Displaced searches for light vector bosons at Belle II

Triparno Bandyopadhyay, Sabyasachi Chakraborty, Sokratis TrifinopoulosJournal of High Energy Physics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

The Belle II experiment, with its advanced tracking capabilities and high luminosity, is poised to become a powerful tool for discovering new, weakly interacting particles. This paper outlines how Belle II can probe previously unexplored parameter spaces for light vector bosons, including dark photons and Z' bosons, with potential implications for anomalies in muon magnetic moments and the ATOMKI anomaly.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, while incredibly successful, leaves some phenomena unexplained. These include persistent anomalies in the magnetic moment of the muon (g-2) and, more recently, intriguing results from the ATOMKI experiment concerning electron-positron pair emissions. These anomalies hint at the existence of new, light particles that interact weakly with known matter. Identifying such particles is a major goal of modern particle physics. Specifically, this paper focuses on light vector bosons (particles that mediate forces, like the photon) that are not part of the Standard Model. These hypothetical particles, such as "dark photons" or Z' bosons, are predicted by various extensions to the Standard Model. A key challenge in searching for these particles is that they are expected to have very weak interactions, making them difficult to detect. Furthermore, if they have a small mass and weak coupling, they can travel a measurable distance within a detector before decaying, leading to "displaced vertices" – decay points not at the primary collision point. This paper addresses how the Belle II experiment can effectively search for these elusive particles by exploiting their potential for displaced decays.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in simulating and projecting the sensitivity of the Belle II experiment to light vector bosons. The authors leverage the detailed understanding of Belle II's detector components, particularly its tracking systems (PXD, SVD, CDC), to estimate the efficiency of reconstructing displaced vertices. They employ a model-dependent approach, focusing on specific theoretical scenarios like the dark photon and various Z' boson models (e.g., Lµ - Lτ, Le - Lµ, B - L).

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Displaced Vertex Reconstruction Efficiency (VRE): The paper develops a model for VRE that accounts for the detector's geometric acceptance and the linearly falling efficiency with increasing radial distance from the beam line. This is crucial for particles that travel a finite distance before decaying.
  • Decay Length Distribution: The probability of a particle decaying at a certain distance is modeled using an exponentially falling distribution, characterized by a decay length (λ). This decay length is directly related to the particle's mass, coupling strength, and boost factor.
  • Cross-Section Calculation: For each model, the differential cross-section for the production of the vector boson is calculated, considering relevant interaction Lagrangians and Feynman diagrams.
  • Event Simulation and Projection: The authors combine the production cross-section, detector efficiencies (including particle identification), and geometric/kinematic cuts to project the number of signal events expected for various parameter space points (mass vs. coupling strength).
  • Exclusion Limits: By comparing the projected number of signal events to a statistical criterion (e.g., 2.3 events for 90% CL exclusion), they derive exclusion limits on the parameter space of these models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical projections and simulations for future data collection at Belle II, rather than analysis of existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Belle II as a Displaced Vertex Search Hub: The paper strongly advocates for Belle II's unique capabilities in searching for light, weakly interacting particles that exhibit displaced decays, a niche where it can outperform previous experiments.
  • Complementarity of Displaced Searches: Displaced vertex searches at Belle II are shown to probe regions of parameter space that are complementary to existing prompt searches and other experimental constraints.
  • Probing the Muon (g-2) Anomaly: For models like the Lµ - Lτ Z' boson, Belle II's sensitivity can directly probe parameter space consistent with the observed muon anomalous magnetic moment.
  • ATOMKI Anomaly Connection: The paper highlights that even with current Belle II data (~200 fb⁻¹), the experiment can already constrain parameter space relevant to the X(17) boson, a proposed solution to the ATOMKI anomaly.
  • Model-Specific Sensitivities: The analysis demonstrates how different theoretical models (dark photon vs. various Z' models) lead to distinct sensitivities and exclusion regions, underscoring the importance of model-specific investigations.

Key Results

  • Projected Sensitivity for Dark Photons: Belle II is projected to exclude a significant portion of the dark photon parameter space for masses between 10 MeV and 500 MeV, particularly for couplings below 10⁻⁶, at its design luminosity of 50 ab⁻¹.
  • Competitive Limits with Current Data: Even with ~200 fb⁻¹ of data, Belle II is expected to achieve limits competitive with experiments like NA64 and E141 for certain parameter regions.
  • Lµ - Lτ Z' Boson Sensitivity: The paper shows that Belle II can probe parameter space for the Lµ - Lτ Z' boson that is compatible with the muon (g-2) anomaly, especially for smaller electron couplings.
  • Le - Lµ and Le - Lτ Models: Belle II is projected to set strong limits on these models, covering large regions of parameter space due to their coupling to first-generation fermions.
  • Protophobic Model Constraints: For the protophobic model, Belle II's projected limits at 200 fb⁻¹ are shown to be stronger than existing limits from NA64, potentially ruling out the X(17) explanation for the ATOMKI anomaly.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The analysis makes certain simplifying assumptions, such as neglecting A'-Z kinetic mixing and not considering dark sector particles in the dark photon model. The authors note that these can be incorporated in future, more detailed analyses.
  • Efficiency Model: The VRE efficiency is modeled as a linearly falling function. A more detailed, data-driven efficiency model could improve the precision of the projections.
  • Hadronic Final States: While hadronic final states were considered, the detector's sensitivity to displaced vertices in these channels was found to be limited for the mass ranges studied. Future work could explore these channels more thoroughly if new detector capabilities or analysis techniques become available.
  • Backgrounds: The projected limits are derived assuming negligible backgrounds. A full experimental analysis would require a detailed understanding and mitigation of various SM and new physics backgrounds.

The authors suggest that Belle II's displaced vertex search capabilities are a crucial avenue for exploring new physics and encourage the collaboration to analyze their data with this hypothesis in mind.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract With a design luminosity of 50 ab − 1 and detectors with tracking capabilities extending beyond 1 m, the Belle II experiment is the perfect laboratory for the search of particles that couple weakly to the Standard Model and have a characteristic decay length of a few centimetres and more. We show that for models of dark photons and other light vector bosons, Belle II will be successful in probing regions of parameter space which are as of now unexplored by any experiment. In addition, for models where the vector boson couples sub-dominantly to the electron and quarks as compared to muons, e.g. in the L μ −L τ model, Belle II will probe regions of mass and couplings compatible with the anomalous magnetic moment of muon. We discuss these results and derive the projected sensitivity of Belle II for a handful of other models. Finally, even with the currently accumulated data, ∼ 200 fb − 1 , Belle II should be able to cover regions of parameter space pertaining to the X(17) boson postulated to solve the ATOMKI anomaly.
BibTeX
@article{bandyopadhyay2022displaced,
  author = {Triparno Bandyopadhyay and Sabyasachi Chakraborty and Sokratis Trifinopoulos},
  title = {{Displaced searches for light vector bosons at Belle II}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep05(2022)141},
}
Figure