Abstract
Both patients and their families were more reluctant than willing to disclose. Marital status, number of hospitalizations and family history of mental illness were all influencing factors of patients' intentions to disclose disease information. Stigma is closely related to disclosure intention and plays an important role in the disclosure intentions of patients and their families. This suggests that the disclosure of disease information is complex, and many factors need to be considered. Disclosure guidelines should be tailored to individuals.
Introduction
Disclosing a mental illness is often considered a critical step toward reducing stigma and accessing social support. However, in many cultures, it remains a "double-edged sword" that can lead to discrimination or a significant social "loss of face." While much of the existing literature on disclosure comes from Western contexts, this study investigates the dynamics within China. In Chinese society, traditional values place a high premium on family reputation, making the decision to "come out" about a psychiatric diagnosis particularly complex.
This research aims to identify the demographic, clinical, and psychological factors that influence the willingness of both patients and their primary caregivers to disclose mental health status within the Chinese healthcare system.
Methods and Data
The researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey at two major mental health centers in Sichuan Province: West China Hospital and the Third People’s Hospital of Mianyang. The study involved 153 hospitalized patients and 159 of their family members.
To quantify disclosure intentions and psychological states, the team utilized several validated psychometric scales, including the Coming Out with Mental Illness Scale (COMIS) to measure the perceived "Benefits of Being Out" (BBO) and "Reasons for Staying In" (RSI), and the Self-Stigma of Mental Illness Scale (SSMIS-SF) to assess internalized stigma. The data were analyzed using hierarchical linear regression to determine which variables best predicted disclosure intentions.
Key Results
The study revealed a striking reluctance to disclose mental illness. Only 34.6% of patients and a mere 18.2% of family members expressed an intention to disclose the illness. This is significantly lower than rates reported in Western nations or even other Asian countries like Japan (61%).
Predictors for Patients
For patients, the perception of disclosure was influenced by several clinical and social factors:
- Benefits of Being Out (BBO): Marital status and the number of hospitalizations were significant predictors, explaining 13.1% of the variance. When self-stigma was added to the model, it explained an additional 4.2% of the variance.
- Reasons for Staying In (RSI): Marital status and a positive family history of mental illness explained 14.4% of the variance in secrecy. Stigma was a massive driver here, accounting for an additional 14.8% of the variance.
Predictors for Family Members
Family members appeared even more secretive than patients. For this group, stigma was the primary and most consistent predictor of disclosure intention, explaining approximately 8% of the variance for both the perceived benefits of being out and the reasons for staying in.
Discussion: The Role of "Face" and Stigma
The findings underscore the profound impact of Chinese cultural values on mental health. The concept of "family scandal" leads to a heavy burden of "affiliate stigma"—the shame transferred from the patient to the family unit. This explains why family members were even less willing to disclose than the patients themselves; they often feel they have more to lose in terms of social standing and "face."
Furthermore, the data suggests that patients who are married or have a known family history of mental illness are more reluctant to disclose. This likely stems from a desire to protect the family's reputation and the social prospects of other family members.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The complexity of disclosure in the Chinese context suggests that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to encouraging openness is insufficient. Disclosure is not merely a personal choice but a family-level negotiation influenced by clinical history and deep-seated cultural stigmas.
Future interventions should focus on developing tailored disclosure guidelines that account for an individual's specific clinical background and social environment. Additionally, anti-stigma campaigns in China may need to address "affiliate stigma" specifically to help families feel more comfortable seeking support without the fear of social ruin.
Summary updated