Discovering Multi-omic Biomarkers for Prostate Cancer Severity Using Machine Learning

Jia Zhou, Kahn RhrissorrakraiarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper presents a machine learning framework to identify multi-omic biomarkers (RNA, mutations, and copy number variations) that correlate with prostate cancer severity. By leveraging Random Forests and Transformer-based deep learning on TCGA data, the researchers identified specific genes like COL1A1 and SFRP4 and cell-cycle pathways that could provide an objective, quantitative "second opinion" to traditional, subjective Gleason grading.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "gold standard" for determining prostate cancer severity is the Gleason score, which involves a pathologist grading tissue samples based on cellular patterns. However, this process is notoriously subjective; human error and variability between pathologists can lead to over- or under-grading, resulting in either unnecessary, invasive treatments or insufficient care.

The authors address the need for objective, molecular-level biomarkers that can validate clinical grading. By moving beyond single-modality studies (which might only look at gene expression), this paper explores how combining different "omics" layers—transcriptomics (RNA-seq), genomics (mutations), and epigenomics (copy number)—can create a more robust picture of disease progression.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged computational approach:

  1. Random Forest (RF) Classifiers: Used as the primary workhorse for both classification and feature selection. The authors used the Gini importance metric and z-scores to rank which genes were most "informative" for predicting specific Gleason scores.
  2. T-GEM (Transformer for Gene Expression Modeling): A newer, interpretable deep learning architecture. Unlike standard neural networks, T-GEM uses self-attention mechanisms to capture complex gene-gene interactions, treating gene expression data as an unordered set rather than a simple vector.
  3. Bioinformatics Enrichment: To ensure the ML results made biological sense, they performed Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA) and hypergeometric tests to see if the high-ranking genes clustered into known biological pathways (like the cell cycle).

The study also compared "all-gene" models against models restricted to the Cancer Gene Census (CGC)—a curated list of 576 genes known to drive cancer—to see if focusing on "the usual suspects" improved interpretability or accuracy.

Datasets

The study utilized the The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Prostate Adenocarcinoma (PRAD) dataset, which includes data from approximately 500 patients.

  • Data Modalities: RNA-seq (19,938 genes), Mutation data (18,701 genes), and Copy Number (CN) data (59,104 elements).
  • Preprocessing: RNA data was $log_2$ transformed; mutations were filtered to exclude "silent" changes that don't affect protein function; and CN data was $log_2$ normalized.
  • Challenge: The dataset is highly imbalanced, with Gleason 7 and 9 representing the vast majority of samples, while Gleason 10 was so rare it had to be excluded.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transcriptomics is King: Across most experiments, RNA-seq data was significantly more predictive of cancer severity than mutational load or copy number variations. This suggests that how genes are being expressed is a more immediate indicator of severity than the underlying "blueprints" (DNA).
  • The "Gleason 8" Difficulty: Models consistently struggled to predict Gleason 8 scores compared to 6, 7, or 9. This highlights a potential biological "gray area" or transition state in prostate cancer that is harder to define with current molecular features.
  • Specific Biomarkers for Specific Grades: The study found that certain genes are "specialists." For example, FANCA (involved in DNA repair) was a top feature for predicting Gleason 6, while COL1A1 (collagen production) was a heavy hitter for the more aggressive Gleason 7 and 9.
  • Cell Cycle Dominance: The most significant pathways identified were related to the cell cycle (G2M checkpoint, E2F targets, and PLK1). This confirms that as the Gleason score increases, the primary biological driver is the loss of control over cellular replication.

Key Results

  • Classification Performance: The Random Forest models achieved median F1-scores of 0.67 for Gleason 6 (using mutation data), 0.70 for Gleason 7 (using RNA), and a high of 0.80 for Gleason 9 (using RNA).
  • Multi-omic Synergy: Combining RNA and Copy Number data improved the F1-score for Gleason 7 to 0.75, demonstrating that multi-omic integration can outperform single-modality models.
  • T-GEM Performance: The Transformer model reached a test accuracy of 0.644. While it didn't vastly outperform the Random Forest, it successfully identified many of the same key biomarkers (like BGN and SFRP4), providing cross-method validation.
  • Validated Biomarkers: Several identified genes, such as ZFHX3 (a tumor suppressor) and EZH2 (a known oncogene), were consistent with existing literature, while others like USP6 were highlighted as potential new targets for Gleason 8.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is data scarcity. While 500 patients is a large cohort for traditional biology, it is relatively small for deep learning models like T-GEM, which often require thousands of samples to converge reliably. This likely explains the high variability in T-GEM's performance across training epochs.

The authors suggest that future work should involve:

  1. Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs): To synthesize more training data to help deep learning models learn better.
  2. Clinical Validation: Moving these identified gene signatures from "in silico" (on the computer) to "in vitro" (in the lab) to confirm their utility as diagnostic tools.
  3. Gleason 8 Focus: Investigating why this specific grade is so difficult to model molecularly.

Summary updated

Abstract

Prostate cancer is the second most common form of cancer, though most patients have a positive prognosis with many experiencing long-term survival with current treatment options. Yet, each treatment carries varying levels of intensity and side effects, therefore determining the severity of prostate cancer is an important criteria in selecting the most appropriate treatment. The Gleason score is the most common grading system used to judge the severity of prostate cancer, but much of the grading process can be affected by human error or subjectivity. Finding biomarkers for prostate cancer Gleason scores in a quantitative, machine-driven approach could enable pathologists to validate their assessment of a patient cancer sample by examining such biomarkers. In our study, we identified biomarkers from multi-omics data using machine learning, statistical tools, and deep learning to train models against the Gleason score and capture the most important features that could potentially serve as biomarkers for the Gleason score. Through this process, multiple genes, such as COL1A1 and SFRP4, and cell cycle pathways, such as G2M checkpoint, E2F targets, and the PLK1 pathways, were found to be important predictive features for particular Gleason scores. The combination of these analytical methods shows potential for more accurate grading of prostate cancer, and greater understanding of biological processes behind prostate cancer severity that could provide additional therapeutic targets.
BibTeX
@misc{zhou2024discovering,
  author = {Jia Zhou and Kahn Rhrissorrakrai},
  title = {{Discovering Multi-omic Biomarkers for Prostate Cancer Severity Using Machine Learning}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2410.22387},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.22387},
}
Figure