Discrimination of Isomeric Glycans via High-sensitive Engineered Nanopore

Guangda Yao, Yinping Tian, Wenjun Ke, Jie Fang, Shengzhou Ma, Tiehai Li, Xi Cheng, Bingqing Xia, Liuqing Wen, Zhaobing GaobioRxiv 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Glycan isomers are the basis for forming the spatial structure of glycans, which poses great challenges to glycan structural analysis and hinders the study of the relationship between structure and function. An economical and convenient analytical method with high resolution is still in demand. Here, we designed an engineered α-hemolysin nanopore with double-mutants (α-HL M113R/T115A) to achieve sensing of glycans with different glycosidic linkages. By extracting three parameters to depict a 3D scatter plot, four glycans with different degrees of polymerization and glycosidic bonds could be distinguished. Through molecular dynamics (MD), we further elucidated the motion trajectories of two different glycosidic bonds in the pore region. In addition, the sensing ability was also applied in the direct identification of glycans in mixture systems. The obtained nanopore data permitted us to achieve a separation accuracy of over 90% independent of the assistance of machine learning algorithms. Designing biological nanopores with high discrimination and sensitivity for glycans with different lineages paves the way for nanopore glycan profiling and potentially sequencing.

Introduction

Glycans, or complex sugars, are often referred to as the "dark matter" of biological molecules. Unlike the linear sequences of DNA or proteins, glycans are characterized by complex branching patterns and specific glycosidic linkages. These structural variations, known as isomers, are crucial for biological functions such as immune responses and disease progression. However, analyzing these isomers is exceptionally difficult. Traditional methods like Mass Spectrometry (MS) struggle because isomers share the same mass, while Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) requires large, pure samples and significant time. There is a critical need for a fast, sensitive, single-molecule method to directly read glycan structures.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers developed an engineered biological nanopore based on α-hemolysin (α-HL) to address this challenge.

The Engineered Nanopore

The team designed a double-mutant pore, α-HL M113R/T115A. The M113R mutation serves as a high-sensitivity sensor for the acetamido groups on the sugars. The T115A mutation was introduced to remove a secondary "noisy" sensing site, resulting in significantly cleaner ionic current signals.

3D Fingerprinting Principle

As glycans pass through the pore under an electric field, they partially block the ion flow, creating characteristic current "dips." To distinguish between isomers, the researchers extracted three key parameters from these signals to create a 3D "fingerprint":

  1. Amplitude (ΔI₂): The magnitude of the current drop.
  2. Dwell Time (τ): The duration the glycan remains in the sensing region.
  3. Standard Deviation (Std): The noise level or "wiggliness" of the blockage signal.
Overview of the engineered nanopore sensing platform, including glycan structures, experimental setup, and 3D mapping of disaccharide and tetrasaccharide isomers.

Key Results

The study validated the pore's sensitivity using synthetic glycan standards, including disaccharides (Gal-GlcNAc with β1,3 vs. β1,4 linkages) and tetrasaccharides with varying linkage patterns.

Linkage-Specific Discrimination

The engineered pore demonstrated the ability to "feel" the difference between β1,3 and β1,4 bonds. Generally, β1,3 linkages resulted in longer dwell times but smaller current blockages compared to β1,4 linkages. Interestingly, the pore was even more effective at distinguishing longer tetrasaccharides than shorter disaccharides. This suggests that the increased structural complexity of longer chains leads to more distinct conformational "poses" within the pore, which amplifies the signal differences.

High Accuracy in Mixtures

In "blind" mixture tests containing all four glycans, the system achieved a separation accuracy of over 90%. By projecting mixture data onto the 3D fingerprints of known standards, the researchers could rapidly identify all components in a single run without needing chemical labels or machine learning algorithms.

Detailed current traces and 3D scatter plots for tetrasaccharide isomers (Tetra-1 and Tetra-2), demonstrating high discrimination.

Discussion and Future Outlook

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations provided physical insight into these results, revealing that isomers take different physical trajectories through the pore lumen. These unique paths lead to distinct interactions with the mutated amino acids, explaining the observed signal variations.

While this work is a significant advancement, limitations remain. The current study focused on β-linkages; future research must expand to α-linkages and other bonding positions. Additionally, optimizing pores for different glycan types may require a "library" of engineered mutants. Ultimately, this research paves the way for the single-molecule sequencing of unknown complex glycans, similar to current nanopore DNA sequencing technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Glycan isomers are the basis for forming the spatial structure of glycans, which poses great challenges to glycan structural analysis and hinders the study of the relationship between structure and function. An economical and convenient analytical method with high resolution is still in demand. Here, we designed an engineered α-hemolysin nanopore with double-mutants (α-HL M113R/T115A) to achieve sensing of glycans with different glycosidic linkages. By extracting three parameters to depict a 3D scatter plot, four glycans with different degrees of polymerization and glycosidic bonds could be distinguished. Through molecular dynamics (MD), we further elucidated the motion trajectories of two different glycosidic bonds in the pore region. In addition, the sensing ability was also applied in the direct identification of glycans in mixture systems. The obtained nanopore data permitted us to achieve a separation accuracy of over 90% independent of the assistance of machine learning algorithms. Designing biological nanopores with high discrimination and sensitivity for glycans with different lineages paves the way for nanopore glycan profiling and potentially sequencing.
BibTeX
@misc{yao2023discrimination,
  author = {Guangda Yao and Yinping Tian and Wenjun Ke and Jie Fang and Shengzhou Ma and Tiehai Li and Xi Cheng and Bingqing Xia and Liuqing Wen and Zhaobing Gao},
  title = {{Discrimination of Isomeric Glycans via High-sensitive Engineered Nanopore}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.12.28.573513},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure