Disk-Drive-Like Operations in the Hippocampus

Wilten Nicola, David Dupret, Claudia ClopathbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel computational model of the hippocampus, the "Neural Disk Drive" (NDD), which directly maps hippocampal dynamics to the operations of a computer's hard disk drive. By building a tripartite spiking neural network, the authors demonstrate how theta oscillations, sharp-wave ripples, and attractor dynamics can be understood as analogous to disk rotation, read/write heads, and actuator arms, respectively, offering a new framework for understanding memory formation and replay.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The hippocampus is known for its remarkable ability to encode and replay memories, often in compressed forms. While oscillations like theta and sharp-wave ripples, along with attractor dynamics, have been implicated in these processes, their precise interplay and the underlying computational mechanisms remain elusive. The authors aim to bridge this gap by proposing a concrete computational analogy: that the hippocampus operates much like a computer's hard disk drive, performing explicit, computer-like operations for memory storage and retrieval. This analogy offers a new lens through which to understand the complex dynamics observed in the hippocampus.

Methods

The core of this paper is the construction and simulation of a tripartite spiking neural network model, the Neural Disk Drive (NDD). This model comprises three interconnected networks:

  • Rotating Disk Network: This network, inspired by hippocampal sharp-wave ripples (SWRs) and theta oscillations, is trained to exhibit cyclical activity analogous to a spinning disk. Interneurons form a "ring" that drives this rotation.
  • Actuator Arm Network: This network, based on attractor dynamics, is trained to mimic the behavior of a disk drive's actuator arm, which points to specific "tracks" on the disk. This is implemented using a recurrent spiking neural network trained with FORCE training to exhibit line attractor dynamics.
  • Read/Write Head Network: This network, responsible for encoding and retrieving information, is modeled using Hebbian plasticity. It learns to associate patterns of activity in the rotating disk network with specific "bits" of information.

The authors also employed Maximum Likelihood Alignment (MLE) to align spike times across trials in experimental data, a crucial step for identifying repeating neural sequences.

Datasets

The paper utilizes experimental data from rats navigating a cheeseboard maze. This data consists of multi-unit recordings from hippocampal ensembles and local field potentials (LFPs). The authors do not introduce new datasets but rather re-analyze existing data to validate their model's predictions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hippocampus as a Disk Drive: The most striking insight is the direct mapping of hippocampal dynamics to hard disk drive components and operations. This provides a powerful, intuitive framework for understanding complex neural processes.
  • Oscillations as Rotation, Attractors as Tracks: Theta oscillations are mapped to disk rotation, while attractor dynamics in the actuator arm network represent the selection of specific "tracks" (neuronal assemblies) on the disk.
  • Interneuron Ring as Rotator: The model predicts and finds evidence for interneuron ring-sequences acting as the fundamental "rotator" for the neural disk.
  • Hebbian Plasticity for Read/Write: Hebbian plasticity is proposed as the biological mechanism for the read/write head, enabling the encoding and retrieval of information onto neural "tracks."
  • Replay as Data Access: Various forms of hippocampal replay (forward, reverse, extended, fragmented) are interpreted as specific data-accessing events within the NDD model.

Key Results

  • The NDD model successfully reproduces key hippocampal dynamics, including theta sequences, phase precession, compressed sequences during SWRs, and a zoo of replay phenomena.
  • The model predicts the existence of "interneuron-ring-sequences," which the authors confirmed in experimental data from rats.
  • The model provides a mechanistic explanation for how hippocampal oscillations and attractor dynamics can work together to form and replay memories.
  • The authors suggest that the hippocampus might store data in a compressed format, given the estimated storage capacity of the NDD model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplifications: The NDD model is a simplification of the complex hippocampal circuitry. For instance, the "tracks" are represented by subsets of neurons, and the "bits" are encoded through synaptic weights.
  • Experimental Validation: While the model predicts interneuron-ring-sequences, further experimental validation of other aspects of the NDD model would be beneficial.
  • Storage Capacity: The estimated storage capacity of the NDD model for rats is in the order of gigabytes, suggesting that the hippocampus might employ data compression for complex memories or primarily store recent events.
  • Future Directions: The authors anticipate that their model could lead to further research exploring the hypothesis that the brain performs explicit, computer-like operations, potentially leading to new models that revisit this idea. They also suggest exploring how multi-track storage and the total storage space of the hippocampus might be implemented.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The rapid computation of re-playable memories within the hippocampus in the form of spike sequences is a near computer-like operation. Information can be encoded once during the initial experience, and replayed numerous times after in a compressed-time representation [1–8]. Theta oscillations, sharp-wave ripples, and attractor dynamics have been posited to collectively play a role in the formation and replay of memories. However, the precise interplay between these dynamical states remains elusive. Here, we show that the memory formation dynamics and operations of the hippocampus are not just computer-like, but map directly onto the dynamics and operations of a disk-drive. We constructed a tripartite spiking neural network model where the hippocampus is explicitly described as a disk drive with a rotating disk, an actuator arm, and a read/write head. In this Neural Disk Drive (NDD) model, hippocampal oscillations map to disk rotations in the rotating disk network while attractor dynamics in the actuator arm network point to “tracks” (spike assemblies) on the disk. The read/write head then writes information onto these tracks, which have temporally-structured spikes. Tracks can be replayed during hippocampal ripples for consolidation. We confirmed the existence of interneuron-ring-sequences, predicted by the rotating disk network, in experimental data. Our results establish the hippocampus as a brain region displaying explicit, computer-like operations. Based on the known interactions between the hippocampus and other brain areas, we anticipate that our results may lead to additional models that revisit the hypothesis that the brain performs explicit, computer-like operations.
BibTeX
@misc{nicola2022disk,
  author = {Wilten Nicola and David Dupret and Claudia Clopath},
  title = {{Disk-Drive-Like Operations in the Hippocampus}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.10.05.511000},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure