Disentangling heavy flavor at colliders

P. Ilten, Nicholas L. Rodd, Jesse Thaler, Mike WilliamsPhysical 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces two novel techniques, SoftDrop jet declustering and the FlavorCone algorithm, to better understand how heavy quarks (charm and beauty) are produced in high-energy particle collisions. These methods offer new ways to test fundamental predictions of quantum chromodynamics and improve the simulations used to interpret collider data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

At particle colliders like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), understanding the production of heavy quarks is crucial for both testing the Standard Model of particle physics and searching for new physics. A particularly challenging aspect is disentangling the various ways these heavy quarks are created, especially the process of "gluon splitting" (where a gluon decays into a heavy quark-antiquark pair). This process is difficult to isolate experimentally and theoretically, leading to uncertainties in our understanding of heavy-flavor physics. Existing jet-finding algorithms often struggle to properly handle events where the resulting heavy quarks are very close together, leading to a loss of information.

Methods

The authors propose two main methods:

  • SoftDrop Jet Declustering: This technique takes a large "fat jet" (a collection of particles originating from a high-energy collision) and recursively "declusters" it to reveal its substructure. By applying flavor tagging (identifying if the subjets contain charm or beauty quarks) to the resulting two subjets, the authors can test the fundamental "splitting functions" of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) that describe how quarks and gluons split. This method is particularly useful for studying the kinematics of heavy-quark production and even the production of quarkonium states (like J/ψ and Υ).
  • FlavorCone Algorithm: This novel jet algorithm is designed specifically to address the challenge of closely spaced heavy-quark jets, which is characteristic of gluon splitting. Instead of relying on traditional jet-finding algorithms that might merge nearby jets, FlavorCone defines jets by centering them around the flight directions of identified heavy-flavor hadrons. This allows the algorithm to smoothly transition from well-separated heavy-quark jets to the overlapping regime of gluon splitting, providing a more complete picture of this process.

Datasets

The authors use simulated data from parton-shower generators, primarily PYTHIA 8.212 and HERWIG++ 2.7.1, to test their proposed methods. They also consider results from other generators like VINCIA and DIRE, and matched NLO calculations from POWHEGBOX. These simulations are used to evaluate the performance of their algorithms and compare different theoretical predictions. No new experimental datasets are introduced in this paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flavor-tagged hadrons are key: The paper emphasizes that directly identifying and using the properties of individual heavy-flavor hadrons is more powerful than simply tagging jets that contain them. This allows for a more precise study of the underlying physics.
  • SoftDrop reveals fundamental splitting functions: The SoftDrop algorithm, when combined with flavor tagging, provides a direct experimental handle on the theoretical splitting functions that govern how quarks and gluons interact.
  • FlavorCone bridges the gap: The FlavorCone algorithm offers a unique way to study the gluon-splitting regime, which is problematic for traditional jet finders that tend to merge nearby jets. FlavorCone's ability to handle overlapping jets is crucial for understanding this process.
  • Discrepancies between generators highlight theoretical uncertainties: The simulations show significant differences between various parton-shower generators, underscoring the need for experimental measurements to guide theoretical improvements.

Key Results

  • The SoftDrop method, when applied to flavor-tagged subjets, shows distinct kinematic distributions for different heavy-flavor production scenarios (e.g., Q → Qg vs. g → QQ). These distributions are found to be qualitatively consistent with theoretical predictions.
  • The FlavorCone algorithm demonstrates a significant improvement (30-40%) in discriminating between heavy-flavor splitting and non-splitting events compared to traditional anti-kt jet algorithms, particularly in the challenging region where jets are close together.
  • The paper presents predicted cross-sections and distributions for various flavor-tagged categories, highlighting differences between PYTHIA and HERWIG++, and showing how these methods can be applied at experiments like LHCb.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Detector effects are not included: The presented results are based on simulations and do not account for the complexities of real detector responses, which will be a crucial factor in experimental implementation.
  • Experimental challenges: The authors acknowledge that precisely reconstructing the flight directions of heavy-flavor hadrons, especially when they are close together, is experimentally challenging but achievable with detectors like LHCb.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that these methods can be extended to study quarkonium production, investigate the impact of gluon polarization, and be applied at other LHC experiments like ATLAS and CMS. They also highlight the importance of developing more sophisticated heavy-flavor categorization schemes and stress-testing event generators with these new techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose two new analysis strategies for studying charm and beauty quarks at colliders. The first strategy is aimed at testing the kinematics of heavy-flavor quarks within an identified jet. Here, we use the SoftDrop jet-declustering algorithm to identify two subjets within a large-radius jet, using subjet flavor tagging to test the heavy-quark splitting functions of QCD. For subjets containing a $J/\ensuremath{\psi}$ or $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Upsilon}}$, this declustering technique can also help probe the mechanism for quarkonium production. The second strategy is aimed at isolating heavy-flavor production from gluon splitting. Here, we introduce a new FlavorCone algorithm, which smoothly interpolates from well-separated heavy-quark jets to the gluon-splitting regime where jets overlap. Because of its excellent ability to identify charm and beauty hadrons, the LHCb detector is ideally suited to pursue these strategies, though similar measurements should also be possible at ATLAS and CMS. Together, these SoftDrop and FlavorCone studies should clarify a number of aspects of heavy-flavor physics at colliders, and provide crucial information needed to improve heavy-flavor modeling in parton-shower generators.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ilten2017disentangling,
  author = {P. Ilten and Nicholas L. Rodd and Jesse Thaler and Mike Williams},
  title = {{Disentangling heavy flavor at colliders}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.96.054019},
}
Figure