Discrete Torsion, Covering Groups and Quiver Diagrams

Bo Feng, Amihay Hanany, Yang‐Hui He, Nikolaos PrezasJournal of High Energy Physics 2001 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a streamlined algorithm for calculating the gauge theory data of D-branes on orbifolds with "discrete torsion." By leveraging the mathematical concept of covering groups, the authors show how to bypass the complex machinery of 2-cocycles and twisted group algebras, instead using only ordinary character tables to derive quiver diagrams.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In string theory, when D-branes (extended physical objects) probe an "orbifold" (a space formed by dividing a smooth manifold by a finite group $G$), they give rise to specific gauge theories. "Discrete torsion" is a subtle degree of freedom in these models—essentially a choice of phases—that significantly alters the resulting physics, such as the matter spectrum and the gauge group.

Traditionally, calculating the effects of discrete torsion required "projective representations" of the group $G$. This involved calculating 2-cocycles—mathematical objects that are notoriously difficult to compute and manipulate. The authors identify a major bottleneck: the physics community lacked a simple, systematic way to generate these "quiver diagrams" (graphical representations of the gauge theory) without getting bogged down in sophisticated cohomology.

Methods

The authors propose a "canonical" method rooted in group theory. Instead of working directly with the projective representations of the orbifold group $G$, they move to its Covering Group ($G^*$).

  1. The Lifting Property: A fundamental theorem in group theory states that every projective representation of $G$ can be "lifted" to an ordinary (linear) representation of its covering group $G^*$.
  2. The Algorithm:
    • Identify the Schur Multiplier $M(G)$, which classifies the possible types of discrete torsion.
  3. Construct the covering group $G^*$.
  4. Compute the ordinary character table of $G^*$.
  5. Decompose the tensor products of these representations to find the matter content.
  6. Computational Tools: The authors used the GAP (Groups, Algorithms, Programming) software package, specifically the Holt algorithm, to find the covering groups of complex finite subgroups of $SU(3)$.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, it does not use traditional "datasets." Instead, it applies its algorithm to a comprehensive list of finite group "test cases" relevant to string theory:

  • Dihedral Groups ($D_{2n}$): Used as a primary illustrative example.
  • Intransitive Subgroups of $SU(3)$: Including various combinations of cyclic and dihedral groups.
  • Transitive/Exceptional Subgroups of $SU(3)$: The $\Delta(3n^2)$ and $\Delta(6n^2)$ series, and the three exceptional groups $\Sigma(60)$ (the icosahedral group $A_5$), $\Sigma(168)$, and $\Sigma(1080)$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Splitting" Quiver: The most striking insight is that the quiver diagram of the covering group $G^*$ is not just one big graph. It naturally splits into $|M(G)|$ disconnected components.
  • Unified Framework: One of these disconnected components is always the "ordinary" quiver (no discrete torsion). The other components represent the quivers for every possible non-trivial value of discrete torsion. This allows researchers to see all possible physics for a given orbifold in a single calculation.
  • Ordinary is Enough: The paper proves that you don't need to know the specific values of the 2-cocycles to find the matter spectrum. Knowing the ordinary character tables of $G$ and $G^*$ is sufficient.

Key Results

  • Theorem 4.5: Formally proves that the quiver $Q(G^*, \mathcal{R})$ consists of disconnected sub-quivers, each corresponding to a different choice of discrete torsion.
  • Visual Catalog: The paper provides a "gallery" of new quiver diagrams for complex orbifolds (Figures 1-8). For example, the $\Delta(3 \times 3^2)$ group (order 27) has a covering group of order 243, which yields nine distinct sub-quivers (the "Space Invaders Quiver").
  • Simplification: The method reduces a problem of "twisted" mathematics to a standard problem of linear representation theory, making it accessible to a much wider range of physicists.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Brane Setups: While the gauge theory data (the "what") is solved, the physical "how"—the specific configurations of D-branes and NS5-branes that produce these theories—remains to be fully established for many of these groups.
  • Analytic Results: While the algorithm works for any specific group, the authors suggest that finding general analytic formulas for the quivers of entire series (like the $\Delta$ series) is a promising next step.
  • Non-commutative Moduli Spaces: The authors note that this work lays the groundwork for studying the non-commutative geometry of these orbifolds, which is a major area of interest in modern string theory.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{feng2001discrete,
  author = {Bo Feng and Amihay Hanany and Yang‐Hui He and Nikolaos Prezas},
  title = {{Discrete Torsion, Covering Groups and Quiver Diagrams}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1088/1126-6708/2001/04/037},
}
Figure