Abstract
There is a certain kind of solid-state balance among individual buildings within the same vernacular architecture. Not all understandings of this balance have formed the common specifications found in current planning textbooks; instead, some manifest as silent and hidden constructing principles of clustering methods and building processes. By considering elements of terrain, climate, and environment as core constructing principles, vernacular architecture—along with its comprehensive thoughts and building techniques—should be treated as a series of archetypes that may be transformed and analogized to the building systems of contemporary vernacular architecture. In this way, vernacular architecture can achieve a real extension. This article reviews the construct tactics of vernacular architecture from the perspective of building typology, elevating it to an instructive theoretical level.
Introduction
As global urbanization accelerates, traditional villages and their unique architectural identities are increasingly threatened. Often, these structures are either "swallowed" by modern development or preserved as "sclerotic signs"—static museum pieces that no longer serve a functional role in contemporary life. The challenge for modern architects is to find a middle ground between purely historical preservation and shallow "revivalism," which often results in literal, hollow copies of traditional forms.
This paper argues that vernacular architecture should be viewed as a living, evolving system rather than a relic. By applying the lens of Architectural Typology, we can extract the underlying "DNA" or abstract prototypes of traditional buildings, allowing for the creation of modern structures that maintain cultural continuity while meeting contemporary demands.
The Typological Framework: Type vs. Model
To move beyond superficial imitation, it is essential to distinguish between a "Type" and a "Model," a distinction famously articulated by Q.D. Quincy. A Model is a finished image intended to be copied exactly, whereas a Type is the "law of the formation model"—an abstract logic or internal rule of construction.
In the context of vernacular architecture, the "Type" represents the constant principles that govern how a building relates to its environment and culture. Because a type is abstract, it allows for "real extension." An architect can utilize modern materials, updated scales, and new technologies, but if they adhere to the underlying typological logic, the resulting structure remains authentically vernacular.
The Archetypal and Temporal Dimensions
The paper incorporates Carl Jung’s concept of the "collective unconscious" to explain how vernacular forms serve as "sediments" of historical and national memories. These forms are not arbitrary; they are the physical manifestation of a community's long-term adaptation to its surroundings.
To analyze these forms, the paper proposes a dual approach:
- Synchronic Analysis: Examining the building as it exists in its current environment, focusing on its immediate relationship with terrain and climate.
- Diachronic Analysis: Viewing the building as a link in a historical chain, understanding how it has evolved over time.
By unifying these perspectives, architects can achieve a design logic that is both grounded in history and responsive to the present.
Hierarchical Classification of Vernacular Forms
The authors propose a hierarchical system to categorize vernacular elements, facilitating their translation into modern design:
- Original Types (Macro-scale): These represent the unity of building and place. For example, the Chinese courtyard is an original type that defines a specific relationship between interior and exterior space, inseparable from its cultural and geographic context.
- Subtypes (Micro-scale): These are the specific components—roofs, windows, materials, and decorative details—that support the original type.
This hierarchy allows architects to identify which elements are "constants" (the core logic) and which are "variables" (the specific materials or techniques that can be updated).
The "Solid-State Balance" and Construct Tactics
Vernacular architecture is characterized by a "solid-state balance," a hidden equilibrium between individual buildings and their environment. This balance is rarely codified in textbooks; it exists as "silent and hidden constructing principles." These principles dictate how clusters of buildings respond to the slope of a hill, the direction of the wind, or the flow of water.
True vernacular construction is an "organism that survives and develops in revolution." By using typology, architects can:
- Extract logical prototypes from historical data.
- Translate these prototypes into the modern era using contemporary techniques.
- Ensure that new rural construction is anchored in the deep inner structure of a culture's lifestyle rather than being created in a vacuum.
Conclusion
Applying architectural typology to vernacular construction offers a path toward a "New Rationalism." It moves the discourse away from the "plunder of history"—where old styles are used merely for aesthetic flair—and toward a method of finding the constant relationship between tradition and modernity. While the paper remains theoretical, it provides the philosophical foundation necessary for architects to create buildings that are both innovative and deeply rooted in their cultural soil. Future research must bridge the gap between this high-level abstraction and practical, step-by-step guidelines for geometric and spatial prototype extraction.
Summary updated