Discovering hydrothermalism from Afar: In Situ methane instrumentation and change-point detection for decision-making

Victoria Preston, Genevieve Flaspohler, Jason Kapit, William Pardis, Sarah Youngs, Donald E. Martocello, Nicholas Roy, Peter R. Girguis, Scott D. Wankel, Anna P. M. MichelFrontiers in Earth Science 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Seafloor hydrothermalism plays a critical role in fundamental interactions between geochemical and biological processes in the deep ocean. A significant number of hydrothermal vents are hypothesized to exist, but many of these remain undiscovered due in part to the difficulty of detecting hydrothermalism using standard sensors on rosettes towed in the water column or robotic platforms performing surveys. Here, we use in situ methane sensors to complement standard sensing technology for hydrothermalism discovery and compare sensors on a towed rosette and an autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV) during a 17 km long transect in the Northern Guaymas Basin in the Gulf of California. This transect spatially intersected with a known hydrothermally active venting site. These data show that methane signalled possible hydrothermal-activity 1.5–3 km laterally (100–150 m vertically) from a known vent. Methane as a signal for hydrothermalism performed similarly to standard turbidity sensors (plume detection 2.2–3.3 km from reference source), and more sensitively and clearly than temperature, salinity, and oxygen instruments which readily respond to physical mixing in background seawater. We additionally introduce change-point detection algorithms—streaming cross-correlation and regime identification—as a means of real-time hydrothermalism discovery and discuss related data supervision technologies that could be used in planning, executing, and monitoring explorative surveys for hydrothermalism.

Introduction

Locating hydrothermal vents on the seafloor is a significant challenge, often described as a "needle in a haystack" problem. While these vents are critical hotspots for deep-sea biological and geochemical activity, their physical footprint is small relative to the vast ocean floor. Discovery typically relies on detecting "plumes"—rising clouds of mineral-rich, chemically distinct water.

Traditional tracers such as temperature, salinity, and dissolved oxygen are frequently used but suffer from high background noise due to rapid mixing with ambient seawater. While turbidity (water cloudiness) is a reliable indicator, it lacks chemical specificity. This study investigates whether methane, a major byproduct of many hydrothermal systems, can serve as a more sensitive and unambiguous long-range tracer for vent discovery.

Methods and Experimental Design

The research team conducted a 17 km transect in the Northern Guaymas Basin, Gulf of California, during the RR2107 expedition in November 2021. The survey utilized two distinct platforms to capture the hydrothermal signal: the Autonomous Underwater Vehicle (AUV) Sentry and a ship-towed sensor rosette.

Schematic of the hydrothermal plume structure and the deployment of AUV Sentry and the towed Rosette.

Instrumentation

The study introduced two novel in situ methane sensors:

  • SAGE (Sensor for Aqueous Gases in the Environment): Utilizes infrared absorption spectroscopy via hollow-core optical fiber.
  • Pythia: A deep-sea cavity ringdown spectrometer (rt-CRDS) designed for high-sensitivity gas concentration measurements.

These were deployed alongside standard CTD (Conductivity, Temperature, Depth) sensors, oxygen optodes, and turbidity sensors (OBS and transmissometers).

Change-Point Detection Algorithms

To move beyond simple threshold-based detection, the authors implemented change-point detection algorithms. By using streaming cross-correlation and regime identification (via the ruptures library), the system identifies shifts in the relationship between multiple sensor streams—such as methane and temperature—to pinpoint the transition from background water into a hydrothermal plume.

Map of the transect area showing the spatial relationship between the active ridge source and the survey legs of Sentry and the Rosette.

Key Results

Detection Range and Sensitivity

Methane proved to be a highly effective long-range tracer, signaling hydrothermal activity between 1.5 and 3 km laterally from the known vent source, and 100–150 m vertically. This performance was comparable to turbidity sensors (2.2–3.3 km range) but provided a significantly higher signal-to-noise ratio than physical tracers like temperature or salinity, which were often obscured by background mixing.

Multi-Sensor Correlation

The study demonstrated that single-sensor analysis is often insufficient. During "Leg 2" of the transect (closer to the source), methane and turbidity exhibited a strong positive correlation (0.8). This multi-sensor alignment provides a robust confirmation of the plume's presence, allowing for more confident decision-making during exploration.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the results are promising, a primary limitation is sensor response time. The SAGE sensor has a lag of approximately 12 minutes, while Pythia requires ~35 minutes. For a moving AUV, this delay means the vehicle may be several kilometers past a plume "hit" before the data is fully processed.

Future work focuses on "on-the-wire" integration, where these algorithms are processed onboard the AUV in real-time. This would enable the vehicle to autonomously alter its mission path—for instance, by circling back to investigate a detected chemical anomaly. Additionally, further testing is required in different geological settings, such as sediment-starved mid-ocean ridges, where methane concentrations may be lower than in the sediment-rich Guaymas Basin.

Summary updated

Abstract

Seafloor hydrothermalism plays a critical role in fundamental interactions between geochemical and biological processes in the deep ocean. A significant number of hydrothermal vents are hypothesized to exist, but many of these remain undiscovered due in part to the difficulty of detecting hydrothermalism using standard sensors on rosettes towed in the water column or robotic platforms performing surveys. Here, we use in situ methane sensors to complement standard sensing technology for hydrothermalism discovery and compare sensors on a towed rosette and an autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV) during a 17 km long transect in the Northern Guaymas Basin in the Gulf of California. This transect spatially intersected with a known hydrothermally active venting site. These data show that methane signalled possible hydrothermal-activity 1.5–3 km laterally (100–150 m vertically) from a known vent. Methane as a signal for hydrothermalism performed similarly to standard turbidity sensors (plume detection 2.2–3.3 km from reference source), and more sensitively and clearly than temperature, salinity, and oxygen instruments which readily respond to physical mixing in background seawater. We additionally introduce change-point detection algorithms—streaming cross-correlation and regime identification—as a means of real-time hydrothermalism discovery and discuss related data supervision technologies that could be used in planning, executing, and monitoring explorative surveys for hydrothermalism.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{preston2022discovering,
  author = {Victoria Preston and Genevieve Flaspohler and Jason Kapit and William Pardis and Sarah Youngs and Donald E. Martocello and Nicholas Roy and Peter R. Girguis and Scott D. Wankel and Anna P. M. Michel},
  title = {{Discovering hydrothermalism from Afar: In Situ methane instrumentation and change-point detection for decision-making}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.984355},
}
Figure