Discretized Approximations for POMDP with Average Cost

Huizhen Yu, Dimitri P. BertsekasUAI 2004

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel discretization method for solving Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) with an average cost criterion. It provides a computationally efficient way to obtain lower bounds on the optimal average cost and can be used to derive upper bounds and approximate optimal policies, even when the existence of an optimal solution is not guaranteed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) are powerful models for sequential decision-making under uncertainty, where the agent doesn't know the exact state of the system but receives observations that provide clues. While POMDPs with a discounted cost criterion have seen significant algorithmic development, the average cost version is considerably more challenging. The primary difficulties lie in the potential non-existence of optimal solutions and the lack of efficient algorithms to find them. This paper tackles this challenge by proposing a discretization approach that approximates the complex continuous belief space of POMDPs with a finite set of "belief points." This allows leveraging well-established algorithms for finite-state Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) to find approximate solutions for average cost POMDPs.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its novel discretization schemes for POMDPs, particularly for the average cost criterion.

  • Discretization of Belief Space: The authors discretize the continuous belief space (the space of probability distributions over states) into a finite set of "belief points." This is achieved by defining an $\epsilon$-discretization scheme, which involves a set of belief points $G$ and a convex representation scheme $\gamma$ that allows any belief to be represented as a convex combination of these points.
  • Lower Approximation Schemes: For the discounted case, they propose a new lower approximation scheme based on a fictitious "optimistic" controller that has access to extra information about hidden states. This scheme is then extended to the average cost case.
  • Value Iteration for Finite-State MDPs: The discretized POMDPs are transformed into finite-state MDPs. The authors leverage existing efficient algorithms, such as value iteration and multi-chain algorithms, to compute the approximate optimal cost functions and policies for these finite-state problems.
  • Error Bounds and Convergence Analysis: The paper provides theoretical analysis on the error bounds of their approximations. They show that their approximations are lower bounds to the optimal average cost and can be used to derive upper bounds on the limsup optimal average cost. They also establish asymptotic convergence results, showing that as the discretization becomes finer, the approximate cost converges to the true optimal cost under certain conditions (e.g., constant optimal average cost and continuous differential cost).
  • Algorithm for Modified MDP: They develop an algorithm to compute an $n$-discount optimal policy for the modified belief MDP. This algorithm involves solving the average cost problem on the finite set of supporting beliefs and then determining optimal controls on transient states.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and uses toy problems for experimental validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap for Average Cost POMDPs: The most significant insight is the successful adaptation of discretization techniques, which have been effective for discounted POMDPs, to the more challenging average cost setting. This opens up new avenues for solving problems where optimal solutions were previously elusive.
  • Leveraging Finite-State MDP Solvers: The paper cleverly transforms complex POMDP problems into manageable finite-state MDPs, allowing the use of powerful, existing algorithms. This is a key enabler for computational tractability.
  • Guaranteed Lower Bounds: The proposed schemes provide guaranteed lower bounds on the optimal average cost. This is crucial for understanding the quality of approximations and for establishing convergence.
  • Practical Implications for Policy Generation: The approximations not only provide cost bounds but also enable the generation of suboptimal policies. This is valuable in real-world scenarios where finding the absolute optimal policy might be computationally infeasible.
  • The Importance of Belief Point Placement: Experimental results suggest that the placement of belief points, not just their number, significantly impacts the quality of the approximation. This highlights the need for intelligent discretization strategies.

Key Results

  • New Lower Approximation Scheme: The paper introduces a novel lower approximation scheme for both discounted and average cost POMDPs.
  • Asymptotic Convergence: They prove asymptotic convergence of the cost approximation for average cost POMDPs under specific conditions, demonstrating that as the discretization becomes finer, the approximate cost approaches the true optimal cost.
  • Experimental Validation: Experiments on toy problems (Paint, Bridge-repair, Shuttle) show that their discretization schemes can achieve near-optimal average costs even with relatively coarse grids. For instance, in the "Paint" problem, TD₂ with a 3-E grid pattern yielded results close to optimal.
  • Bounding Optimal Costs: The proposed methods can be used to bound the optimal liminf and limsup average cost functions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Existence of Optimal Solutions: The paper notes that the existence of optimal solutions for average cost POMDPs is not always guaranteed, which is a fundamental challenge in the field. While their method provides approximations, it doesn't solve the existence problem directly.
  • Conditions for Convergence: The asymptotic convergence results are shown under specific conditions, such as the continuity of the optimal differential cost. Relaxing these conditions for broader applicability is a potential area for future work.
  • Quality of Upper Bounds: The paper acknowledges that the upper bounds derived from their approximations can sometimes be loose, limiting their informativeness.
  • Computational Cost of Policy Generation: While the algorithms are efficient for computing approximations, generating $n$-discount optimal policies for the modified MDP can still be computationally intensive, especially for large $n$.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more general frameworks for deriving upper and lower approximation schemes for POMDPs and investigating more sophisticated discretization strategies that consider the placement of belief points. They also hint at the need for policies with additional optimality guarantees for finite-stage behavior.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2004discretized,
  author = {Huizhen Yu and Dimitri P. Bertsekas},
  title = {{Discretized Approximations for POMDP with Average Cost}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2004},
}
Figure