Discrete Dirac structures and discrete Lagrange--Dirac dynamical systems in mechanics

Linyu Peng, Hiroaki YoshimuraJournal of Mathematical Physics 2024 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for discretizing Dirac structures and Lagrange-Dirac dynamical systems in mechanics. By developing (±)-discrete Dirac structures and their induced counterparts on the cotangent bundle, the authors provide a unified approach to discretizing nonholonomic systems that preserves geometric structures, leading to stable numerical integrators.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of numerically simulating mechanical systems with nonholonomic constraints. Continuous Dirac structures offer a powerful way to incorporate these constraints into the formulation of dynamical systems, but discretizing these structures while preserving their geometric properties has been a significant hurdle. Existing discrete methods often lose these crucial geometric features, leading to numerical instabilities over long time simulations. This work aims to bridge this gap by proposing a consistent discrete framework for Dirac structures and Lagrange-Dirac systems, ensuring better numerical behavior for nonholonomic systems.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in the development of (±)-discrete Dirac structures. This involves:

  • Discretizing two-forms and constraint distributions: Using (±)-finite difference maps (forward and backward differences), the authors define discrete analogues of two-forms and constraint spaces on manifolds.
  • Induced Dirac structures on cotangent bundles: They extend this concept to the cotangent bundle, defining (±)-discrete induced Dirac structures which are discrete counterparts to the continuous induced Dirac structures.
  • Discrete Lagrange-Dirac dynamical systems: The framework is then used to formulate discrete Lagrange-Dirac systems, which are shown to be equivalent to existing discrete Lagrange-d'Alembert equations.
  • Lagrange-d'Alembert-Pontryagin principle: The variational structure of these discrete systems is clarified through a discrete version of this principle.

The use of (±) finite difference maps allows for a more general and flexible discretization, capturing both forward and backward propagation of information.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical validation using illustrative examples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified discrete framework for nonholonomic systems: The paper provides a systematic way to discretize nonholonomic systems that respects the underlying geometric structures, offering a more robust approach than previous methods.
  • Preservation of geometric structures in discretization: The proposed (±)-discrete Dirac structures and induced Dirac structures are designed to preserve key geometric properties, which is crucial for long-term numerical stability.
  • Equivalence to existing discrete methods: The authors demonstrate that their new framework recovers established discrete Lagrange-d'Alembert equations, validating their approach and showing its compatibility with prior work.
  • The power of (±)-finite differences: The use of both forward and backward finite differences offers a more comprehensive discrete representation, allowing for a richer geometric structure.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully defines (±)-discrete Dirac structures and (±)-discrete induced Dirac structures on manifolds and cotangent bundles, respectively.
  • It establishes the formulation of (±)-discrete Lagrange-Dirac dynamical systems within this framework.
  • It proves that the resulting discrete equations of motion are equivalent to the discrete Lagrange-d'Alembert equations from Cortés and Martínez [2001] and McLachlan and Perlmutter [2006].
  • The variational structure is clarified via the (±)-discrete Lagrange-d'Alembert-Pontryagin principle.
  • Numerical simulations of a vertical rolling disk and the classical Heisenberg system demonstrate the effectiveness and stability of the proposed discrete systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Extension to infinite dimensions: The current work is limited to finite-dimensional systems. The authors suggest exploring extensions to infinite-dimensional Dirac dynamical systems.
  • Discrete Hamilton-Dirac systems: Further research is needed to understand how discrete Hamilton systems can be formulated within this (±)-discrete Dirac structure framework, particularly concerning symplectic Euler methods.
  • Lie-Dirac reduction: The paper suggests discretizing Lie-Dirac reduction and associated reduced discrete Lagrange-Dirac systems.
  • Nonequilibrium thermodynamics: Applying the variational discretization to nonequilibrium thermodynamic systems is proposed as a future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we propose the concept of $(\pm)$-discrete Dirac structures over a manifold, where we define $(\pm)$-discrete two-forms on the manifold and incorporate discrete constraints using $(\pm)$-finite difference maps. Specifically, we develop $(\pm)$-discrete induced Dirac structures as discrete analogues of the induced Dirac structure on the cotangent bundle over a configuration manifold, as described by Yoshimura and Marsden (2006). We demonstrate that $(\pm)$-discrete Lagrange--Dirac systems can be naturally formulated in conjunction with the $(\pm)$-induced Dirac structure on the cotangent bundle. Furthermore, we show that the resulting equations of motion are equivalent to the $(\pm)$-discrete Lagrange--d'Alembert equations proposed in Cortés and Martínez (2001) and McLachlan and Perlmutter (2006). We also clarify the variational structures of the discrete Lagrange--Dirac dynamical systems within the framework of the $(\pm)$-discrete Lagrange--d'Alembert--Pontryagin principle. Finally, we validate the proposed discrete Lagrange--Dirac systems with some illustrative examples of nonholonomic systems through numerical tests.
BibTeX
@article{peng2024discrete,
  author = {Linyu Peng and Hiroaki Yoshimura},
  title = {{Discrete Dirac structures and discrete Lagrange--Dirac dynamical systems in mechanics}},
  journal = {Journal of Mathematical Physics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure