Discovering new physics in rare kaon decays

Thomas Blum, Peter Boyle, Mattia Bruno, Norman H. Christ, Felix Erben, Xu Feng, Vera Guelpers, Ryan Hill, Raoul Hodgson, Danel Hoying, Taku Izubuchi, Yong-Chull Jang, Luchang Jin, Chulwoo Jung, Joe Karpie, Christopher Kelly, Christoph Lehner, Antonin Portelli, Christopher Sachrajda, Amarjit Soni, Masaaki Tomii, Bigeng Wang, Tianle WangarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

This white paper, authored by the RBC and UKQCD collaborations, provides a roadmap for using Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) to hunt for "New Physics" through the study of rare kaon decays. By simulating the strong force on a discrete spacetime grid, researchers are reaching a level of precision that allows them to test the Standard Model at energy scales far beyond the reach of the Large Hadron Collider.

TL;DR

Lattice QCD is entering a high-precision era, allowing researchers to predict rare kaon decays with enough accuracy to reveal discrepancies that might signal new particles or forces. These "tiny laboratories" provide a window into physics at energy scales as high as 1,000 TeV, potentially guiding the next generation of particle physics experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics is remarkably successful, but we know it’s incomplete—it doesn't explain dark matter or the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe. To find what lies beyond, physicists look for "rare" processes where the SM predictions are very small or suppressed. Kaon ($K$ meson) decays are perfect candidates because they are highly sensitive to the weak interaction and CP violation (the difference between matter and antimatter).

However, kaons are made of quarks bound by the strong force (QCD). Calculating these strong-force effects is notoriously difficult because QCD becomes "non-perturbative" at low energies—you can't just use simple pen-and-paper approximations. This theoretical uncertainty has historically been the bottleneck. This paper outlines how the RBC and UKQCD collaborations are using massive supercomputing power to overcome this hurdle.

Methods

The primary tool is Lattice QCD, which discretizes four-dimensional spacetime into a grid (lattice). By placing quarks on the sites and gluons on the links, the complex path integrals of QCD can be solved numerically using Monte Carlo simulations.

Key technical advances discussed include:

  • G-parity and Periodic Boundary Conditions: Novel ways to handle pions in a finite "box" to extract physical decay amplitudes.
  • RI/SMOM Renormalization: A sophisticated scheme to connect the "bare" numbers calculated on a computer to the physical "renormalized" values used in the continuum.
  • 4-Flavor Simulations: Moving from 3-flavor models (up, down, strange) to 4-flavor models that explicitly include the charm quark, which is essential for reducing systematic errors in mass difference calculations ($\Delta M_K$).
  • Exascale Computing: The paper forecasts the need for massive computational resources, citing requirements in the range of hundreds of "Exaflops-hours" on machines like NERSC’s Perlmutter.

Datasets

In Lattice QCD, "datasets" refer to gauge configurations—snapshots of the gluon fields generated via Markov Chain Monte Carlo. The paper references several specific ensembles:

  • Lattice Sizes: Ranging from $32^3 \times 64$ up to $128^3 \times 512$.
  • Inverse Lattice Spacings ($1/a$): Values from 1.38 GeV to 5.51 GeV, where higher values represent a finer grid and better resolution of short-distance physics.
  • Sample Sizes: For example, the calculation of direct CP violation ($\epsilon'$) utilized 741 Monte Carlo samples to achieve a 10% statistical error.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The 1,000 TeV Window: Because rare kaon decays involve "loop" diagrams where heavy, undiscovered particles could circulate, they are sensitive to physics at energy scales (1,000 TeV) much higher than the LHC's direct reach (~13 TeV).
  • The "Charm" Bottleneck: For the $K_L - K_S$ mass difference, the charm quark mass is the dominant source of error. Explicitly including the charm quark in the lattice grid is the next frontier for precision.
  • Isospin Breaking is No Longer Negligible: As precision approaches the 1% level, tiny effects—like the mass difference between up and down quarks and the influence of electromagnetism (QED)—must be included in the simulations.
  • Long-Distance Dominance: While some decays are "short-distance" (easy to calculate), others are "long-distance" (messy and hadronic). Lattice QCD is uniquely capable of tackling these messy parts where other theoretical methods fail.

Key Results

  • Direct CP Violation ($\epsilon'$): Recent lattice results for $Re(\epsilon'/\epsilon)$ are consistent with experimental measurements, a major milestone after 25 years of effort.
  • Mass Difference ($\Delta M_K$): A preliminary lattice result of $5.8(0.6)_{stat}(2.3)_{sys} \times 10^{-12}$ MeV was reported. While the systematic error is still large (~40%), it represents a path toward a 5% accuracy goal by 2026.
  • Rare Decays ($K \to \pi\nu\bar{\nu}$): The paper targets a 30% total uncertainty for these decays in the near term, providing a crucial cross-check for the NA62 experiment at CERN.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several steep challenges:

  1. Computational Cost: Moving to finer lattices (to better simulate the charm quark) increases the cost exponentially, requiring the world's most powerful supercomputers.
  2. Disconnected Diagrams: Some calculations involve "vacuum" fluctuations that are extremely noisy and require massive statistics to resolve.
  3. Three-Pion States: Future high-precision work will need to account for decays into three pions, a significantly more complex multi-particle problem that remains an "unsolved problem" in some contexts.

The paper concludes that while the obstacles are substantial, they are "surmountable," with a goal of reducing errors below 10% for most key processes within the next decade.

Summary updated

Abstract

The decays and mixing of $K$ mesons are remarkably sensitive to the weak interactions of quarks and leptons at high energies. They provide important tests of the standard model at both first and second order in the Fermi constant $G_F$ and offer a window into possible new phenomena at energies as high as 1,000 TeV. These possibilities become even more compelling as the growing capabilities of lattice QCD make high-precision standard model predictions possible. Here we discuss and attempt to forecast some of these capabilities.
BibTeX
@misc{blum2022discovering,
  author = {Thomas Blum and Peter Boyle and Mattia Bruno and Norman H. Christ and Felix Erben and Xu Feng and Vera Guelpers and Ryan Hill and Raoul Hodgson and Danel Hoying and Taku Izubuchi and Yong-Chull Jang and Luchang Jin and Chulwoo Jung and Joe Karpie and Christopher Kelly and Christoph Lehner and Antonin Portelli and Christopher Sachrajda and Amarjit Soni and Masaaki Tomii and Bigeng Wang and Tianle Wang},
  title = {{Discovering new physics in rare kaon decays}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.10998},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.10998},
}

Loading related content...

Figure