Disparities in Unmet Health Care Needs Among US Children During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Sanjana Pampati, Nicole Liddon, Elizabeth A. Stuart, Lance A. Waller, Jonetta J. Mpofu, Benjamin A. Lopman, Susan Hocevar Adkins, Jodie L. Guest, Jeb JonesThe Annals of Family Medicine 2024 · DOI

Abstract: Our findings highlight the need for continued research examining unmet health care needs and for continued efforts to optimize the clinical experience to be culturally inclusive.

Introduction

While the immediate clinical impacts of COVID-19 on children were well-documented early in the pandemic, the "shadow" impact on routine pediatric care—including well-child visits, vaccinations, and the management of chronic conditions—remained less clear. The pandemic introduced significant new barriers to care, such as office closures and fear of infection, while simultaneously exacerbating existing structural inequities like lack of insurance and systemic discrimination. This study quantifies these disruptions, revealing that nearly 1 in 6 children aged 5–12 in the U.S. experienced forgone medical care during this period.

Methodology

Researchers utilized a longitudinal survey design, analyzing data from two waves of the COVID Experiences Survey (CovEx). Participants were recruited from the AmeriSpeak panel (NORC), a probability-based panel designed to be representative of the U.S. household population. Wave 1 was conducted in late 2020, followed by Wave 2 in Spring 2021, capturing a critical window of the pandemic's middle phase with a total of 1,287 participating parents.

The study employed multivariate logistic regression models using predicted marginal standardization to estimate adjusted prevalence ratios (APRs) for three primary outcomes: forgone care, forgone well-child visits, and the absence of any well-child visit in the preceding year. The models adjusted for child age, sex, and race/ethnicity while examining factors across the social ecology, including parental experiences of racism (measured via a modified Everyday Discrimination Scale), household income, and county-level data such as urbanicity and physician-to-population ratios.

Key Findings and Drivers of Unmet Need

The research highlights that unmet pediatric needs were not distributed equally, with significant disparities driven by race, existing health conditions, school instruction modes, and parental experiences of systemic racism.

The Impact of Systemic Racism

One of the most striking findings was the powerful correlation between parental experiences of racism and unmet child health needs. In the frequency-based model, children of parents who reported the highest levels of experienced racism had a model-adjusted prevalence of 70.3% for forgone care, compared to just 11.8% for those whose parents reported no such experiences. This suggests that systemic discrimination acts as a primary barrier to accessing the healthcare system.

Racial and Geographic Disparities

  • Racial Gaps: Hispanic children (APR 1.6) and non-Hispanic multiracial children (APR 1.7) were significantly more likely to experience forgone care than non-Hispanic White children.
  • Geographic Constraints: Children in rural counties were 1.7 times more likely to have missed a well-child visit compared to their suburban peers, highlighting supply-side constraints in healthcare availability.
  • Economic Barriers: Households with annual incomes between $30,000 and $100,000 were more likely to report no well-child visits than those earning over $100,000, affirming that affordability remains a significant gatekeeper for routine care.

Structural and Behavioral Barriers

While the top reason cited for forgoing care was the behavioral fear of catching COVID-19 (38.0%), the second most common reason was structural: difficulty in making an appointment (18.6%). Additionally, a "modality gap" was observed; children attending school virtually were significantly more likely to have forgone care than those attending in person. In-person schooling often triggers healthcare touchpoints, such as requirements for sports physicals or referrals from school nurses, which were lost during remote learning.

The Paradox of Existing Conditions

Children with existing emotional or mental health conditions were twice as likely to experience forgone care, yet they were more likely to have had a well-child visit in the past year than their healthy peers. This suggests that while these children have higher "touch" rates with the healthcare system, their complex needs still frequently go unmet during periods of systemic strain.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study's findings underscore the high rates of unmet pediatric needs during the pandemic: 16.3% of children had forgone care of any type, and 30.1% had no well-child visit in the year leading up to Spring 2021.

Limitations of the study include a lack of a direct pre-pandemic baseline for the cohort and the exclusion of non-English speakers, which likely underrepresents the experiences of households with limited English proficiency—a group often at high risk for healthcare disparities. Future interventions must focus on "culturally inclusive" clinical optimizations and multilevel strategies that address structural racism to ensure equitable access to care during future public health emergencies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our findings highlight the need for continued research examining unmet health care needs and for continued efforts to optimize the clinical experience to be culturally inclusive.
BibTeX
@article{pampati2024disparities,
  author = {Sanjana Pampati and Nicole Liddon and Elizabeth A. Stuart and Lance A. Waller and Jonetta J. Mpofu and Benjamin A. Lopman and Susan Hocevar Adkins and Jodie L. Guest and Jeb Jones},
  title = {{Disparities in Unmet Health Care Needs Among US Children During the COVID-19 Pandemic}},
  journal = {The Annals of Family Medicine},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1370/afm.3079},
}
Figure