Discovery of Very High Energy Gamma-Ray Emissions from the Low-luminosity AGN NGC 4278 by LHAASO

Zhen Cao, F. Aharonian, Axikegu, Y. Bai, Y. W. Bao, D. Bastieri, Xiao-Jun Bi, Y. J. Bi, Weixin Bian, A.v Bukevich, Qing Cao, Weiwei Cao, Jiang Chang, A. M. Chen, E. S. Chen, H. X. Chen, Liang Chen, Lin Chen, Long Chen, M. J. Chen, Q. H. Chen, Shaomin Chen, T. L. Chen, Y. Chen, Ningyan Cheng, Y. D. Cheng, Maxwell Cui, S. W. Cui, X. H. Cui, Y. D. Cui, B. Z. Dai, H. L. Dai, Z. G. Dai, Danzengluobu Danzengluobu, X. Q. Dong, K. K. Duan, J. H. Fan, Y. Z. Fan, J. Fang, Kun Fang, Chunsheng Feng, Hansheng Feng, Lei Feng, S. H. Feng, X. T. Feng, Y. Feng, S. Gabici, Bo Gao, C. D. Gao, Qi Gao, W. Gao, M. M. Ge, Li‐Sheng Geng, Gwenael Giacinti, G. H. Gong, Q. B. Gou, M. H. Gu, Fulai Guo, Xiaoguang Guo, Yi-Qing Guo, Y. A. Han, M. Zahid Hasan, H. H. He, Jiawei He, Yan He, Y. K. Hor, Bowen Hou, C. Hou, Xin Hou, Haibing Hu, Q. Hu, S. C. Hu, Dezhi Huang, T. Q. Huang, W. J. Huang, X. T. Huang, Yeyuan Huang, Xiangdong Ji, H. Y. Jia, Kun Jia, K. Jiang, X. W. Jiang, Z. J. Jiang, Ming Jin, M. M. Kang, I. Karpikov, D. Kuleshov, K. Kurinov, B. B. LiThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

The LHAASO observatory has discovered very-high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray emissions from NGC 4278, a low-luminosity active galactic nucleus (AGN). This finding is significant because it demonstrates that even weak radio jets can accelerate particles to VHE energies, expanding our understanding of particle acceleration in the universe.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs) are powerful cosmic engines that emit radiation across the electromagnetic spectrum. Understanding the processes that generate very-high-energy (VHE) gamma rays from AGNs is crucial for unraveling the physics of particle acceleration in extreme astrophysical environments and for understanding the origin of the VHE gamma-ray background. Historically, VHE gamma-ray sources have predominantly been blazars, a subclass of AGNs with relativistic jets pointed directly at Earth. However, there's a vast population of less active AGNs, known as low-luminosity AGNs (LLAGNs), which are less understood in terms of their VHE emission capabilities. The challenge has been to detect VHE emissions from these LLAGNs, which are more common but fainter, and to understand the mechanisms at play in their less powerful jets. This paper addresses this gap by presenting the discovery of VHE gamma-ray emission from NGC 4278, a typical LLAGN, using data from the LHAASO observatory.

Methods

The LHAASO observatory, equipped with a Water Cherenkov Detector Array (WCDA) and KiloMeter-square Array (KM2A), was used to detect VHE gamma rays. The analysis involved:

  • Data Selection and Quality Cuts: Events were filtered based on the number of fired detectors, zenith angle, shower core location error (RMDS), and gamma/proton separation parameter (Pincness) to ensure high-quality data.
  • Background Estimation: A "direct integration method" was employed to estimate background events, excluding regions of the Galactic plane and known gamma-ray sources.
  • Excess Map Generation: The difference between the event map and the background map was used to create an excess map, highlighting potential source regions.
  • Spectral and Temporal Analysis: A multi-dimensional maximum likelihood analysis was used to fit the excess maps, estimating the source's position, photon flux, and spectral index. The analysis considered a power-law spectrum with EBL attenuation.
  • Variability Analysis: Light curves were generated and analyzed using Bayesian blocks and a likelihood variability test to identify temporal variations in the VHE emission.
  • SED Construction: Spectral Energy Distributions (SEDs) were constructed for different source states (active and quasi-quiet) to compare their intrinsic emission properties.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of VHE gamma-ray data collected by the LHAASO observatory's WCDA between March 5, 2021, and October 31, 2023, with an effective live-time of approximately 891 days. KM2A data from the same period were also utilized, primarily for upper limit estimations due to lower statistics. The analysis also references existing VHE AGN catalogs and data from other observatories for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LLAGNs can be VHE Gamma-Ray Emitters: The discovery of VHE emission from NGC 4278, a low-luminosity AGN, challenges the previous notion that only powerful blazars and FRI radio galaxies are significant VHE gamma-ray emitters. This suggests that particle acceleration mechanisms in weaker jets are more efficient than previously thought.
  • Compact, Weak Jets are Capable of VHE Emission: NGC 4278 has a compact, weak radio jet. This finding implies that the physical conditions within these less powerful jets are sufficient to accelerate particles to extremely high energies, leading to VHE gamma-ray production.
  • Monthly Variability in VHE Emission: The analysis revealed a statistically significant indication of variability in the VHE emission from NGC 4278 on a timescale of a few months. This variability is consistent with low-frequency observations and suggests dynamic processes within the source.
  • LHAASO's Survey Mode is Crucial: The LHAASO observatory's wide field of view and homogeneous sky coverage are highlighted as essential for discovering VHE sources, particularly from less luminous and potentially less variable AGNs that might be missed by traditional pointing observations.

Key Results

  • Detection of VHE Gamma-Ray Source: A VHE gamma-ray source, 1LHAASO J1219+2915, was detected with a significance level of 8.8σ during the active period.
  • Association with NGC 4278: The best-fit position of the VHE source is R.A. = 185.05° ±0.04°, Dec. = 29.25° ±0.03°, which is spatially coincident with the LLAGN NGC 4278 within ~0.03 degrees.
  • Spectral Properties: The best-fit photon spectral index during the active period is Γ = 2.56 ± 0.14.
  • Flux Measurement: The VHE flux in the 1-10 TeV range during the active period is (7.0 ± 1.1 sta ± 0.35 syst) × 10⁻¹³ photons cm⁻² s⁻¹, which is approximately 5% of the Crab Nebula flux.
  • Variability Indication: A statistically significant indication of variability on a few-month timescale was found, with the flux in the active state being about 7 times higher than in the quasi-quiet state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Statistics for KM2A: The pre-trial significance for KM2A observations was less than 4σ, limiting its use for spectral energy distribution analysis, and only upper limits could be estimated.
  • EBL Absorption: While the EBL absorption is noted as not very important for NGC 4278 due to its relatively small distance, it is a factor that needs to be considered for more distant sources.
  • Future LHAASO Observations: The authors suggest that further LHAASO observations will be crucial for discovering more VHE LLAGNs, which will aid in constructing a more comprehensive VHE AGN catalog and improving our understanding of AGN physics. Specifically, continued monitoring will help to better characterize the variability and potentially pinpoint the emission region.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The first source catalog of the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory (LHAASO) reported the detection of a very high energy gamma-ray source, 1LHAASO J1219+2915. This Letter presents a further detailed study of the spectral and temporal behavior of this pointlike source. The best-fit position of the TeV source (R.A. = 185.°05 ± 0.°04, decl. = 29.°25 ± 0.°03) is compatible with NGC 4278 within ∼0.°03. Variation analysis shows an indication of variability on a timescale of a few months in the TeV band, which is consistent with low-frequency observations. Based on these observations, we report the detection of TeV γ -ray emissions from this low-luminosity active galactic nucleus. The observation by LHAASO's Water Cherenkov Detector Array during the active period has a significance level of 8.8 σ with a best-fit photon spectral index Γ = 2.56 ± 0.14 and a flux f 1–10 TeV = (7.0 ± 1.1 sta ± 0.35 syst ) × 10 −13 photons cm −2 s −1 , or approximately 5% of the Crab Nebula. The discovery of VHE gamma-ray emission from NGC 4278 indicates that compact, weak radio jets can efficiently accelerate particles and emit TeV photons.
BibTeX
@article{cao2024discovery,
  author = {Zhen Cao and F. Aharonian and Axikegu and Y. Bai and Y. W. Bao and D. Bastieri and Xiao-Jun Bi and Y. J. Bi and Weixin Bian and A.V Bukevich and Qing Cao and Weiwei Cao and Zhe Cao and Jiang Chang and J. F. Chang and A. M. Chen and E. S. Chen and H. X. Chen and Liang Chen and Lin Chen and Long Chen and M. J. Chen and M. L. Chen and Q. H. Chen and Shaomin Chen and S. H. Chen and S. Z. Chen and T. L. Chen and Y. Chen and Ningyan Cheng and Y. D. Cheng and Maxwell Cui and S. W. Cui and X. H. Cui and Y. D. Cui and B. Z. Dai and H. L. Dai and Z. G. Dai and Danzengluobu Danzengluobu and X. Q. Dong and K. K. Duan and J. H. Fan and Y. Z. Fan and J. Fang and J. Fang and Kun Fang and Chunsheng Feng and Hansheng Feng and Lei Feng and S. H. Feng and X. T. Feng and Y. Feng and Y. L. Feng and S. Gabici and Bo Gao and C. D. Gao and Qi Gao and W. Gao and W. K. Gao and M. M. Ge and Li‐Sheng Geng and Gwenael Giacinti and G. H. Gong and Q. B. Gou and M. H. Gu and Fulai Guo and Xiaoguang Guo and Yi-Qing Guo and Y. Y. Guo and Y. A. Han and M. Zahid Hasan and H. H. He and H. N. He and Jiawei He and Yan He and Y. K. Hor and Bowen Hou and C. Hou and Xin Hou and Haibing Hu and Q. Hu and S. C. Hu and Dezhi Huang and T. Q. Huang and W. J. Huang and X. T. Huang and X. Y. Huang and Yeyuan Huang and Xiangdong Ji and H. Y. Jia and Kun Jia and K. Jiang and X. W. Jiang and Z. J. Jiang and Ming Jin and M. M. Kang and I. Karpikov and D. Kuleshov and K. Kurinov and B. B. Li},
  title = {{Discovery of Very High Energy Gamma-Ray Emissions from the Low-luminosity AGN NGC 4278 by LHAASO}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ad5e6d},
}
Figure