Discovery of Delayed Spin-up Behavior Following Two Large Glitches in the Crab Pulsar, and the Statistics of Such Processes

Mingyu Ge, Shuang‐Nan Zhang, F. J. Lu, Tong Li, J. P. Yuan, Xiaoping Zheng, Y. Huang, S. J. Zheng, Yupeng Chen, Zhi Chang, Y. L. Tuo, Qianjia Cheng, Can Güngör, L. M. Song, Y. P. Xu, X. L. Cao, Yutong Chen, Congzhan Liu, Shuo Zhang, Jin‐Lu Qu, Qingcui Bu, Ce Cai, G. Chen, L. Chen, Mengting Chen, Tianxiang Chen, Wei Cui, J. K. Deng, Yongwei Dong, Y. Y. Du, Mingye Fu, G. H. Gao, M. Gao, Y. D. Gu, Ju Guan, Chengcheng Guo, Danxiang Han, L. F. Hao, J. Huo, S. M. Jia, Luhua Jiang, Weichun Jiang, C. J. Jin, Jing Jin, Yan Jin, Ling-Da Kong, Bing Li, Di Li, Cheng-Kui Li, Gang Li, Ming Li, Wei Li, X. Li, Yong Li, Z. W. Li, Ziyi Liu, X. H. Liang, J. Y. Liao, Gang Liu, Haibo Liu, Xinye Liu, Y. N. Liu, Bo Lü, X. F. Lu, Q. Luo, T. Luo, Xiang Ma, Bin Meng, Y. Nang, J. Y. Nie, G. Ou, Na Sai, R. C. Shang, X. Y. Song, Liang Sun, Y. Tan, Lian Tao, Chun Wang, G. F. Wang, Juan Wang, Jingbo Wang, Meng Wang, Na Wang, W. S. Wang, Yue Wang, Yusen Wang, X. Y. Wen, Z. G. Wen, Boyu Wu, Bowen Wu, M. Wu, G. Xiao, Shuo Xiao, S. L. XiongThe Astrophysical Journal 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Astronomers have discovered a "delayed spin-up" behavior in two previously unanalyzed glitches of the Crab pulsar, bringing the total number of such observed events to five. This finding, combined with a statistical analysis, suggests that these delayed spin-up processes might be a common, albeit often too brief, feature of all pulsar glitches, offering new insights into the internal physics of neutron stars.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pulsar glitches are sudden, unexplained jumps in a pulsar's rotation frequency and its rate of slowing down. While these events offer a unique window into the extreme physics of neutron stars, their exact cause and the detailed processes involved remain poorly understood. A key challenge is that the rapid evolution of a glitch often happens too quickly to be fully captured by observations, making it difficult to resolve the precise sequence of events. Some glitches exhibit a "delayed spin-up" phase, where the pulsar briefly speeds up after the initial spin-down jump, before settling into its normal recovery. This phenomenon has been observed in only a few large glitches, leaving open the question of whether it's a rare occurrence or a more universal, but often undetectable, aspect of glitch behavior. This paper aims to address this by investigating two specific Crab pulsar glitches (from 2004 and 2011) that were not previously analyzed for this delayed spin-up behavior, and by performing a statistical study of all known glitches exhibiting this characteristic.

Methods

The researchers employed a "coherent timing analysis" technique, which involves precisely measuring the arrival times of pulses from the Crab pulsar across various observatories. This allows them to model the pulsar's spin evolution with high accuracy. They used data from multiple instruments, including radio telescopes (Nanshan 25-m, Kunming 40-m), X-ray telescopes (RXTE, INTEGRAL, Insight-HXMT), and gamma-ray detectors (Fermi-LAT/GBM).

The core of their analysis involved fitting the observed spin frequency and its derivative to a model that includes several components: a rapid initial spin-up (C1), a delayed spin-up (C2), and a normal exponential recovery (C3), along with a permanent change (C4). The key innovation here is the detailed investigation of the C2 component, the delayed spin-up process, for the two newly analyzed glitches. They also performed a statistical analysis of the parameters of these delayed spin-up events (like their amplitudes and time scales) and compared them to glitches that do not show this behavior.

Datasets

The study utilized observational data from several major astronomical facilities:

  • Radio Telescopes: Nanshan 25-m radio telescope (Xinjiang, China) and Kunming 40-m radio telescope (Yunnan, China).
  • X-ray Telescopes: Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE), INTEGRAL, and the Hard X-ray Modulation Telescope (Insight-HXMT).
  • Gamma-ray Detectors: Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT) and Fermi Gamma-ray Burst Monitor (GBM).
  • Archival Data: Data from Jodrell Bank Observatory was also referenced.

The paper focuses on five specific glitches of the Crab pulsar (designated G1-G5, occurring in 1989, 1996, 2004, 2011, and 2017). The analysis of G3, G4, and G5 is presented in detail, with G1 and G2 parameters taken from previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Delayed Spin-up is Not Unique: The discovery of delayed spin-up in the 2004 and 2011 Crab pulsar glitches strongly suggests this phenomenon is not limited to the largest or most prominent glitches.
  • A Common, Yet Elusive, Feature: The statistical analysis indicates that the characteristics of these five glitches with observed delayed spin-up are similar to other glitches, except for their larger amplitudes. This leads to the hypothesis that delayed spin-up might be a common feature of all glitches, but is often too short-lived to be detected with current observational cadences.
  • Interconnected Glitch Components: The study found significant positive correlations between the amplitudes and time scales of the delayed spin-up (C2) and the subsequent recovery (C3) processes, as well as the permanent spin frequency change (Δνg). This suggests a deeper physical connection between these different phases of a glitch.
  • Crab Pulsar as a Unique Laboratory: The Crab pulsar continues to stand out with its strong correlation between spin frequency jump (Δν) and spin-down rate change (|Δi|), a feature not seen in other pulsars like Vela. This uniqueness, coupled with the observed delayed spin-up, points to specific internal conditions within the Crab pulsar.

