Discrete Element Parameter Calibration of Livestock Salt Based on Particle Scaling

Lulu Nie, Baoqin Wen, Jingbin Li, Shufeng Li, Yali Li, Zhaokun Zhang, Zhiyuan Wang, Zhihao FanarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Discrete Element Method (DEM) simulations are essential for designing livestock salt delivery systems, yet they are often limited by high computational costs and parameter uncertainty. This study presents a calibration framework using particle scaling (scaling factor $h=2$) and Response Surface Methodology (RSM). By identifying key contact parameters—specifically salt-salt rolling friction, salt-salt restitution, and salt-steel rolling friction—the researchers achieved a simulation accuracy with a relative error of only 0.6% compared to physical experiments. This approach enables efficient, high-fidelity modeling of bulk salt flow for precision agriculture applications.

Introduction

In modern precision agriculture, automated systems such as screw conveyors and silos are increasingly used to deliver precise mineral supplements, like livestock salt (sodium chloride). Optimizing these systems requires accurate computer simulations using the Discrete Element Method (DEM). However, two primary challenges hinder practical application: the extreme computational expense of simulating millions of tiny salt particles and the difficulty of directly measuring microscopic contact parameters. This paper addresses these hurdles by employing particle scaling laws to create larger "proxy" particles that maintain physical consistency with real-world behavior.

Methodology

The calibration process followed a multi-stage experimental and numerical design.

Dimensional Analysis and Scaling

Based on governing equations of particle motion, scaling laws were applied to double the particle size ($h=2$). This ensured that while particle density remained invariant, contact stiffness and restitution were adjusted to preserve physical realism.

Physical Benchmarking

The "Angle of Repose" (AOR), the steepest angle at which a salt pile remains stable, served as the primary calibration target. Physical measurements were conducted using a BT-1000 tester.

Experimental setup using the BT-1000 tester and resulting angle of repose measurements over multiple trials.

Parameter Screening and Optimization

A Plackett-Burman design was used to screen seven factors, identifying salt-salt rolling friction, salt-salt restitution, and salt-steel rolling friction as the most significant influences on the AOR. Subsequently, Steepest Ascent and Box-Behnken designs were utilized within a Response Surface Methodology (RSM) framework to optimize these parameters. Simulations were executed in EDEM software using the Hertz-Mindlin no-slip contact model.

Particle size distribution via sieving and the relationship between particle size and scaling ratios.

Results and Discussion

The study successfully identified optimal contact parameters for the scaled livestock salt model:

  • Salt-salt rolling friction coefficient: 0.23
  • Salt-salt restitution coefficient: 0.544
  • Salt-steel rolling friction coefficient: 0.368

Using these parameters, the EDEM simulation yielded an angle of repose of 45.55°, which closely matches the experimental value of 45.27°. The resulting 0.6% relative error validates the reliability of the scaled model.

A key insight from the sensitivity analysis is the dominance of rolling friction over static friction in determining bulk flow characteristics. Furthermore, the "inverse calibration" approach proved effective for determining microscopic parameters that are otherwise nearly impossible to measure directly on individual salt grains.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that doubling particle size through scaling laws significantly reduces computational overhead without sacrificing simulation accuracy. While the current model uses spherical simplifications, it provides a robust foundation for engineering livestock salt handling equipment. Future work should investigate the limits of scaling factors and the impact of non-spherical particle geometries and environmental moisture on salt cohesion.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{nie2025discrete,
  author = {Lulu Nie and Baoqin Wen and Jingbin Li and Shufeng Li and Yali Li and Zhaokun Zhang and Zhiyuan Wang and Zhihao Fan},
  title = {{Discrete Element Parameter Calibration of Livestock Salt Based on Particle Scaling}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2506.03786},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.03786},
}
Figure