Disability disparities in STEM: Gaps in salaries and representation for doctorate recipients with disabilities in the U.S., 2019

Franz Castro, Elizabeth A. Stuart, Jennifer A. Deal, Varshini Varadaraj, Bonnielin K. SwenormedRxiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

There is a significant paucity of data examining disparities in salary and representation for disabled scientists, which is essential for advancing inclusion and equity in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM). This study analyzed cross-sectional data from the 2019 Survey of Doctorate Recipients to compare salaries between doctorate recipients with and without disabilities employed in STEM (N = 704,013). Using propensity score weighting to ensure balanced comparisons across socioeconomic, degree, and job-related characteristics, the study further examined academic career milestones. Results indicate that doctorate recipients with early-onset disabilities (identified <25 years of age) earned $10,580 less per year than non-disabled workers, a gap that widened to $14,360 within academia. Furthermore, academics with disabilities were significantly underrepresented in higher faculty ranks, tenure, and leadership positions. These findings underscore a critical need for expanded efforts to foster inclusion and provide equal opportunities for career advancement in STEM.

Introduction

While the STEM community has increasingly prioritized diversity regarding gender and race, disability remains a frequently overlooked dimension of the equity conversation. Despite the protections of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), structural barriers persist even for those who have reached the highest levels of educational attainment. This research addresses a critical gap in the literature: if two scientists possess the same degree, work in the same field, and have comparable years of experience, does the presence of a disability still result in lower compensation and fewer promotions?

Methodology

The researchers employed a cross-sectional analysis using Propensity Score Weighting (PSW), a statistical technique designed to mimic a controlled experiment within an observational study.

To ensure the groups were comparable, the team used Generalized Boosted Models (GBM)—a machine learning approach—to calculate weights. These weights balanced the "disabled" and "non-disabled" cohorts across a wide array of covariates, including sex, age, race, marital status, doctoral field, job field, and geographic region. By combining these weights with linear regression and sandwich variance estimators, the authors achieved a "doubly robust" estimation of salary differences.

Crucially, the study distinguished between two groups:

  1. Early-onset disability: Identified before age 25, typically before or during the early stages of the professional pipeline.
  2. Late-onset disability: Identified at age 25 or later, often occurring after a career trajectory has been established.

Data Sources

The study utilized the 2019 Survey of Doctorate Recipients (SDR), a biennial census conducted by the National Science Foundation (NSF). The SDR tracks individuals who received U.S. research doctorates in science, engineering, or health fields. The raw data included 80,882 respondents, representing a weighted total of approximately 1.15 million doctorate holders. The primary analysis focused on the 704,013 individuals currently employed in STEM within the United States.

Key Findings

The Hidden Wage Gap

The most significant disparities were found among those with early-onset disabilities. These individuals earn an average of **$10,580 less per year** than their non-disabled peers ($p < 0.0001$). This suggests that structural barriers encountered early in the educational pipeline—and potential disadvantages in negotiating initial entry-level salaries—compound over the course of a career.

In the academic sector, this disparity is even more pronounced, with the salary gap widening to **$14,360 less per year** ($p < 0.0001$). Interestingly, while scientists with late-onset disabilities also showed lower salaries, the differences did not reach statistical significance. This may be because these individuals often acquire disabilities after they have already secured professional rank, tenure, and established salary trajectories.

The Academic Glass Ceiling

The data reveals a precipitous drop in the representation of disabled scientists as they move up the academic ladder. While researchers with disabilities are present at the Instructor and Lecturer levels, they are significantly less likely to hold senior positions.

  • Faculty Rank: Only 1.5% of Full Professors had early-onset disabilities, compared to 2.1% of Instructors/Lecturers.
  • Tenure and Leadership: Academics with disabilities were significantly less likely to hold tenure ($p = 0.0004$) or serve in high-level leadership roles such as Deans or Presidents ($p < 0.0001$).

Discussion and Limitations

The authors posit a "two-sided attrition" model: younger disabled scientists face structural barriers to entry, while older disabled scientists face "retirement pressure" due to inaccessible workplaces and cumbersome processes for securing accommodations.

However, the study notes several limitations. The SDR uses a Census Bureau definition of disability that focuses on physical and sensory limitations, excluding psychological, learning, and behavioral disorders. This likely leads to an underestimate of the true disparity. Additionally, the study is subject to "survivor bias," as it only accounts for those currently in the STEM workforce, ignoring the 36.7% of doctorate holders who may have exited the workforce due to disability-related barriers.

Conclusion

These findings suggest that mere compliance with the ADA is insufficient to ensure equity. The authors advocate for a fundamental shift from "providing accommodations" to "fostering inclusion." This includes moving away from fragmented departmental responsibilities toward centralized, institutional agencies dedicated to accessibility. To truly close the gap, STEM institutions must address the systemic barriers that prevent scientists with disabilities from reaching the highest echelons of their fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction There is paucity of data examining disparities in salary and representation for disabled scientists, which is needed to advance inclusion and equity for people with disabilities in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM). Methods Analyses used cross-sectional data from the 2019 Survey of Doctorate Recipients. We compared salaries between doctorate recipients with and without disabilities who were currently employed in STEM (N = 704,013), but who were otherwise similar on socioeconomic, degree and job-related characteristics, using propensity score weighting to carry out balanced comparisons, and further examined these differences in salary in the subset of doctorate recipients working in STEM at academic institutions (N = 219,413). In the subset of participants working in academia, we examined whether the representation of people with disabilities differed across categories of academic career milestones using chi-square tests (α = 0.05). Results Doctorate recipients working in STEM with early onset disabilities (identified &lt;25 years of age) earned $10,580 less per year than non-disabled workers, and in the subset of academic workers this difference was larger (-$14,360). Salaries appeared lower for people with late onset disabilities as compared to those without, although these differences did not reach statistical significance. We observed an underrepresentation of academics with disabilities at higher faculty ranks (p&lt;0.0001), among Deans/Presidents (p&lt;0.0001) and among those with tenure (p: 0.0004). Conclusion These findings support a need to expand efforts to foster inclusion, provide equal opportunities for career advancement, and improve working conditions for people with disabilities in STEM.
BibTeX
@misc{castro2022disability,
  author = {Franz Castro and Elizabeth A. Stuart and Jennifer A. Deal and Varshini Varadaraj and Bonnielin K. Swenor},
  title = {{Disability disparities in STEM: Gaps in salaries and representation for doctorate recipients with disabilities in the U.S., 2019}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.12.04.22283081},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure