing the time-varying correlations between the identified CCN components using a sliding window approach. This resulted in a measure of how connectivity between these regions changes over time.
  3. State Identification (K-means Clustering): The dFC data was then clustered into three recurring "brain states" using k-means clustering. These states represent distinct patterns of functional connectivity within the CCN.
  4. Hidden Markov Model (HMM) and Occupancy Rate (OCR): For each subject, they estimated the proportion of time spent in each of the three identified states (Occupancy Rate or OCR). This captures the temporal dynamics of brain network engagement.
  5. Statistical Analysis: Finally, they used partial correlations to investigate the relationship between the dFC features (connectivity within each state and OCR) and cognitive scores (specifically, the Mini-Mental State Examination or MMSE), while controlling for age and gender.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Open Access Series of Imaging Studies (OASIS)-3 cohort. This dataset includes imaging (rs-fMRI) and clinical data from 1385 participants, spanning a range of ages (42-95 years) and cognitive statuses, including healthy controls (HC) and individuals with very mild Alzheimer's disease (vmAD).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Static Connectivity: The core idea is that AD doesn't just weaken connections; it fundamentally alters the way brain networks communicate over time.
  • Distinct AD Brain States: The study identified three recurring patterns of CCN connectivity, and importantly, the time spent in these states differed between healthy individuals and those with AD.
  • Temporal Dynamics as Biomarkers: The temporal patterns of brain activity (how long subjects spend in certain states) appear to be more sensitive to AD progression than static connectivity measures.
  • CCN's Role in AD: The cognitive control network, crucial for executive functions, shows significant dynamic alterations in AD, suggesting its dysfunction is a key feature of the disease.

Key Results

  • Connectivity Changes: As AD progresses, connectivity within the middle frontal gyrus tends to increase, while connectivity in the inferior parietal lobule (both within itself and with other CCN regions) decreases.
  • State Occupancy Differences: Healthy controls spend more time in a state characterized by lower within-middle frontal gyrus connectivity and higher connectivity between the hippocampus and the rest of the CCN, compared to individuals with mild dementia.
  • Correlation with Cognition:
    • In State 1, higher connectivity between the inferior parietal lobule and inferior frontal gyrus was positively correlated with MMSE scores.
  • In State 2, lower connectivity within the middle frontal gyrus and its connection with the inferior frontal gyrus were negatively correlated with MMSE.
  • The occupancy rate of State 2 (spending less time in a state with lower middle frontal gyrus connectivity) was positively correlated with MMSE scores, meaning individuals with more severe symptoms spent less time in this state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • MMSE as a Measure: The authors acknowledge that the MMSE is a "noisy" measure for assessing cognitive state in AD.
  • Window Size Choice: The choice of window size for dFC analysis is an implicit assumption and can influence the detection of rapid fluctuations versus smoother trends.
  • Clustering Parameters: K-means clustering requires predefined parameters, and while different distance metrics didn't significantly alter results, other clustering methods might offer improvements.
  • Future Directions:
    • Investigating the dysconnectivity between the CCN and the Default Mode Network (DMN) in AD.
  • Developing methods to mechanistically remove irrelevant networks when studying dynamic functional connectivity.
  • Exploring how modulating these connectivity patterns could be a therapeutic strategy.
  • The authors suggest that the temporal and spatial patterns of CCN connectivity could serve as a biomarker to differentiate AD stages.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is the most common age-related dementia that promotes a decline in memory, thinking, and social skills. The initial stages of dementia can be associated with mild symptoms, and symptom progression to a more severe state is heterogeneous across patients. Recent work has demonstrated the potential for functional network mapping to assist in the prediction of symptomatic progression. However, this work has primarily used static functional connectivity (sFC) from rs-fMRI. Recently, dynamic functional connectivity (dFC) has been recognized as a powerful advance in functional connectivity methodology to differentiate brain network dynamics between healthy and diseased populations. Methods Group independent component analysis was applied to extract 17 components within the cognitive control network (CCN) from 1385 individuals across varying stages of AD symptomology. We estimated dFC among 17 components within the CCN, followed by clustering the dFCs into 3 recurring brain states and then estimated a hidden Markov model and the occupancy rate for each subject. Finally, we investigated the link between CCN dFC connectivity features with AD progression. Results Progression of AD symptoms were associated with increases in connectivity within the middle frontal gyrus. Also, the AD with mild and severer symptoms showed less connectivity within the inferior parietal lobule and between this region with the rest of CCN. Finally, comparing with mild dementia, we found that the normal brain spends significantly more time in a state with lower within middle frontal gyrus connectivity and higher connectivity between the hippocampus and the rest of CCN, highlighting the importance of assessing the dynamics of brain connectivity in this disease. Conclusion Our results suggest that AD progress not only alters the CCN connectivity strength but also changes the temporal properties in this brain network. This suggests the temporal and spatial pattern of CCN as a biomarker that differentiates different stages of AD. Impact Statement By assuming that functional connectivity is static over time, many of previous studies have ignored the brain dynamic in Alzheimer’s disease progression. Here, a longitudinal resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging data are used to explore the temporal changes of functional connectivity in the cognitive control network in Alzheimer’s disease progression. The result of this study would increase our understanding about the underlying mechanisms of Alzheimer’s Disease and help in finding future treatment of this neurological disorder.
BibTeX
@misc{sendi2021disrupted,
  author = {Mohammad S.E. Sendi and Elaheh Zendehrouh and Zening Fu and Jingyu Liu and Yuhui Du and Elizabeth C. Mormino and David H. Salat and Vince D. Calhoun and Robyn L. Miller},
  title = {{Disrupted dynamic functional network connectivity among cognitive control networks in the progression of Alzheimer’s disease}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.12.31.424877},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure