TL;DR
This study surveyed over 1,400 international migrants in China about their knowledge and attitudes regarding COVID-19 during the early stages of the pandemic. It found that roughly half lacked adequate knowledge and had poor attitudes towards prevention, highlighting a critical need for tailored public health messaging for this vulnerable population. Trust in Chinese institutions emerged as a significant factor influencing positive attitudes.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic presented a unique challenge for international migrants, who often face barriers to accessing timely and accurate health information due to language differences, cultural disparities, and precarious legal status. While global migrant populations are substantial, research on their specific knowledge and attitudes during health crises like COVID-19 is limited. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating the disease knowledge and attitudes of international migrants in China, a country that was an early epicenter of the outbreak, to inform future public health preparedness and interventions for this demographic.
Methods
The researchers conducted a national, cross-sectional online survey between February 17 and March 1, 2020. They recruited 1,426 international migrants from 77 countries across 6 continents. Knowledge about COVID-19 was assessed using 7 items based on WHO guidelines, with scores ranging from 0-7. Attitudes were measured using 5 items assessing confidence, worry, and preparedness, with scores ranging from 0-5. Multivariable ordinal logistic regressions were employed to identify factors associated with knowledge and attitudes, considering information channels, preferences, and trust in Chinese institutions.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from a self-administered online survey. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation. The survey itself was developed based on formative research, including discussions with stakeholders and pilot testing with international migrants.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Information Gaps are Significant: Despite the global nature of the pandemic, international migrants in China showed a concerning deficit in COVID-19 knowledge, with only about half possessing a "good" level of understanding. This suggests that existing public health campaigns may not be effectively reaching or resonating with this population.
- Social Media as a Double-Edged Sword: While social media (like WeChat) was the primary channel for information, it was also associated with better knowledge. However, the potential for misinformation on these platforms is a significant concern that needs careful management.
- Trust Matters for Attitudes: A strong correlation was found between higher trust in Chinese institutions (government, hospitals, police, etc.) and more positive attitudes towards COVID-19 prevention and control. This highlights the importance of building and maintaining trust for effective public health messaging.
- Language Barriers are a Major Hurdle: Encountering language barriers when seeking medical services was negatively associated with having good COVID-19 knowledge, underscoring the need for multilingual health resources.
- Worry Extends Beyond Self: While many migrants felt confident in protecting themselves, a significant portion expressed worry about their loved ones contracting COVID-19, indicating a strong social and familial concern.
Key Results
- Knowledge: 51.2% (730/1426) of participants had a "good" level of knowledge about COVID-19. Knowledge was positively associated with receiving information through social media (aOR: 2.0), the internet (aOR: 1.4), and community channels (aOR: 1.5). Language barriers were negatively associated with knowledge (aOR: 0.8).
- Attitudes: 46.0% (656/1426) had a "positive" attitude towards COVID-19 prevention and control. Positive attitudes were strongly associated with higher levels of trust in various Chinese institutions and groups.
- Information Channels: WeChat was the most common channel for receiving information (94.5%), followed by friends (59.5%).
- Barriers: Language communication was the most frequent barrier to receiving medical services (55.1%).
- Trust: Over half of participants reported high trust in Chinese institutions and groups overall (52.4%). Doctors and medical professionals, the police, and the department handling immigration received particularly high trust.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Selection Bias: The online recruitment method may have introduced selection bias, potentially overrepresenting individuals with internet access and digital literacy.
- Limited Trust Data: Data on trust in Chinese institutions was only collected from 868 participants, which could affect the generalizability of findings related to trust.
- Language Bias: The survey being available only in English might have excluded non-English speakers, introducing another layer of selection bias.
- Self-Reported Data: All data was self-reported, which is susceptible to information bias.
- Geographic/Demographic Skew: The majority of participants were from African countries, limiting the generalizability of findings to migrants from other regions.
Future work should focus on developing and implementing tailored, multilingual public health campaigns for international migrants. Enhancing support systems, addressing stigma, and providing psychosocial services are also crucial for improving their health outcomes during epidemics and disasters. Further research could explore the impact of cultural differences on health information processing and trust.
Summary updated