Discarding Functional Residues from the Substitution Table Improves Predictions of Active Sites within Three-Dimensional Structures

Sungsam Gong, Tom L. BlundellPLoS 2008 · DOI

Abstract

Substitutions of individual amino acids in proteins are subject to varying evolutionary restraints based on their structural and functional roles. Environment Specific Substitution Tables (ESSTs) describe these patterns by considering local environments, such as secondary structure and solvent accessibility. However, including functional residues in the calculation of these tables can introduce inconsistencies. This study demonstrates that discarding functional residues—specifically those involved in protein-protein, protein-nucleic acid, and protein-ligand interactions, as well as catalytic activity—improves the accuracy of active site predictions. Using the CRESCENDO program, the new methodology increased the Z-score at active site residues by 98% and identified 16% more active sites compared to previous ESSTs. These findings suggest that removing functional "noise" allows substitution tables to better reflect purely structural restraints.

Introduction: Separating Structural and Functional Signals

A central challenge in structural biology is the accurate prediction of protein active sites. Traditionally, these sites are identified by searching for highly conserved amino acids. However, evolutionary conservation is driven by two distinct pressures: structural stability (maintaining the protein's fold) and functional necessity (enabling catalysis or binding).

Standard Environment Specific Substitution Tables (ESSTs) serve as "rulebooks" for expected amino acid variability in specific structural contexts. A significant limitation of traditional ESSTs is that they incorporate data from all residues, including those in functional sites. This "contaminates" the baseline; if the model already expects functional sites to be highly conserved, these sites become harder to distinguish from the structural background. This research addresses this issue by intentionally "masking" known functional residues during the construction of the substitution tables.

Methodology: A "Less is More" Approach to Data Curation

The researchers developed a protocol to build "cleaned" ESSTs by identifying and discarding functional residues from training alignments.

Categorization and Mapping

Functional residues were classified into four categories:

  1. Catalytic sites (enzymatic activity)
  2. Protein–protein interactions (PPI)
  3. Protein–nucleic acid interactions (PNI)
  4. Protein–ligand interactions (PLI)

To ensure high-quality data, a "double-map" protocol was implemented to align sequence-based functional annotations from UniProt with 3D structural data from the Protein Data Bank (PDB).

Training and Benchmarking

The study utilized a massive structural library based on SCOP (v1.71), defining 1,187 protein families for table construction. Functional data was sourced from the Catalytic Site Atlas (CSA), UniProt, InterPare, and BIPA. A "blind" test set of 73 SCOP families was excluded from training to validate the predictive power of the new tables.

Predictions were performed using CRESCENDO, which calculates a Z-score by comparing observed conservation in a protein family to the expected conservation predicted by the ESST. A high Z-score indicates "extra" conservation not explained by structural constraints alone, signaling a potential functional site.

Results: Enhanced Sensitivity and Statistical Significance

The removal of functional residues significantly sharpened the contrast between structural background and functional signal.

Improved Prediction Metrics

The new methodology yielded dramatic improvements in active site identification:

  • Z-Score Boost: The average Z-score at active site residues increased by 98%.
  • Increased Sensitivity: The model identified 16% more active sites than the previous gold-standard ESST (Shi et al., 2001).
  • Better Discrimination: Specific matrix types (e.g., "ALL-B" and "ALL-C") that masked combinations of functional residues consistently outperformed non-masking models, particularly in identifying complex sites like the cysteine protease catalytic triad.
Figure 6: Radar plot comparing amino acid substitution patterns across different ESST versions. The 'OLD(J)' line represents the previous standard, while other lines show the impact of masking different functional residue categories.

The Hierarchy of Conservation

The study confirmed that catalytic residues are the most conserved, followed by ligand-binding sites. While protein-protein interaction (PPI) sites are more "neutral" and harder to distinguish from structural background, masking them still improved the model's ability to identify them. This suggests that functional constraints are distinct from structural ones across all categories.

Discussion and Future Directions

By removing functional "noise," the new ESSTs more accurately reflect the physical constraints of protein folding. However, the authors noted a relatively high number of false positives. These may not necessarily be errors; some may represent residues critical for the local architecture of the active site or currently undiscovered functional sites.

Future work could involve expanding the prediction window beyond the "first cluster" of residues to better balance sensitivity and precision. Additionally, incorporating dynamic constraints—such as allostery or post-translational modifications—could further refine the evolutionary models.

Conclusion

Discarding functional residues from the calculation of substitution tables provides a cleaner structural baseline, significantly enhancing our ability to predict active sites. This methodology demonstrates that understanding what to exclude from a model can be just as important as what to include when attempting to isolate biological signals from complex data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Substitutions of individual amino acids in proteins may be under very different evolutionary restraints depending on their structural and functional roles. The Environment Specific Substitution Table (ESST) describes the pattern of substitutions in terms of amino acid location within elements of secondary structure, solvent accessibility, and the existence of hydrogen bonds between side chains and neighbouring amino acid residues. Clearly amino acids that have very different local environments in their functional state compared to those in the protein analysed will give rise to inconsistencies in the calculation of amino acid substitution tables. Here, we describe how the calculation of ESSTs can be improved by discarding the functional residues from the calculation of substitution tables. Four categories of functions are examined in this study: protein-protein interactions, protein-nucleic acid interactions, protein-ligand interactions, and catalytic activity of enzymes. Their contributions to residue conservation are measured and investigated. We test our new ESSTs using the program CRESCENDO, designed to predict functional residues by exploiting knowledge of amino acid substitutions, and compare the benchmark results with proteins whose functions have been defined experimentally. The new methodology increases the Z-score by 98% at the active site residues and finds 16% more active sites compared with the old ESST. We also find that discarding amino acids responsible for protein-protein interactions helps in the prediction of those residues although they are not as conserved as the residues of active sites. Our methodology can make the substitution tables better reflect and describe the substitution patterns of amino acids that are under structural restraints only.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2008discarding,
  author = {Sungsam Gong and Tom L. Blundell},
  title = {{Discarding Functional Residues from the Substitution Table Improves Predictions of Active Sites within Three-Dimensional Structures}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000179},
}
Figure