Disgust as an emotional driver of vaccine attitudes and uptake? A mediation analysis

Paula M. Luz, Heidi E. Brown, Claúdio J. StruchinerEpidemiology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Research on the drivers of vaccine acceptance has expanded, but most interventions fall short of coverage targets. This study explored whether vaccine uptake is driven directly or indirectly by disgust, with attitudes towards vaccines acting as a possible mediator. An online cross-sectional study of 1,007 US adults found that Disgust Sensitivity and Germ Aversion have a twofold effect: a direct positive effect on vaccine uptake and an indirect negative effect through vaccine attitudes. In contrast, Perceived Susceptibility had only a direct positive effect. These psychological drivers, however, were small compared to economic and logistic determinants.

Introduction: The "Yuck" Factor in Vaccination

Public health officials often struggle to understand why vaccine coverage falls short of targets, even when vaccines are free and accessible. Traditional models focus on rational decision-making—weighing risks versus benefits. However, this research investigates a more visceral driver: disgust.

Disgust is considered part of our "behavioral immune system" (BIS), an evolutionary adaptation designed to help us avoid pathogens. This study addresses a paradox: Does disgust make us want vaccines to avoid disease, or does it make us avoid them because we view the needle or the biological agent as a contaminant? By using mediation analysis, the researchers aimed to disentangle these conflicting emotional pathways.

Methodology

The researchers conducted an online cross-sectional study in January 2017, surveying 1,007 US adults via Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (MTurk). They employed several validated psychometric instruments:

  • Revised Disgust Scale (DS-R): Measures general disgust sensitivity.
  • Perceived Vulnerability to Disease (PVD) scale: Split into Germ Aversion (discomfort with potential contamination) and Perceived Susceptibility (belief in one's likelihood of getting sick).
  • Vaccine Attitudes Scale: A 6-item scale measuring trust in vaccine efficacy and safety.

The core of the study is a mediation analysis, which determines if an exposure (disgust) affects an outcome (vaccine uptake) directly, or indirectly by first changing a mediator (vaccine attitudes).

Results: The Double-Edged Sword of Disgust

The analysis revealed that Disgust Sensitivity and Germ Aversion have a "twofold" effect. They directly increase the likelihood of vaccination (the protective impulse), but they also correlate with negative attitudes toward vaccines (the contamination impulse). These two effects essentially cancel each other out in the "total effect" calculation.

Forest plots showing the direct, indirect, and total effects of Disgust, Germ Aversion, and Perceived Susceptibility on vaccine uptake.

In contrast, Perceived Susceptibility—the cognitive belief that one might get sick—had a strong, direct positive effect on uptake (OR 1.32) without the negative "yuck" baggage associated with germ aversion.

The Role of Mediation

The mediation model clarifies how emotional states translate into behavior. For Germ Aversion, the indirect path through vaccine attitudes is negative (OR 0.92), suggesting that highly germ-averse individuals may view the act of vaccination itself as a form of contamination, even if they fear disease.

Mediation diagram illustrating the path from Germ Aversion to Vaccine Uptake through Vaccine Attitude.

Conclusion and Practical Implications

While the psychological insights are fascinating, the study found that "factual" barriers—like whether a vaccine is offered at your workplace—have a much larger impact on actual behavior than emotional sensitivity. The strongest predictors for getting a flu shot were being in a priority group (OR 3.82) and having the vaccine offered at the workplace (OR 3.48).

However, understanding the role of disgust explains why "debunking" myths often fails; logic is frequently insufficient to override a visceral emotional response. Future public health messaging might need to account for these deep-seated emotional drivers to improve vaccine acceptance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Research on the drivers of vaccine acceptance has expanded but most interventions fall short of coverage targets. We explored whether vaccine uptake is driven directly or indirectly by disgust with attitudes towards vaccines acting as a possible mediator. An online cross-sectional study of 1007 adults of the USA via Amazon's Mechanical Turk was conducted in January 2017. The questionnaire consisted of four sections: (1) items assessing attitudes towards vaccines and vaccine uptake, (2) revised Disgust Scale (DS-R) to measure Disgust Sensitivity, (3) Perceived Vulnerability to Disease scale (PVD) to measure Germ Aversion and Perceived Susceptibility, and (4) socio-demographic information. Using mediation analysis, we assess the direct, the indirect (through Vaccine Attitudes) and the total effect of Disgust Sensitivity, Germ Aversion and Perceived Susceptibility on 2016 self-reported flu vaccine uptake. Mediation analysis showed the effect of Disgust Sensitivity and Germ Aversion on vaccine uptake to be twofold: a direct positive effect on vaccine uptake and an indirect negative effect through Vaccine Attitudes. In contrast, Perceived Susceptibility was found to have only a direct positive effect on vaccine uptake. Nonetheless, these effects were attenuated and small compared to economic, logistic and psychological determinants of vaccine uptake.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luz2019disgust,
  author = {Paula M. Luz and Heidi E. Brown and Claúdio J. Struchiner},
  title = {{Disgust as an emotional driver of vaccine attitudes and uptake? A mediation analysis}},
  booktitle = {Epidemiology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1017/s0950268819000517},
}
Figure