Key Results

  • Two New Delayed Spin-up Glitches Identified: The glitches in the Crab pulsar from 2004 (G3) and 2011 (G4) were found to exhibit delayed spin-up behavior.
  • Time Scales of Delayed Spin-up: The time scales (τ1) for these newly identified delayed spin-up processes were measured as 1.7 ± 0.8 days for G3 and 1.6 ± 0.4 days for G4.
  • Largest Glitch (G5) Refined: The largest glitch in 2017 (G5) was re-analyzed, with its initial rising time constrained to be less than 0.48 hours.
  • Correlations Found: For the five glitches with observed delayed spin-up, strong positive correlations were found between:
  • The amplitudes of the delayed spin-up (Δvd1) and recovery (Δvd2) processes.
  • Their respective time scales (τ1 and τ2).
  • The permanent change in spin frequency (Δνp) and the total frequency step (Δvg).
  • No Correlation with Non-Delayed Glitches: The distribution of Δvg and |Δi| for these five glitches is similar to those without detected delayed spin-up, suggesting they are fundamentally similar but with larger amplitudes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Observational Cadence: The primary limitation highlighted is the observational cadence of past and even current observations. The study suggests that many glitches might have delayed spin-up components that are too short to be detected, especially for smaller glitches.
  • Need for Higher Cadence Data: The authors emphasize the critical need for more high-cadence observations of the Crab pulsar in the future to better detect and characterize these potentially short-lived delayed spin-up processes.
  • Statistical Study of Smaller Glitches: Further analysis of existing data for smaller glitches is recommended to search for evidence of delayed spin-up processes with even shorter time scales.
  • Understanding Neutron Star Interior: The correlations found between glitch parameters are expected to provide valuable constraints on the internal structure and physics of neutron stars, which will be a focus of future theoretical and observational work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Glitches correspond to sudden jumps of rotation frequency ( ν ) and its derivative ( ) of pulsars, the origin of which remains not well understood yet, partly because the jump processes of most glitches are not well time-resolved. There are three large glitches of the Crab pulsar, detected in 1989, 1996, and 2017, which were found to have delayed spin-up processes before the normal recovery processes. Here we report two additional glitches of this pulsar that occurred in 2004 and 2011 for which we discovered delayed spin-up processes, and present refined parameters of the largest glitch, which occurred in 2017. The initial rising time of the glitch is determined as <0.48 hr. The two glitches that occurred in 2004 and 2011 had delayed spin-up time scales ( τ 1 ) of 1.7 ± 0.8 days and 1.6 ± 0.4 days, respectively. We also carried out a statistical study of these five glitches with observed spin-up processes. We find that the Δ ν versus relation of these five glitches is similar to those with no detected delayed spin-up process, indicating that they are similar to the others in nature except that they have larger amplitudes. For these five glitches, the amplitudes of the delayed spin-up process ( ) and recovery process (Δ ν d2 ), their time scales ( τ 1 , τ 2 ), and permanent changes in spin frequency (Δ ν p ) and total frequency step (Δ ν g ) have positive correlations. From these correlations, we suggest that the delayed spin-up processes are common for all glitches, but are too short and thus difficult to be detected for most glitches.
BibTeX
@article{ge2020discovery,
  author = {Mingyu Ge and Shuang‐Nan Zhang and F. J. Lu and Tong Li and J. P. Yuan and Xiaoping Zheng and Y. Huang and S. J. Zheng and Yupeng Chen and Zhi Chang and Y. L. Tuo and Qianjia Cheng and Can Güngör and L. M. Song and Y. P. Xu and X. L. Cao and Yutong Chen and Congzhan Liu and Shuo Zhang and Jin‐Lu Qu and Qingcui Bu and Ce Cai and G. Chen and L. Chen and Mengting Chen and Tianxiang Chen and Y. B. Chen and Wei Cui and Wei Cui and J. K. Deng and Yongwei Dong and Y. Y. Du and Mingye Fu and G. H. Gao and H. Gao and M. Gao and Y. D. Gu and Ju Guan and Chengcheng Guo and Danxiang Han and L. F. Hao and J. Huo and S. M. Jia and Luhua Jiang and Weichun Jiang and C. J. Jin and Jing Jin and Yan Jin and Ling-Da Kong and Bing Li and Di Li and Cheng-Kui Li and Gang Li and Ming Li and Wei Li and X. Li and X. B. Li and X. F. Li and Yong Li and Z. W. Li and Z. X. Li and Ziyi Liu and X. H. Liang and J. Y. Liao and Gang Liu and Haibo Liu and Xinye Liu and Y. N. Liu and Bo Lü and X. F. Lu and Q. Luo and T. Luo and Xiang Ma and Bin Meng and Y. Nang and J. Y. Nie and G. Ou and Na Sai and R. C. Shang and X. Y. Song and Liang Sun and Y. Tan and Lian Tao and Chun Wang and G. F. Wang and Juan Wang and Jingbo Wang and Meng Wang and Na Wang and W. S. Wang and Yue Wang and Yusen Wang and X. Y. Wen and Z. G. Wen and Boyu Wu and Bowen Wu and M. Wu and G. Xiao and Shuo Xiao and S. L. Xiong},
  title = {{Discovery of Delayed Spin-up Behavior Following Two Large Glitches in the Crab Pulsar, and the Statistics of Such Processes}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ab8db6},
}
Figure