Abstract
The construction industry in developing countries like Vietnam, which incorporates small and medium construction enterprises, is typically more prone to disputes and contract dispute-related lawsuits. A dispute may occur at any time in the life cycle of the project. It is sometimes solved with the intermediation of a lawyer or directly by stakeholders. Understanding the causes of disputes in a construction project not only improves the efficiency of a company but also increases the success of projects. This study was carried out using a questionnaire survey at construction projects in Ho Chi Minh City. Sample data with 117 observations were analyzed to find the disputing factors in construction projects: diversity of working style among the parties; reluctance to work; and poor teamwork. Correlation coefficient on a rank of factors between design consultant and contractor; Design consultant and project owners are positively correlated. The Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) analysis identified six groups of factors in construction disputes: cooperation, technology, economics, productivity, information, and behavior. The findings are useful for enterprise practice and provide participants with an overview of sources of dispute. Thus, a more complete risk management plan can be formulated, which will accelerate project progress and improve the likelihood of success.
Introduction
The construction industry in developing nations like Vietnam is notoriously dispute-prone. These conflicts lead to prolonged resolution times, severe damages, and frequent litigation. While technical errors are often blamed, the root causes are frequently buried in the complex interactions between stakeholders, including owners, contractors, and designers. This paper addresses the lack of empirical data regarding why these disputes happen in the specific context of Vietnam’s small and medium-sized construction enterprises. By identifying and ranking these factors, the study aims to help managers formulate better risk management plans to accelerate project progress and improve success rates.
Methodology
The researchers employed a multi-stage statistical approach to identify and analyze dispute factors. The process began with a literature review and pilot study to distill 26 potential factors. These were then incorporated into a survey instrument using a 5-point Likert scale, distributed to professionals in Ho Chi Minh City.
Statistical analysis included mean ranking to determine factor impact, Spearman’s Rho correlation to assess stakeholder agreement, and Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) with Varimax rotation to group the 26 factors into six broader themes. Cronbach’s Alpha was used to ensure data reliability.
Results
The study analyzed 117 qualified responses from a diverse group of industry professionals. The cohort was predominantly male (81.2%) and experienced, with over 80% having more than five years in the industry. Respondents included design consultants (42.7%), contractors (18.8%), and owners/project managers (18.8%).
The analysis revealed that behavioral and organizational factors are perceived as the most significant drivers of disputes. The top-ranked factor was "Diversity of working style among parties" (Mean = 3.82), followed by "Reluctance to work" and "Poor teamwork."
The EFA successfully grouped the 26 factors into six components explaining 81.5% of the total variance:
- Co-operate-related (19.6%): Unilateral termination, untimely payments.
- Technology-related (13.4%): Design flaws, schedule delays.
- Economy-related (13.4%): Material price spikes, financial controls.
- Productive-related (13.1%): Individual engagement, working manners.
- Information-related (12.1%): Lack of instructions, slow response to contingencies.
- Behavior-related (9.9%): Communication, trust, cultural diversity.
Discussion
A critical finding of this research is that behavioral factors outweigh technical ones. The prominence of "soft" factors like clashing working styles suggests that project failure is often a human-centric problem rather than a purely engineering one.
Furthermore, a significant "perception gap" was identified between contractors and owners. While designers and contractors show a strong correlation in their ranking of factors ($r = 0.788$), the correlation between contractors and owners was not statistically significant ($r = 0.343, p > 0.05$). This disconnect suggests that owners have a fundamentally different perspective on project risks, which can become a breeding ground for conflict. Additionally, the high ranking of "non-serviceable contract information" (5th) underscores how vague contracts prevent parties from effectively managing risks.
Conclusion
This study provides a roadmap for project managers in Vietnam to move from reactive firefighting to proactive risk management by focusing on behavioral and organizational alignment. While the study is limited by its focus on Ho Chi Minh City and the use of convenience sampling, the findings offer valuable insights for enterprise practice. Future work should focus on integrating these factors into formal risk management frameworks and investigating intervention protocols, such as standardized communication platforms, to mitigate these identified risks.
Summary updated