Disentangling the distal association between β-Amyloid and tau pathology at varying stages of tau deposition

Seyed Hani Hojjati, Gloria Chiang, Tracy Butler, Mony J. de Leon, Ajay Gupta, Yi Li, Mert R. Sabuncu, Farnia Feiz, Siddharth Nayak, Jacob Shteingart, Sindy Ozoria, Saman Gholipour Picha, Antonio Fernández, Yaakov Stern, José A. Luchsinger, Davangere P. Devanand, Qolamreza RazlighimedRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have identified a "distal association" between the two primary hallmarks of Alzheimer’s Disease—amyloid-beta (Aβ) and tau—showing that they correlate across different brain regions long before they physically overlap. This interaction peaks during a critical "acceleration phase" in asymptomatic individuals, suggesting that Aβ may act as a remote catalyst for tau spread before the two pathologies eventually "uncouple" in the later stages of the disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the study of Alzheimer’s Disease (AD), we have two main villains: extracellular Aβ plaques and intracellular tau tangles. Historically, researchers have faced a topographical puzzle: Aβ typically begins accumulating in the association cortices (like the precuneus and frontal lobes), while tau begins in the medial temporal lobe (MTL). They start in different places, yet we know they are linked.

Most studies focus on "local" associations—where the two proteins physically overlap. However, this ignores the early stages of the disease where they are spatially separated. This paper addresses the "distal association" gap: How does Aβ in one part of the brain relate to tau in another? Understanding this "long-distance" relationship is vital for identifying the window where therapeutic intervention might actually stop tau from spreading.

Methods

The authors employed several clever techniques to map this relationship:

  • Regional Cut-points: Rather than using a single "global" threshold for what counts as Aβ or tau positive, they established 68 region-specific thresholds. These were based on the 95th percentile of a "normative" group of young, healthy adults (ages 20-39) to account for natural variation and "off-target" tracer binding.
  • Pseudo-longitudinal Staging: Since following patients for decades is difficult, the researchers used a "snapshot" of 572 elderly subjects and sorted them based on how many brain regions showed tau positivity. This allowed them to categorize subjects into four phases: No-tau, Pre-acceleration, Acceleration, and Post-acceleration.
  • Distal Regression Modeling: To find distal links, they used multiple linear regression. For a specific "target" region of tau, they looked at Aβ levels in all other 67 regions, while controlling for age, gender, and—crucially—the local Aβ in that target region. This isolated the "long-distance" effect.

Datasets

  • Elderly Cohort: 572 subjects (477 healthy controls, 14 with MCI, and 82 with mild AD) from eight research cohorts at Weill Cornell Medicine and Columbia University.
  • Young Reference Cohort: 144 healthy individuals (aged 20-39) used to define "normal" baseline levels for PET tracers.
  • Imaging: 3T T1-weighted MRI for structural mapping, 18F-MK6240 PET for tau, and 18F-Florbetaben or 18F-Florbetapir PET for Aβ.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The MTL as a Hub: In the early "pre-acceleration" phase, distal associations are already present, specifically involving tau in the entorhinal cortex and parahippocampal gyrus. These regions act as "hubs" that are sensitive to Aβ levels elsewhere in the brain.
  • The Acceleration Peak: The strongest distal associations occur during the "acceleration phase." In this stage, tau in 28 out of 68 regions showed significant links to Aβ in other areas.
  • The "Aβ+ Healthy Control" Sweet Spot: The most surprising finding was that asymptomatic healthy controls who were Aβ-positive showed the highest degree of distal association. This suggests a "critical window" where Aβ is actively driving tau spread before clinical symptoms appear.
  • The Late-Stage Uncoupling: In the "post-acceleration" phase (mostly MCI and AD patients), the distal association actually weakens. It appears that once the "fire" of tau pathology is widespread, it becomes somewhat independent of the Aβ "matches" that started it.

Key Results

  • Phase Distribution: The study successfully categorized the 572 subjects: 229 in No-tau, 155 in Pre-acceleration, 143 in Acceleration, and 45 in Post-acceleration.
  • Statistical Significance: In the acceleration phase, the entorhinal cortex and parahippocampal gyrus showed distal associations with more than 55 regions of Aβ deposition.
  • Clinical Correlation: While 96% of the post-acceleration group were Aβ-positive and had MCI or AD, their distal association scores were lower than those in the earlier acceleration phase.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-sectional Data: The "pseudo-longitudinal" approach is a model of progression, not a direct observation of it. A true longitudinal study (tracking the same people over years) is needed to confirm if these distal Aβ levels actually predict the future rate of tau accumulation.
  • Tracer Variability: The study used two different Aβ tracers (Florbetaben and Florbetapir). While the authors used "Centiloid" scaling to standardize the data, slight differences in tracer behavior are always a factor in PET research.
  • Sample Size: While 572 is a robust number for PET studies, some sub-groups (like MCI) were relatively small, potentially limiting the statistical power to detect even finer associations.
  • Mechanism: The study shows that an association exists, but not how. The authors suggest neural hyperactivation or disruption of connectivity as potential mechanisms, which warrants further investigation in animal models or functional MRI studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Studies on the histopathology of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) strongly suggest that extracellular β-amyloid (Aβ) plaques promote the spread of neurofibrillary tau tangles. Despite well-documented spatial discrepancies between these two proteinopathies, their association remains elusive. In this study, we aimed to investigate the distal (non-local) association between tau and Aβ deposition by studying the Aβ, and tau positron emission tomography (PET) scans of 572 elderly subjects, aged 67.11 ± 6.08 years (476 healthy controls (HC), 14 with mild cognitive impairment (MCI), 82 mild AD). We also leveraged 47 tau-PET and 97 Aβ-PET scans of healthy young individuals (aged 20-40) to find regional cut-points for tau- and Aβ-positivity in 68 cortical regions in the brain. Based on these cut-points, we implemented a pseudo longitudinal technique to categorize the elderly subjects into four pathologic phases of AD progression: a no-tau phase, a pre-acceleration phase, an acceleration phase, and a post-acceleration phase. We then assessed the distal association between tau and Aβ in each phase using multiple linear regression models. First, we show that the association between tau and Aβ starts distally in medial temporal lobe (MTL) regions of tau (e.g., left and right entorhinal cortex and right parahippocampal gyrus) in the early stage of tau aggregation (pre-acceleration phase). We then show that tau in several bilateral brain regions (particularly the entorhinal cortex and parahippocampal gyrus) exhibits strong distal associations with Aβ in several cortical brain regions during the acceleration phase. We found a weak distal association in the post-acceleration phase, comprising 96% of MCI or mild AD and Aβ+ subjects. Most importantly, we show that the HC Aβ+ subjects have the highest degree of distal association between tau and Aβ of all the subjects in the acceleration phase. The results of this study characterize the distal association between the two key proteinopathies of AD. This information has potential use for understanding disease progression in the brain and for the development of anti-tau therapeutic agents.
BibTeX
@misc{hojjati2023disentangling,
  author = {Seyed Hani Hojjati and Gloria Chiang and Tracy Butler and Mony J. de Leon and Ajay Gupta and Yi Li and Mert R. Sabuncu and Farnia Feiz and Siddharth Nayak and Jacob Shteingart and Sindy Ozoria and Saman Gholipour Picha and Antonio Fernández and Yaakov Stern and José A. Luchsinger and Davangere P. Devanand and Qolamreza Razlighi},
  title = {{Disentangling the distal association between β-Amyloid and tau pathology at varying stages of tau deposition}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.03.31.23288013},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure